Barliman Butterbur
Worthy Keeper/Bree Roué
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2003
- Messages
- 2,762
This is a terribly important subject. Technically, I am obese, weighing at the moment 229 pounds, although I am handsome and debonair... 
I've been overweight all my life, starting from about 25 (I'm 70 now). I've tried every approach to weight loss you can think of, and they all worked — at first. I've seen my doctor, my nutritionist, I've been to Weight Watchers — you name it, I've done it. In recent years (especially now that my wife is retiring — I so want to spend a long healthy life with her) I have become quite desperate in my quest to lose weight and regain health.
Recently however, I've discovered — finally — what seems to be the truth of it in the form of two books: The China Study by Campbell and Campbell, and Eat to Live by Joe Fuhrman, MD.
The China Study is a book about the findings of the largest nutritional study ever undertaken in the history of medicine. To give you an idea of the size and depth of the study, I'll quote a passage:
"In the early 1970s, the premier of China, Chou EnLai, was dying of cancer. In the grips of this terminal disease, Premier Chou initiated a nationwide survey to collect information about a disease that was not well understood. It was to be a monumental survey for twelve different kinds of cancer for more than 2400 Chinese counties and 880 milliion (96%) of their citizens. The survey was remarkable in many ways. It involved 650,000 workers, the most ambitious biomedical research project ever undertaken."
Prior to this, Colin Campbell (the senior author of the writing team) had done years of hard scientific research on what turned cancer off and on in the body. This is what he found out:
1. As we live our lives, we acquire carcinogens simply as a result of being exposed to the various land/sea/air/food pollutants, and in most cases the body destroys them and/or they simply remain dormant because one's genes have not turned on to produce cancer.
2. They found out through exhaustive longitudinal studies that it is animal protein in dietary amounts that acts as the catalytic agent that turns cancer on and off in the presence of carcinogens (such as aflatoxin for instance). This is extremely provocative science, and the "status quo" scientists (to say nothing of the meat industry) became violently against the findings — and they still are.
3. The author proposes a primary way of eating that protects against all diseases of affluence (cancer, obesity, diabetes, heart disease) acquired through a Western animal-based diet: A whole foods plant-based diet.
After having read the book (400+ pages), with its meticulously listed exhaustive research, there is simply one conclusion: get away from animal protein. Become a vegetarian, a vegan if possible.
I am not stating this to convert anyone reading this post. But I do state the truth. My own (so far) haphazard vegetarianism over the years has, I believe brought me this far alive and as healthy as I am. But my state of health demands big fundamental improvements, and they aren't going to come through drugs or surgery. They must come through something more fundamental, namely: what I choose to put in my mouth, and what I choose not to put in my mouth — along with a program of proper exercise.
The second book is the basic how-to. The Fuhrman book outlines the what and the how of eating a basically vegan diet that is tasty and full of variety (to say nothing of the myriad recipe books of vegetarian cookery of all cultures). It dovetails beautifully as the "practice side" of the "theory side" coming from The China Study. And believe me folks, it's not as if I'd never read anything about nutrition before. I am a lay expert on it. But I know the truth when I see it, and now I know how to save myself. I'll check in from time to time with reports of my progress.
There was only one other time — when I was a smoker — when I had an experience of being overwhelmed by a body of evidence to the extent where every rationale for keeping on doing self-harm was destroyed. That was back in 1963. I was in the student store at UCLA perusing a book called Smoking and the Public Interest, published by the Consumer's Union. That day I stood transfixed in front of the book rack, reading about what smoke does to the lungs and how it creates cancer. There was simply nothing else to do than to stop smoking right then and there, and that's what I did. Over the last several days I've had that kind of experience again of being overwhelmed by a relentless progression of evidence. It's like being sat on by an elephant: you can't ignore it! So — if you want to gain maximum health, switch over to a whole food plant-based way of eating for the rest of your life.
This post is addressed to all those with an open mind. To the rest, I've nothing to say. Nothing gets through to anyone heavily invested in staying with a particular belief. I wish one and all the very best.
Barley
I've been overweight all my life, starting from about 25 (I'm 70 now). I've tried every approach to weight loss you can think of, and they all worked — at first. I've seen my doctor, my nutritionist, I've been to Weight Watchers — you name it, I've done it. In recent years (especially now that my wife is retiring — I so want to spend a long healthy life with her) I have become quite desperate in my quest to lose weight and regain health.
Recently however, I've discovered — finally — what seems to be the truth of it in the form of two books: The China Study by Campbell and Campbell, and Eat to Live by Joe Fuhrman, MD.
The China Study is a book about the findings of the largest nutritional study ever undertaken in the history of medicine. To give you an idea of the size and depth of the study, I'll quote a passage:
"In the early 1970s, the premier of China, Chou EnLai, was dying of cancer. In the grips of this terminal disease, Premier Chou initiated a nationwide survey to collect information about a disease that was not well understood. It was to be a monumental survey for twelve different kinds of cancer for more than 2400 Chinese counties and 880 milliion (96%) of their citizens. The survey was remarkable in many ways. It involved 650,000 workers, the most ambitious biomedical research project ever undertaken."
Prior to this, Colin Campbell (the senior author of the writing team) had done years of hard scientific research on what turned cancer off and on in the body. This is what he found out:
1. As we live our lives, we acquire carcinogens simply as a result of being exposed to the various land/sea/air/food pollutants, and in most cases the body destroys them and/or they simply remain dormant because one's genes have not turned on to produce cancer.
2. They found out through exhaustive longitudinal studies that it is animal protein in dietary amounts that acts as the catalytic agent that turns cancer on and off in the presence of carcinogens (such as aflatoxin for instance). This is extremely provocative science, and the "status quo" scientists (to say nothing of the meat industry) became violently against the findings — and they still are.
3. The author proposes a primary way of eating that protects against all diseases of affluence (cancer, obesity, diabetes, heart disease) acquired through a Western animal-based diet: A whole foods plant-based diet.
After having read the book (400+ pages), with its meticulously listed exhaustive research, there is simply one conclusion: get away from animal protein. Become a vegetarian, a vegan if possible.
I am not stating this to convert anyone reading this post. But I do state the truth. My own (so far) haphazard vegetarianism over the years has, I believe brought me this far alive and as healthy as I am. But my state of health demands big fundamental improvements, and they aren't going to come through drugs or surgery. They must come through something more fundamental, namely: what I choose to put in my mouth, and what I choose not to put in my mouth — along with a program of proper exercise.
The second book is the basic how-to. The Fuhrman book outlines the what and the how of eating a basically vegan diet that is tasty and full of variety (to say nothing of the myriad recipe books of vegetarian cookery of all cultures). It dovetails beautifully as the "practice side" of the "theory side" coming from The China Study. And believe me folks, it's not as if I'd never read anything about nutrition before. I am a lay expert on it. But I know the truth when I see it, and now I know how to save myself. I'll check in from time to time with reports of my progress.
There was only one other time — when I was a smoker — when I had an experience of being overwhelmed by a body of evidence to the extent where every rationale for keeping on doing self-harm was destroyed. That was back in 1963. I was in the student store at UCLA perusing a book called Smoking and the Public Interest, published by the Consumer's Union. That day I stood transfixed in front of the book rack, reading about what smoke does to the lungs and how it creates cancer. There was simply nothing else to do than to stop smoking right then and there, and that's what I did. Over the last several days I've had that kind of experience again of being overwhelmed by a relentless progression of evidence. It's like being sat on by an elephant: you can't ignore it! So — if you want to gain maximum health, switch over to a whole food plant-based way of eating for the rest of your life.
This post is addressed to all those with an open mind. To the rest, I've nothing to say. Nothing gets through to anyone heavily invested in staying with a particular belief. I wish one and all the very best.
Barley

