• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

gondolin

  1. Escape from Gondolin (Atreyu's Tale)

    The attacks on Gondolin had grown increasingly intense. Aiden (the elf) his human wife Kora and their son Atreyu made their way to the escape tunnels made by Idril the daughter of King Turgon. "Come my wife! My son! We must leave this place or else perish with it!" Called the tall red haired...
  2. Looking forward to The Fall of Gondolin!

    And the third book is coming out in August 2018. Lookimg forward to The Fall Of Gondolin! It was one of my favourite stories in The Silmarillion.
  3. O

    Concerning Gondolin

    I have been trying to wrap my head around the geography of Gondolin for a while. If the Echoriath and Tumhalad had long before been a great lake, and the Dry River the only (or main?) outlet, how was there life within the valley? If there is flowing water within the Echoriath, and there are no...
  4. Your pick: Gondolin or Nargothrond?

    Which one is your favorite, mine is Nargothrond. Finrod Felagund is one of my favorite characters in the Silmirillion and Nargothrond only fell after he died in Tol-in-Gaurhoth. Gondolin stayed secret longer and so it survived longer and got stronger.
  5. 🧝Legolas' relation to Gondolin

    Hi everyone! Ever since I watched "The Hobbit, the Desolation of Smaug" on the world premiere, I have wondered about a small detail: In the movie in Mirkwood, Legolas and the woodelves capture the dwarves and take their weapons. When Legolas examines Orcrist he says something like this: "This...
  6. M

    What hidden depths of mythology does The Hobbit reveal?

    Every-time I go back to it, I'm kind surprised how much of the Grander mythology is hinted at it was was originally just a half-baked children's tale.
  7. S

    Fall of Gondolin

    In the original story Tuor made his way through the Golden Cleft to the sea. He then grew weary of the sea and guided by the Noldoli's blue lanterns he found a way beside the river border until the voice of the sea was far behind him. Thus he came soon to that region that has been called...
  8. S

    Last Stand of the Captains of Gondolin

    In The Book of Tales Vol. II, we are treated to the original version of The fall of Gondolin in all its valiant glory, unabridged, and not a one paragraph description as in the Silmarillion. After reading this version of the battle I must say that the last stand of the elves of Gondolin against...
  9. S

    The Appearance of 🧝Legolas in Gondolin

    Recently I have been reading the lost tales, and I must say, in The Lost Tales vol. 2, The Fall of Gondolin may be the greatest battle I have ever had the pleasure of reading, with the descriptions and mighty deeds of the captains of Gondolin, of the battle between Ecthelion (possibly the...
  10. T

    RP 🎲 The First Age: Fair Gondolin

    Triandra Ravenstar walked through the woods in South Beleriand, stopping briefly to take a rest. She leaned on her staff, brushing a golden strand of hair off of her face. She then sat down. How she came to be in the very south of Beleriand was very blurry, even though it has been five years...
  11. Húrin revealing the whereabouts of Gondolin?

    Had there been no Maeglin and his treachery, would Húrin's actions had been enough for Gondolin to be discovered and ruined by Morgoth eventually?
  12. Of Tuor and his coming to Gondolin

    this is by far my favourite essay of the Unfinished Tales, but it is woefully incomplete. Why are we not told "the seven names of the Hidden City" ? We only catch a very fleeting glimpse of what Tuor saw when the gates opened, but why did the Professor never tell us more? Why did he abandon the...
  13. Chapter 23: Of the Fall of Gondolin

    Narn e·Dant Gondolin ar Orthad en·Êl This story deals mostly with Tuor son of Huor. It begins as Tuor is raised by Elves (Grey-Elves, Annael). Unfortunately for Tuor, he was captured by the Easterlings and made a slave. The good thing is that Tuor handled that situation elegantly and became...
  14. C

    How many 🧝elves lived in Gondolin?

    Hello, this is a very silly question, but I am wondering how many elves in total lived there. They say that gondolin had an army of 12.000 men, would that lead to a number of 30.000-40.000 elves total in that city? Tell me please what you think
  15. F

    🧝Legolas - Fall of Gondolin

    Forgive me if this has been answered before. IS Legolas Greenleaf of the Tree, the night-sighted leader at the end of the Fall of Gondolin, the same as the Legolas Greenleaf of LOTR? If he is, he would be at least 6000 years old during LOTR, since that LOTR is in the Third Age, and the FOG...
  16. What saved Gondolin...

    ...from being discovered by Morgoth & co.? Alright, the eagles are what comes to mind immediately. The servants of Manwë, mighty in their own right, but still... Morgoth had quite a few winged servants. There were the dragons, extremely powerful and cunning. There were also some...
  17. 🧝Legolas of Gondolin?

    I have been aware of the fact that there is a Legolas mentioned leading the Exhiles of Gondolin after its fall in one of the earlier versions of the story. What does this mean? This might be a repeat of an earlier question, but I have not found any others. Does anyone know anything about it...
  18. B

    Curious about the location of Gondolin from The Hobbit?

    This maybe a stupid question, but where the heck is Gondolin. Does it say in the Hobbit, cos to be honest ive never got round to reading it.
  19. Of Brethil and Gondolin......

    Were Brethil and Gondolin located in Beleriand? I remember thinking they were but I am not sure if I'm right. And also, where was Beleriand in relation to Middle earth? I know it sank into the sea and stuff but I'm not sure exactly were it was. Does anyone have a map of ME adn Beleriand?
  20. 4

    Gondolin Map Location

    My Sil maps leave much to be desired, as this most critical place is located in the crease of the pages, making it very difficult to make out. What I really want to know, is where Gondolin is (was) located when looking at a map in the 3rd age.
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…