• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

faramir

  1. Eowyn and Faramir...

    Does anybody else think that they should have added the chapter about Eowyn and Faramir in the film, instead of all ludicrous parts about Aragorn and Arwen?
  2. Faramir: Much better than in the 📔book.

    Despite all the criticism one reads, David Wenham's portayal of Faramir in The Two Towers was the creation of a much better character than in Tolkien's book. If one really thinks about it, perhaps they will realise something. Faramir's situation: His father hates him. His beloved brother is...
  3. Why Faramir was bad. . .

    I now know why Faramir was bad, he was used as a delay to stop the stairs of Cirith Ungol needing to be shown, and to make the story more believable aswell because the ring was "tearing the mind of our main character apart" Its in the Extras ;) :)
  4. The Role of Faramir's Dream

    While re-reading LOTR once again, Boromir's explanation for his presence at the council of Elrond really bothered me. Faramir had the prophetic dream many times...Boromir once. Did he in fact have the dream at all? Boromir seems honest enough, but I can't say I believe him. Faramir's...
  5. Where did faramir take frodo and sam??

    this has confused me. where was it that faramir took them?? orcs were attacking and the nazgul were there, was it supposed to the the attack on gondor from mordor??? that is a huge change from the book!! so i suppose PJ is going to cut that battle completely out of ROTK? what about the...
  6. Faramir... A criminal?

    Its been so long since i read the books, maybe i should again for the hell of it but i cant remember if Faramir took Frodo and sam as "hostages" if you will. ALl i can remember is Frodo hearing the war by the river and stuff and i all remember is faramir passing by the hobbits asking them who...
  7. Faramir.... an injustice?

    Well, if you were to ask me, I say Faramir was done an injustice! I beleive the he was shown much differently than in the book. He seemed.... smarter, wiser in the book. I can't describe things like this well.... does anyone get what I'm saying? Does anyone agree?
  8. Why Make Faramir Bad?

    I think Peter Jackson has done a great job with the LOTR films because he has mostly stayed true to the books. However, I was wondering why he chose to make Faramir bad? I mean Tolkien says in the book Faramir didn't fall under the rings spell like his brother did. Also Faramir is nice to...
  9. Boromir's and Faramir's brother in RotK

    See here fG
  10. M

    faramir and eowyn

    I really hope their lil' lurve subplot won't get cut. I was reading it today and found it very sweet. Hopefully pj will show how Eowyn 'got over' aragorn via faramir and won't leave her all sad with nobody to love her *wipes tear*
  11. R

    in favor of PJs interpretation of faramir aka alternative adaptation

    i'm sure a lot of us has already expressed our protest of PJs treatment of faramir; in as much as PJ has the rights to alter the events according to the book to suite an altogether different medium. i'm sure for a lot of long time LOTR fans it was a shock for them to find one of the more noble...
  12. Anyone as dissapointed as me in Faramir's movie representation?

    I don't know about everyone else, but I was extremely dissapointed in the way Jackson portrayed Faramir. He was supposed to be kind and noble. Instead, they made him look like he was just like boromir - wanting the ring for his own use in Gondor. And, another thing, what was with the change of...
  13. T

    The Faramir Analysis

    I think it is prime-time we took a good look at PJ's Faramir and acknowledge some facts, from the book and from the films in general: * Faramir went to Osgiliath in the book. This is not a change or deviation from the book. Indeed, in terms of chronology, he went right after spending the...
  14. F

    Does Faramir hear Ulmo's voice?

    Which of the Valar would have spoken to Faramir? I do not have the Sil at hand, but I remember that Ulmo, Lord of Waters, was the one who spoke to men, whose voice was most often heard by mortals. Gandalf alludes to the lords of the west occasionally, saying that Bilbo and Frodo were meant to...
  15. What Do You Think About Faramir?

    Ok, in Tolkien's trilogy, Faramir is described as being very close in likeness to Boromir. In the film they kind of look similar but not REALLY close. Do you think that Faramir should look a lot like Boromir to be accurate to the book or do you think it's ok for him to be pretty different...
  16. Faramir and the one ring?

    Another one of my really smart questions. How come Faramir wasn't tempted by the ring when others like Gandalf, Saruman (Istari), Denethor, and Boromir (his family) were? :)
  17. Faramir and Immediate 👑King Recognition... What do you think?

    This is a great scene and a great chapter, but I wanted to know your opinion. Why does Faramir recognize Aragorn immediately? A few points: No one else did around that area. counter to the point: Faramir had just been healed by Aragorn (hands of a king) counter to the counter: Merry was...
  18. E

    Did Faramir make the right choice?

    It boggles the mind the final wonderful choice Faramir makes at Hennuth Annun, not based on logic: He whispers with Frodo as they go to the hideout, concerning Isildur's bane, and remarks how, if it gave advantage in battle, he can see how Boromir would be tempted. and later, And the...
  19. B

    Faramir instead of Boromir

    What would have happened in your opinion, if the Steward of Gondor have chosen Faramir instead of Boromir to go to Rivendell? Better or worse. HMMMM...:)
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…