Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
Hello fellow Tolkein fans,
I like most (if not all) of you have seen the New Line Cinema LOTR Trilogy. I personally feel it is extremely well made, with the right ammounts Hollywood-ness and accuracy to the storyline to make it a success.
But there is one bit in the movie that ruins the...
Okay, first off, you must realize Tolkien only gave a few definite numbers for the Siege of Gondor/Battle of Pelennor Fields. But he did leave hints that we can figure out, which I hope to do here. I have here many quotes for our use and my arguments as to numbers at the battle.
-200 Axe men...
We all know she slayed the Witch-King with the aid of Merry. We all know her role in the Pelennor Fields was vital to the victory that day. But, did she do anything else?
Nowhere in the book does it describe the young Dernhelm cleaving Orcs, or where her position was in the cavalry charge...
What would happen if sauron's forces won the battle of the pelennor fields? And if they conquered Minas Tirith? Even though they didnt win against Lorien and Thranduil's kingdom this was definately the turning point in the War of the Ring. If minas tirith fell then Gondor would ultimately fall...
Gothmog
After the Lord of the Nazgul is slain at Pellenor, Tolkien writes that Gothmog leads the armies of Sauron. Obviously, this is not the Gothmog of the Silmarillion, the Lord of the Balrogs, so who is he? Is he another Nazgul? I don't think there is another reference to him in LOTR but...