Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
One of the things that really turned the Valar against them was the first kinslaying over the boats. But what if the Teleri or whatever they're called had simply agreed to give them some boats to get the Simarils back?
It was once prophesised by the Vala Námo that a certain apparent Maia, who once served all 14 Valar and took on the form of a Teleri Elf, would fall from the grace of the Valar and the Calaquendi alike, and would dwell with Melkor and Annatar ere Dagor Dagorath.
Most of the prophecy had been...
It was once prophesised by the Vala Námo that a certain half-Teleri, as well as half-Maia of Manwe and Varda - would fall from the grace of the Valar and the Calaquendi alike, and would dwell with Melkor ere Dagor Dagorath.
Most of the prophecy had been forgotten among the Eldar, but part of it...
Remember before the Kinslaying when he told Olwe 'if it were not for the Noldor, you would still be living in huts on the beach'?
Perhaps those words were just out of anger, but to me they implied Feanor saw the Teleri as less civilized.
In the early part of the Sil, Tolkien ranks the three Eldarin kindreds by their nobility. Vanyar are considered the most noble of the Elves, Noldor second, and Teleri last.
After the exile back to ME and the Kinslaying though, did the Noldor lose this status of being more noble than the Teleri...
It seems that once the Elves got so far in their geneologies, it was no longer so clear as to who was of which clan (with all the mixing and inter-marrying going on). However, was it ever explicitely stated to which Elrond belonged? On his father's side, there is certainly much Noldorin blood...
Of all the three kinds of Quendi, who do you think is the better? Can it be said that some kind is superior or greater than the other.
I have always liked the Ñoldor better because of their achivements and deeds, but I wonder if they can be considered truly the best?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.