• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

samwise gamgee

  1. Does Samwise Gamgee ever say "Yippee" in the books

    He says "Hurray" when he gets excited to hear that he is going to see the elves. But i remember him saying Yippee too. If not i may have a foggy memory
  2. How did Sam know he could sail into the West?

    Something I was just thinking about. Sam stayed in ME for long after Frodo, Bilbo, Gandalf, Elrond, etc. sailed into the West. So how did he know -- or rather, who told him -- he could go there? I suppose maybe Legolas could've told him? But then how did HE know? Or after Rosie died did Sam...
  3. F

    What Is Sam Saying Near the End of TTT?

    Hi everyone, Here's something that's always puzzled me. Near the end of The Two Towers, when Frodo and Sam are in Osgiliath, there comes a point at which Frodo says, "It's calling to him, Sam. His Eye is almost on me." Sam replies, "Hold on, Mr. Frodo. You'll be all right," but after that we...
  4. Sam as Frodo's Garner

    Question on Sam as Frodo's garner. Was he paid for this service? did he do it for free? how did it come about? thanks.
  5. B

    How did Bilbo and Sam manage to part with the Ring by choice?

    Sauron: Didn't part with it of his own free will. Had it cut from his finger. Isildur: Didn't destroy it and only parted with it when killed by orcs. Deagol: Didn't seem willing to part with it and only parted with it when murdered by Smeagol. Smeagol*: Lost it unwillingly when it slipped off...
  6. B

    Could Sam have destroyed the Ring at the end?

    Say that Gollum DID give up and DID NOT go after the Hobbits or that Sam HAD killed him, could Sam be able to overwhelm Frodo and get the Ring into the fire (even if it meant killing Frodo in the process) or would the Nazgul have gotten there first? True, Frodo was kind of invisible, but Sam...
  7. B

    What if Sam had not caught up to Frodo?

    This is an interesting one. I cannot, off the top of my head, think of a situation that Sam was truly NEEDED with Frodo in TTT or ROTK, except maybe, perhaps, on Mount Doom itself in ROTK. True, Sam did help Frodo fend off Gollum, but Sam only had a Barrow Blade. Frodo had a Mithril Coat...
  8. G

    Did Sam is God?!

    Recently reading the books again, I realized that Sam is the actual personification of God in the plot of the history, what ya think about it?
  9. "Samwise you fool"

    In RoTK (personally my favorite of the trilogy) there is s key scene where Frodo and Sam make it almost to the entrance of Mt Doom where they are confronted by Gollum, desperate to get his precious back, who attacks Frodo and tries to murder him. At a crucial point, Sam gets up and starts to...
  10. Why doesn't the Ring betray Sam in 🌋Mordor?

    If the Ring is able to change sizes at its will (intentionally slipping off Isildur's finger), why does it not fall off Sam when he is surrounded by orcs?
  11. Sam and Farmer Maggot

    Wow. It has been a long time since I posted in the movie forum. Since coming back on here I decided to go and watch the extended edition movies again. Most of my LoTR books are packed so I can't access them.:( Luckily, time has softened my purist stance on the movies (though I still did fast...
  12. Frodo and Sam sleeping on a precipice?

    After Frodo, Sam and Gollum pass Minas Morgul, they climb the stairs towards Cirith Ungol. One scene shows them resting on the very brink of an appalingly steep and narrow precipice, overlooking Minas Morgul far far below. I personally thought this scene was far-fetched and unrealistic. Do you?
  13. Samwise Gamgee

    Probably Sam was born on 6 April 2983. 'Samwise' means 'half-wise' (i.e. simple or foolish). Sam Gamgee is a servant of Frodo the Ring-bearer. Samwise is a gardener and he loves trees and plants. He left the Shire with his master and then went to Rivendell. Later he went to the great journey...
  14. Sam and Frodo- Osgiliath Tearjerker

    I was just reminded of this by some one's sig, i think it might be Lamarievenstar's but I think that one of the most powerful bits in TTT, (the film, it's not in the book) is when Sam and Frodo are in Osgiliath, and Sam is talking about the great tales, and why they are so great. And while he's...
  15. Mini-Argonath and Sam's address

    I just finished extended edition of Return Of The King again and I noticed a couple of things. There appears to be a "mini-Argonath" in the scene of the coronation of Aragorn. After he says the line "My friends, you bow to no one," the camera pulls back so that you can see all of the...
  16. L

    Sam... why we "go on"... songs sung

    I'm going nuts digging through the Trilogy looking for what may or may not even be... a quote, I think by Sam, about: "songs being sung about those that keep going when there's no good reason to" Can somebody please put me out of my misery and into the joy of discovery? (or, tell me for...
  17. The unfinished business of Master Samwise

    What is it that Sam had to do before the end? Is there only one obvious answer to this, or are there various possible 'solutions'?
  18. Proof that Samwise Gamgee is the coolest character ever...

    Here is the proof: http://www.ryano.net/iraq/?36237
  19. Will the Real Sam Gamgee Please Stand Up?

    I ran across two especially agreeable letters in the Carpenter/Tolkien volume of Tolkien's Letters, which I thought I'd share: =============================== 184 To Sam Gamgee [On 13 March, a letter was written to Tolkien by a Mr Sam Gamgee of Brixton Road, London S.W.9: 'I hope you...
  20. F

    Frodo, Sam and the Anti-climax

    I have always felt sad and disappointed about the way Frodo and Sam were received/treated after they completed their journey with the Ring. I'm not speaking about how they were received back in the Shire either, where you'd expect the folk to not understand the implications of what they'd done...
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…