debate

I have it on DVD, i recorded it in HDMI with capture card. Theatrical release. And thats what i am sticking with :) But. Whats people's views on 4k versions? Ever since i got Terminator 2 2017 Bluray, i have now... glared at 4k with scepticism. Since James Cameron movies have bad rumors of poor...

This is a brief transition chapter setting up the final acts of the struggle against Sauron. However, it contains some fascinating ideas that are key themes of the book. On this reading, I have been struck by the personal journeys of several characters. Aragorn is now seen as so powerful that...

Hey. I am rereading the Lord of the Rings (this time in English not in Polish). I am on Book 4. There is one thing that seems weird to me. Sam overhears the conversation that Gollum has with Smeagol that he wants 'her' to kill them. And yet he suspects nothing when he leads them to Shelob. Did...

I'm a very new Tolkien fan and I'm only just beginning to sift through the HoME books, but I've been hearing a lot more seasoned fans talk about the great LaCE debate. I've only read excerpts from LaCE, so I'm not really sure I understand? Can anyone explain?

I was just re-reading some "Do Belrogs have Wings" threads, and was forced to ask myself - "Is THAT really the biggest Tolkien debate?" What other unsettled debates of LOTR are there left standing?

I've often heard people look at debates (friendly and otherwise) and advise that one does not make it personal. My question is: How is that even possible? A debate or discussion is all about different personal views. It's about taking a stand for what you personally believe. Or by...

I think it's time we settled this once and for all. Do Balrogs have wings? Please, nobody bite my head off for this, but I think it had to happen. So do they or don't they? In tFotR, the Balrog certainly has wings, as it stretches across the Hall. Then we have all the other Balrogs mentioned...

Okay, just vote for the things that you agree with.

A bit of a side- theme to the Arwen debate, really, but this can go off in a rather broad direction. What do you think ? Do you see elves as better than humans, perhaps devine even, simply because they are elves or do you see them as being judged upon their deeds and actions , therefore not...

Would it be possible to take some/all of the topics from the Great Debates and discuss them in the Book sections? This could really bring some more life and depth to the currently life-less and depthless book forums. I think it would be reall interesting to see what our more simple minds'...

I met a Harry Potter fan on-line and we got into an argument over which was more realistic (or which one one can identify with more.) The Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter. We decided to do this formally, so we are going to have an official debate. We are holding it over aim on January 24th...

I know this has appeared long ago in this forum, but to sum it all up, what did everyone decide on. Who the heck is he?