• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Characterization in the movie was absolutely PERFECT!!!

Great thread Aragil.

In general I support most of the characterizations.

I didn't perceive some of the characters as portrayed in the way that many others did. I didn't think Gandalf's "is it safe" remarks re the Ring were "sputtering". Consider that he's left the most appallingly powerful artifact in Middle Earth in the care of a hobbit and he's just been given cause to believe that the pursuit is hard on his heels. I don't think that a little trepidation and urgent inquiry is out of place.

Merry and Pippin were not what I had in my mind's eye, but I think PJ came up with a better picture than I had. He captured their adolescence and immaturity very well, and he did make a clear distinction between the two. Merry was clearly more level headed and quicker to realise that a situation was serious and called for serious action.

I'm with you on Aragorn. The Aragorn I saw was fairly weatherbeaten and looked like someone who had spent some hard time in hard places. Although chronologically he is old, he is not old for his bloodline (especially one in whom the blood of Numenor runs more true than in any other for centuries). The books clearly give the impression of not quite middle aged for me. Certainly he should be vigorous and capable. Some of the Aragorn objectors seem to want an old veteran on the verge of collecting his pension. And I don't think JRRT ever used the adjective "grizzled" to describe him.

Elrond was great. He had the stern approach and careworn attitude I was looking for. Galadriel, likewise was good given the limited time on screen. More time would have brought out the softer side of her a bit more.

Sorry to the Orlando fans, but Legolas was boring and colourless. However, that's how he was in FOTR. It wasn't until well into TTT that he developed much of a personality and even then he never set the world on fire.

Gimli was a bit of a D&D stereotype dwarf for me. However, he may warm up when he has a bit more to do.

I hated Boromir to start with but found myself warming to him by the end of the movie. As with Legolas, my reaction to him was exactly how I reacted to him the first time I read the book, so from that perspective, they got his character right.

Sam was great. He had the right mixture of rustic, bucolic ignorance (NOT stupidity) and stubborn loyalty. I did miss the "tall, shapeless felt bag" that he used for a hat though.

I thought Frodo was in some ways was the weakest of the Fellowship. The pathos got a bit close to pathetic and he was a bit too Boy's Own for me. And the CG stuff made his neck look like he was a front row forward (Rugby allusion, I don't know the equivalent American football position). But overall, he was acceptable.
 
I thought PJ did a good job portraying the company of the fellowship. The characterization of non central characters was perhaps a bit dubious.

Concerning Gandalf, I do not remember him being portrayed as spluttering. Everyone seems to site only the one incident when Gandalf fears that the ring may have been taken, in which case his entire mission would have failed. The fact that Gandalf who no where else (except at the meeting of the Balrog) shows signs of trepidation in the face of gravest danger seems to indicate to me that Gandalf was not portrayed as spluttering. In fact I would argue that Tolkien portrayed him in similar distress as Gandalf rushed on Shadowfax to Shire once he had escaped Orthanc. The distress of Gandalf rushing to Bree was not shown by PJ nor his relief as he learned that the hobbits were accompanied by Strider. In PJ's rendition Gandalf is merely far less confident in security of the Shire and therefore he rushes from the libraries of Minas Tirith to the Shire to be sure that it is safe.

In other instances Gandalf was very composed: at the entrance to the mines of Moria he was at a loss but not distressed by the howling of the wolves; on the bridge of Khazad- Dum after his initial surprise by the appearance of a balrog, he was composed and commanding. You can think of other instances for yourselves.

Moreover, he portrayed Gandalf as lighthearted and fond of the hobbits which was a concern of mine. Also Ian portrayed the heaviness of his burden, looking very old and even dotardly at times which is how he appeared to many according to Tolkien's description, so much so that the Theoden's guard allowed him to pass with his staff. Of all the characters I the nuiances of Gandalf's character were best portrayed.

Aragorn is perhaps more subtle than Gandalf in some ways. His knowledge of the wilds was much lost in the movie. And he was a weatherbeaten roadworn man, "all that is gold does not glitter" -- it is a shame that that short poem was left out. I did like the fact that PJ drew out Aragorn's struggle with his own past. He did indeed struggle with it and Elrond makes specific mention that he is chosen because he is Isildur's heir. PJ choose to explicitly state the struggle Aragorn had over the ring, which was implicit in the book.

I don't have time to go into all the characters. I will make mention of two characters I did not like. The only objectionable aspect of Arwen was not her role in saving Frodo (recall that Luthien saved Beren) but her kinky first appearance sneaking up on Strider in the wilds (which also diminished Aragorn's abilities) and putting a sword to his neck. That was just silly. Also Elrond appeared quite bitter. The elves might have become bitter because of Isuldur's poor choice, but they were more magnanimous, especially Elrond. And the homeliness of his house was not manifest in the film.

On the whole I thought the character portrayal was a bright spot in the film. But since most of the characters are not developed until later books, we shall have to see whether his good beginnings do not falter.
 
Originally posted by aragil
Tar-Steve- I'll remind you that the point of this thread is not whether we liked the character's portrayal, but wether it was justifiable based on what is in the books.

WTF?

In what way is my Galadriel objection not based on "what's in the books" and where are the "reminders" for all the posts in this thread that ARE simple statements of the "whether we liked/disliked the character's portrayal" variety?

(Just wondering what makes me so special. )
 
re why you're so special...

I was responding to a lot of people's posts, and in my haste what popped out of your post wast the opening sentence 'I didn't like Galadriel's portrayal in the movie'. That's what I was reffering to- then you backed it up with book quotes, and I gave my weak defence.
 
Aragil, I just found this thread and apologize for not looking closer, sooner.....

Having said that, you and the NLC fanatics (a new name) have me so worn out from other posts in other threads that my brain will not function properly tonight to go through an in-depth analysis of all that has been said. I have read every post now and will respond tomorrow when what little brain I have is working more clearly.

I do have one thought on characterization in the movie and I say it in all sincerity. Did anyone notice Rosie Cotton? My God... I thought she was sooooooooooo hot. I guess it's because she reminds me of a dark and delicate cajun lady from my home state. I know that she didn't play a role in the book until The Scouring of the Shire but I thought her sweet cuteness is exactly what I imagined Rosie would be all about. And as Schwartz... said in Terminator... "I'll be back!!"
 
In case anyone was wondering when my two-cents would be added, be warned. The time is swift approaching. I've been out of town for a few days.

Love Always
xgothgrrl
 
The characters in the Fellowship were great IMHO.
Gandalf didn't splutter or anything, he dearly loved hobbits and feared the Ring. In Moria he was the Gandalf I imagined.
Boromir was a noble man, tempted by the Ring, the sword lessons to Merry and Pippin made him look better than in the book to me honestly.
Gimli was the stout-hearthed Dwarf he was supposed to be. To nit-pick: He didn't have a helmet when they left Rivendell. He got a helmet from Theoden before they went to Helms Deep.
Legolas was the friendly, fast moving Elf.
Merry was more thoughtfull than the overly active Pippin, but in the book of FOTR they are not as clearly given character as they were in the movie. The movie did it better for them.
Frodo is the scared but determined Hobbit, some scenes did cut back his courage though.
Sam is the loving friend of Frodo. Simple-minded perhaps, but true in his hearth, as in the books.
 
Just bringing this back up on the off-hand chance anyone still has objections to character-portrayal in the movies.
 
C'mon Darth..Don't let your undying praise and admiration for PJ stop you from being somewhat objective...compared to any character you see, yes, the characters were excellent. Compared to Tolkien, most were somewhat lacking...

1) Character wise (personality and overall performance) Boromir and Gandalf (with the exception of about three scenes) were probably the closest to Tolkien.

Arwen, Saruman and Gimli were the worst

Frodo, Aragorn, Bilbo and Legolas were neutral in my mind.

2) Physical wise (looking the part): The Nazgul, Gandalf, Saruman, Sam and Gimli (with the exception of the stupid helmet) were the best fit for the part.

Elrond, Galadriel (though I don't think any actress could do Galadriel justice), and Frodo were the worst cast form a physical perspective.

See, this purist can be objective as well as critical.
 
Thorin, what's the point if you're going to be objective?

But since you did it I have to do it too now .

1) Charachter wise:

Good: Boromir, Gandalf, Sam, Bilbo, Aragorn.

Decent: Frodo, Pippin, Merry, Gimili, Legolas, Elrond, Galadriel, Saruman.

Bad: Arwen, Celebron.

I don't have anything in particular against Elrond or Legolas, but I can't say they blew me away either.

2) Vissually:

Good: Gandalf, Boromir, Aragorn, Bilbo, Sam, Gimili, Legolas, Saruman.

Decent: Frodo, Merry, Galadriel, Elrond.

Bad: Arwen, Celebron, Pippin.


I'm almost tempted to say put Galadriel in the "good" category. In my opinion, without the light surrounding her, she looks perfect. Her eyes reflect both sorrow and joy. Elijah Wood didn't look enough like a hobbit for my tastes. He wasn't "full" enough, for lack of better words. I thought Sam, on the other hand, looked perfect.

Not to loose my objectivity (for what it's worth), but in my most humble opinion the movie was incredible visually. Literrally scene for scene I was blown away by the amount of color and creativity coming off screen. But I'm very sensitive visually so that makes me slightly biased. The only scene that I have serious objections with is Galadriels transformation. It just looked really cheap. I don't mind the idea so much, but use a different color!!! That blueish/green scheme looked so puny and cheap. They should have made it golden/amber. That would have shone through much more majestically. But her voice ruins it for the most part. Loose the bass.

Other then that objection everything is literally spot on (visually).
 
I first saw the film, and then I read the book...
In the film, Arwen appearence seemed logical, but...
After I had read the book, I got this sort of "sense" of Elven-women...They are noble, beautiful, bla-bla-bla, you all know that, but although they are strong personalities, and brave and proud, they don't seem like sort of women who would go around waving swords, fighgting...For instance, take the story of Beren and Luthien ("The Silmarillion") Luthien "fought" with song and grace, not with swords!!!
What I'm trying to say is that Elven women are strong, but their strength is represented in a different way... Holding a sword...that's something that becomes mortal women - like Eowyn, or some other female characters from "The Silmarillion"...
PJ's wish to show Arwen as a strong women who doesn't just sit around and wait for her prince to save her is OK, but I think he didn't do it in the right manner...

And I liked how they presented Boromir's character!!! The scene of his death really touched me... He was taken over by the ring, but he gained his absolution and died honourably... And he also reffers to Hobits as "little ones"... That really shows his sensitive side... He was really portrayed well in the film.
 
I first saw the film, and then I read the book...
In the film, Arwen appearence seemed logical, but...
After I had read the book, I got this sort of "sense" of Elven-women...They are noble, beautiful, bla-bla-bla, you all know that, but although they are strong personalities, and brave and proud, they don't seem like sort of women who would go around waving swords, fighgting...For instance, take the story of Beren and Luthien ("The Silmarillion") Luthien "fought" with song and grace, not with swords!!!
What I'm trying to say is that Elven women are strong, but their strength is represented in a different way... Holding a sword...that's something that becomes mortal women - like Eowyn, or some other female characters from "The Silmarillion"...
PJ's wish to show Arwen as a strong women who doesn't just sit around and wait for her prince to save her is OK, but I think he didn't do it in the right manner...

And I liked how they presented Boromir's character!!! The scene of his death really touched me... He was taken over by the ring, but he gained his absolution and died honourably... And he also reffers to Hobits as "little ones"... That really shows his sensitive side... He was really portrayed well in the film.
 
Millena- I think there's several of you Belgraders around the boards these days. I live right next to Belgrade, Montana, USA. Bet you didn't know THAT existed. Welcome to the forum!

I agree with you completely on Boromir in the movie. I loved a lot of things in that movie, but Boromir might be my favorite of all. No offence to JRRT, but I never really empathisized with the character in the books- he just seemed like a head-strong individual, who I thought was probably better off dead (rather than alive and lusting for the Ring). Somehow, Sean Bean and PJ really made the character work for me: I really felt the tragedy of his fall and saw how desperately he wanted to make amends. If that had been the only good part in the movie it probably would have been enough for me to enjoy the whole show. (I've probably already posted all this somewhere on this thread, but darnit, it's a good enough bit that it's worth a second mention).

Regarding Arwen- I think I might disagree with you a little here. Remember, a large part of Arwen (well, about half) was human, so she might do things that other Elven women wouldn't do. Even Luthien carried a knife (and what a knife), and while Arwen held a sword, she didn't really use it, she still defeated the Nazgûl through guile.
 
Belgrade in America? ..... Hmmm.... Actually, I know that there are 7 Belgrades in USA... Not too original, I guess...


Your reply on Arwen... I agree with you! Can you believe it, I actually FORGOT that Arwen was part human... Hmmm.... Maybe the reason I disregarded her human descent was because in JRRT's book, she is barely noted!!! I think I've learned more about characters reading appendix (how do you guys Americans call that addition to the book?)
than reading the book... And speaking of Arwen, I really hated the way her life was ended!!!! Booo-hooo-hooo.... I almost started crying in the bus, when I read that part...


I saw the film before I read the book, and I went to see it once again... I definitely liked the casting!!! I don't know if anyone noticed, but Viggo Mortensen ( I hope I spelled the name corectly) has grey eyes, dark hair... Just like the people of Numenor!!! Everyone looked like they were described in the book, except fot one little thing : all the Elves ( save Elrond and his children ) were fair-haired!!!!!! Why? All the Elves of Middle-earth were dark-haired people, save Lady Galadriel, who was partly of Vanyar descent...
 
About Arwen being half-human... hmm... on her mother's side, not a trace of mortal blood: her maternal gradparents were Galadriel and Celeborn. On Daddy's side, her grandmother Elwing was half-elven but rared in an Noldorin community, and Eärendil the same. So mortal influence would be close to zero. I think of her rather as I do of Galadriel: not the type to go around pretending to slit Aragorn's throat and trying to outrace Nazgûl. In particular, she seemed to treat Frodo like and infant: in the book, he's wounded and very weak, but it's the part where he shows the most courage and force of spirit – here he's as wilful and active as a bag of spuds. "Ifyouwanthimcomeandclaimhim" wans nearly like "don't you touch my little guy, you nasty shadow! he's SO cute, I wouldn't have anything happen to him. Complete misportryal of Arwen, IMHO.
Also, rather minor but just as off-course, orcs hatching out of mud: this was the time to show some grandiose scenes of armies filling up the whole screen, not vile pupating in the dark. That along with the fact Gandalf and Saruman don't fight: there may be a mental strife, but none of that ninja stuff.

On the other hand, Boromir was EXCELLENT: he really played his character very deeply. Though the scene of his death with the slow-motion arrow-pricking was overdone, in my sense. Excellent acting overall. Apart from Arwen, I think no character was really mistreated. I especially like Gandalf, Galadriel and Elrond. That's not how I imagined Elrond, but it works out very well. Remove Arwen's pranks and the mud-hatched orcs and it is near perfect.
 
Millena- (re. fair-haired Elves) I don't really know why the costumers decided to do that, but in their defence, several of the Sindar (Elwe, Cirdan) are said to have either blonde or silver hair. Thranduil, Legolas, and Celeborn are all related to Elwe, so it is possible that they had lighter color hair. The other Elven Blondes are Silvan, which might make up a large enough group to have both Blonde and Dark-colored hair. At least they were definitely right with Galadriel!

Rúmil- Regardless of their upbringing, Elrond and family were very much half-human.
From Many Meetings
He was the Lord of Rivendell and mighty among both Elves and Men
How can you reconcile this quote with mortal influences being near nil? Remember, after ~TA 1980 the Northern Dunedain were based out of Rivendell, giving Arwen over 1000 years of mortal influence. And for those who think of Elven women as incapable of running away from Nazgûl, here's a bit from HoME 10 which discusses the nature of Elven women:
I think the potential capture of the Ring-Bearer and the One Ring by the Nazgûl falls under the broad category of 'dire straits', so even an elven woman would be excused if she rides a horse away from the Black Riders under these circumstances. Did she treat Frodo like an infant? I didn't feel that way, I thought the treatment was more as an invalid, which Frodo was at that point. Arwen was definitely protective of him, but considering the circumstances that seems forgivable.
I am, however, inclined to agree with you on the sword-to-Aragorn's neck bit. I have no idea why that was there, and playfully threatening violence definitely does not seem to be in the character of any besides an Orc.

And speaking of Orcs, I think I disagree with you regarding the Orcs out of the Mud. If you're interested (and you'd have to be very interested to read all the following posts) here's two links to threads which discuss the scene and the relationship between Sauron's and Saruman's Orcs in GREAT detail:

http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=1431
and
http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=2146

If you don't feel like reading these threads (and who could blame you?) here is an interesting quote, again from HoME 10:
Clearly Tolkien did not feel that this crossing in any way deserved 'grandiose' treatment. It was Saruman's wickedest deed, brought about by his lust for mastery, and the offspring of this crossing were vile. Vile pupating in the dark sounds pretty well in line with JRRT's concept, in my opinion.
Hope you don't think I was picking on you- just trying to address some of your points, after all, that's what this thread is for!
 
About the mortal influence on Arwen: you do make a point there. I guess I hadn't thought of that. But about her "courage": yes, no doubt if the Nazgûl hat invaded Rivendell, I'm sure she would have acted proudly and bravely. But in the film it looks like she just out seeking danger for the thrill of it, not being brave "at a pinch"; even the male Eldar and Edain avoided combat as much as they could, except for the reckless types like Fëanor. If the sneeking up on Aragorn had been absent, it would haved deleted that impression, Arwen going out to have some fun at the Nazgûl's expence. About the Orcs, it is quite a long debate – must do some reading before I can come up with a valid opinion on how Orcs reproduce, though I think in the Silm it says they do it after the manner of the Children of Illúvatar (brr). Still, the wizard karate fight sticked out.

And, as the Professor said,
you are welcome to let your pen run as it will, it is horrible writing letters to people with whom you have to be 'careful'
Can't put it better than the Professor, can I?
 
Aragil

Hmmm....I'm really interested....where did you read about Elven portraits? Well, I've only read LOTR and half of "the Silmarillion", so I guess it doesn't really make me an expert for Toliken...
So far, I've only got the picture of all Elves being dark haired, and only the Vanyar and some of their offsprings being fair-haired...
Can anyone tell me about other works of Tolkien.....? I can't wait to get my hands on them!!!
 
Hmm....I'm replying to myself....
Ok, I get it that there were much more blonde Elves around, but I still don't like it in the film - ALL of them were blonde!!!!! Why, oh, why?!!!
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…