Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
I know a lot of people were talking about Smaug and the likelihood of his involvement in the War of Wrath (which seems likely), but what about the greatest of the cold-drakes? Anyone have any ideas?
In The Silmarillion it reads:
However, the War of Wrath spans some fourty years according to Lotr Project timelines (F.A. 545-587). It's also hard for me to imagine that at least the Noldor didn't take a chance to visit their relatives in Middle-Earth, or warn the free peoples about the...
What would happened, if valar army had been defeated in war of Wrath?
would morgoth tried attack valinor,if he had won war of Wrath?
did valar had any back up plan if they had lost and forced to retreat?
I would expect that many Quendi passed through Lindon during or after the War of Wrath and may have met each other there. Of course in RP I always must meet many Elves the first time, but the chances are that if my and their characters both lived in the First Age, they might already be...
I think that Smaug was in the War of Wrath. Let us examine the facts. Smaug is of the Winged Uruloki. These were created by Morgoth, and in the Great Battle the Silmarillion states that well-nigh all of them were destroyed...but not all. However, if nearly all of them were destroyed and Smaug...
All right, I'm sure you all know that it has been said several times that the greatest amassing of forces occurred at the War of Wrath, and the second greatest gathering of forces was at the Last Alliance. Well, my question is this, what about Ar-Pharazon's colossal fleet he assailed the Undying...
"Why all of the senseless destruction? Are people really so lazy?" A giant raven who just happened to be one of the more animalically-minded Ainur and an ancestor of the Crebain surveyed the ruins of Beleriand. "I was comfortable there. Plenty of interesting, albeit tragically featherless and...
Greetings, all. The title should tell you something about the story. You do not have to rhyme to post, although it would be awesome. :*rolleyes:
For people to be joining, I am looking for an achingly varied group. Representatives of all kinds of races, and when I type, "all kinds of races,"...
from Tolkiens writings:
THIS is a disturbing idea- at least to me- if he surrendered and begged for mercy- how could the good Valar treat him this way?
I think this is extremely perplexing, from an ethical / merciful standpoint.
You have an enemy, beaten, humbled, pleading, and yet you "hew...
Is it possible that Olorin took part in the War of Wrath when Morgoth was overthrown. I haven't read anything about this so far and was wondering if anyone had any ideas. Sorry if it has been brought up before.
Ok, to me I have always assumed that the Valar fought in the War of Wrath, but I was reading a thread that made me think twice about that. Throughout the Silmarillion when it discusses the War of wrath all it says is "the host of the Valar" or "the host of Valinor" fought but it never mentions...
I was discussing some properties of the War of Wrath with gate7ole and I was amazed to find out that in the HoME V: The Lost Road, it is stated that the War of Wrath lasted for 50 years:
How did the war last fifty years (547-597)? The Encyclopedia of Arda, which is of course not always...
Ok, I might be getting ahead of myself here as I've only reached up to the Ackallbeth in the Silmarillion, But I'm confused about the Flooding of Beleriand.
The Valar leave the Belssed Realm and come to Middle Earth, kick Morgoths butt, and save the day and at the end of it all the whole of...
Why did Sauron never return to Angband,after being defeated by Luthien & Huan? Shame?:confused:
And why did he not take an active part in the War of Wrath? He was second in command,right after Morgoth and he was bound to his master's will. Instead he just hid and later parleyed with Eonwë -...