• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Characterization in the movie was absolutely PERFECT!!!

The characterisations weren't perfect.

Aragorn: acted too much like a confidence-lacking moron. Arwen can take him unawares, and he can nearly be beaten by an orc.

Gandalf: Is too much of a blundering idiot. Panicky and trivial.

Galadriel: That mad thing that happens is just wrong. She is meant to be gently mocking Frodo not turning into a monochromic misconception of a literary subtlety. She is amiably patronising to Frodo, she doesn't suffer from some vaguely identifiable seizure caused by the words of a hobbit.

Sam: OK

Borormir: His submission to Aragorn was unexpected but acceptable.

Legolas: Soopa cool. The only bad thing I can see is that he detracted from the skills of the other companions.

Gimli: Treated as the comedian of the fellowship. He should be a strong character, not just an outlet for one-liners.

Merry, Pippin: OK, no major complaints.

Celeborn: Galadriel's concubine

Saruman: Rum-de-dum-de-dumde-dum. (On the tower, you know) He was good, but I have a vague bias towards Christopher Lee.

As with everything in this film I am left feeling dissatisfied. "Why oh why couldn't they just have done this differently, or that differently?"

Anyway the point at the end is that 'perfect' is too strong a word to use. Of course they will never be perfect to anyone's mind unless they direct the film themselves. I believe strongly that with someone, a person who truly understands the books, advising PJ, the film could have been the cinematic event we all wished it to be.
 
Millena- I'm not sure that there were more blonde elves than dark-haired ones, check out the posts by Cìan in http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=1925
I think you might have a valid gripe about the Elves seeming to all be blondes in the movie, but Celeborn is described as having silver hair, Galadriel does have blonde hair:
They were clad wholly in white; and the hair of the Lady was of deep gold, and the hair of the Lord Celeborn was of silver long and bright;
Also the Elf who helps the Fellowship cross the Celebrant in Lorien (at least) has blonde hair:
He gave a call like the low whistle of a bird, and out of a thicket of young trees an Elf stepped, clad in grey, but with his hood thrown back; his hair glinted like gold in the morning sun.
However, I think that barring special mention most Elves (excepting of course the Vanyar) did have dark hair.

The only other works of Tolkien I know of which describe Middle-earth are Unfinished Tales and The History of Middle-earth series. Both were published posthumously (like the Sil), and they both contain large amounts of editorial commentary by Tolkien's son, Christopher. If you're interested, there are several threads in the HoME forum about which books make a good read.

Rúmil- well, the sword-to-Aragorn's-neck thing is definitely not a fond memory for me, either. Still, I don't let it ruin my impression of Arwen- I just imagine that she was sent out by her father, as Glorfindel in the books mentions several messengers being sent out in search of the Ring-bearer. If you like, think of her as an amalgamation of herself and her two brothers, as (sadly) I don't think that either Elladan or Elrohir will be making an appearance in the movies. And don't forget to ignore the sword to the neck bit.
As for the Uruk-hai (a favorite topic of mine, I should warn you), we don't know the movie's take on their conception. Remember, in the movie Sauron tells Saruman to build an army while Gandalf is imprisoned in Orthanc. By the time the Fellowship reaches Lorien the Orc warriors are full-grown, indicating that Saruman must have used magic in addition to his cross-breeding of humans and orcs. So the Uruk-hai in the movie might have been conceived after the manner of the children of Illuvatar (it says this in both the Sil and HoME), but their maturation and development were greatly accelerated via the magical muck. At least that's my take.
Re. the Wizards' duel- the book doesn't tell us what happened. But what we do know is what Gandalf has just learned:
1) Saruman has connected the dots regarding Gandalf's activity in the Shire and the location of the Ring
2) Saruman has fallen from trying to help the free peoples, and is at best working for himself, at worst working for Sauron
3) The Nazgûl are once again abroad, and are also looking for the Shire
4) Frodo's current plan is to wait until September (3 months) to leave
With Gandalf knowing this information, do you really think Gandalf would meekly acquisce when Saruman asked him to go to the roof of Orthanc? Heck no- the fate of the Free Peoples and his own charge from Illuvatar hung in the balance! There was bound to be a fight one way or another. To give the film-makers credit, they tried to make it a battle of the minds- the wizards used telekinetic powers rather than fencing with staves. This scene just doesn't bother me that much- Tolkien left it up to interpretation, and just because the film-makers' interpretation is different than most people's is no reason to crucify them, IMO (slight exageration there on my part, I know).

Jamesy2-
Of course saying anything in a movie is perfect is silly, that was just a hook to get purists to debate (although Darth Saruman might actually agree with the statement). The point is perfection is in the eye of the beholder- whether or not they were perfect is going to be determined by the individual viewer, regardless of what the film-makers themeselves did. Incidentally, I think that I'm just agreeing here with what you said in the last paragraph of your post.
Way back when I started this thread (six months ago) it was common practice by many on these boards to make blanket statements regarding how poor the characterization was in this movie. In the relatively few instances where people would post specifics with these blanket statements, I felt that they were often complaining about stuff that was in the book. I think that in the course of this thread, I and others have provided quotes from the book which address many of the points you were complaining about. What I think this boils down to is that many of the interpretations of the book which you held going into the movie were different than what you saw on the screen. However, I can't emphasize enough that what you are judging the movie against is an interpretation. For instance, while you were seemingly offended by Gandalf's portrayal, Thorin (one of the purist of the purists, I might add) ranked Gandalf as one of the two characters closest to the book. How can this be? Probably because you two had differing interpretations after reading the books. Given that two purists (I hope you don't mind being labeled as such) can have such differing interpretations, we can hardly expect the film to please everyone with its characterizations. Happily for me, the film crew either pegged my interpretations or, even better, took a different perspective on a character which helped me to understand them in a new way!
 
Well, for Arwen, I suppose I could try stopping my ears and closing my eyes when she appears: after all, she is, and remains, a minor character. About the orcs and the fighting wizards, it still seems sort of out of place, but I don't let it ruin the film on me. The other misfortunes of the film, like Saruman commanding the landslide, are off from the book, but they fit in somehow.
 
Originally posted by Rúmil
The other misfortunes of the film, like Saruman commanding the landslide, are off from the book, but they fit in somehow.

That just got me thinking (uh-oh). Remember Helm's Deep- I believe the clouds came from the East (i.e. Mordor), but Saruman certainly had the ability to command some sort of lightning- they called it 'Fire of Orthanc', or something like that, and it was used to breech the Deepening Coomb. I never put that together with the movie, but maybe it does fit better with the books then I had thought.
 
I must say I can't remember that. I guess I'll just have to pick up Lotr again and read it right through. Hee, hee.
 
{Lifted from MGIWH III}
Hmmm. The books says that Merry and Pippin know exactly what seriousness the quest entails, eh? Let's have a look: Hmm. Looks like Merry and Pippin didn't know what they were getting into, and that this was generally accepted by Gandalf and Elrond. In fact, Gandalf even says that if they did no what was in store for them, they would not dare to go!! There support of Frodo was not done out of any great wisdom on their parts, but purely out of friendship with their cousin. This was what was portrayed in the movie, and it was a Perfect characterization.
 
Granted I spoke haughtily when I said they understood the seriousness of the quest. At the same time, I did say that their bravery was naive. They didn't truly understand what was going or could happen to them. They remained loyal. However, they at least understood what the quest was and where they needed to go. From the intro of M&P to F&S it is obvious that they are clueless. The general scope of how M&P were portrayed taints how the CoE is interpreted. It is the whole picture and not just one instance. If I recall it was Merry that said that Elrond would have to tie them up or let them go. Pippin, on the other hand was used as an idiot for nothing more then cinematic comic relief on Jackson's part. "So where are we going again?" Like the the trip could have been nothing more than a trek to visit the woods of Rivendell.

aragil said:
This was what was portrayed in the movie, and it was a Perfect characterization.
Perfect? I highly doubt it. The best you can say is that regardless, the job got done.
 
Well there's no denying that you might not like how it was portrayed, but I believe that their decision was portrayed correctly as per the books.
{Movie version}
Merry did understand things- in the Shire he immediately understands the seriousness of the Black Riders and that they are after Frodo- Pippin remains clueless about the whole affair. Even in Bree it is Merry who first grasps the concept of a 'bigger' beer, while Pippin goes off blathering about 'Baggins'. At the CoE Merry does get the 'sack' line, as well as Gandalf's line that the necessity for 'a person of intelligence' rules out Pippin. This continues through the end of Fellowship and into The Two Towers. It is Merry who realizes that Frodo has decided to leave the Fellowship, and Merry makes the decision to draw away the Uruk-hai so that Frodo stands a chance of escaping. Likewise, it is Merry who realizes what is at stake with the Ents and Isengard, Pippin is initially content to simply return to the Shire and enjoy the simple pleasures he has always known there. The CoE scene fits in perfectly with this. Merry somewhat understands the dangers associated with the quest (though obviously none of the 9 fully understood the dangers, not even Gandalf). Pippin, on the other hand, is motivated by one thing: friendship. This is one of the great themes of the book, and I for one am very pleased with the way it was worked into the movies. For me the fact that Pippin says a funny line does not detract at all from the importance of this decision!
{Book version}
I find that the book Pippin operates in much the same way- in the journey to Crickhollow he is quite rash in what he says, and it is his loud singing that immediately precedes two encounters with the Black Riders. In Crickhollow it is Pippin who empties the contents of his bath onto Frodo's new floor- the consequences aren't as grave as the stone in the well at Moria, but it is equally indicative of his character. After making the pledge to follow Frodo to Rivendell, it is Pippin who says (in reference to the we must away ere break of day song) "Oh! That was poetry! Do you really mean to start before the break of day?". The pledge was of course very touching, but it is clear that he has no idea what is the import of the trip to Rivendell, nor of the seriousness of the danger which they'll be in. IMO opinion this line is at least the equal of "Great! Where are we going?". Not to say I didn't like it- I liked both lines!!
In Bree it is of course Pippin who begins to tell the story of Bilbo's disappearance (here Frodo thinks of him as 'the ridiculous young Took'), which of course prompts Frodo to sing 'Heyd-diddle-diddle', which revealed the Ring and made the remaining journey to Rivendell so dangerous. At the Prancing Pony Pippin also makes the foolish statement that all of the Hobbits will look like Strider after a few days in the Wilderness, and it is Pippin who calls Frodo 'The Lord of the Ring' while in Rivendell. Pippin's impertinence continues with his ill-timed question to Gandalf at the Gates of Moria (prompting the `Knock on the doors with your head, Peregrin Took' reply), to say nothing of the infamous rock down the well. He grows quite a bit in Two Towers- leaving the leaf-tolken for Strider and engineering the escape from the orcs. Still he nearly manages to bring disaster on the quest when he looks into the Palantir. Even when he arrives in Minas Tirith he has on final shocking bit of foolishness- he is ignorant of the fact that Aragorn is the rightful heir to the throne of Gondor. How did he manage to miss that fact for 30+ chapters??
Simply put, Pippin is foolish (or ridiculous, or any of the other adjectives which JRRT sprinkles on him throughout the books). No wonder Elrond was especially against Pippin joining the Fellowship! He does things without thinking them through, and even when he does think he usually shows a less-than-total-comprehension level. This does not in any way diminish from his joining the quest- he pledges to go out of friendship, and in spite of the horrors of what happens to him he never really considers turning back. But his initial decision to go is certainly not made with the deliberation and understanding of Gandalf or Aragorn, or even Merry. Hence I believe his line in the movie at the CoE is not only funny, but it is quite appropriate.
 
I'm very nearly persuaded. . .

Indeed I am quite convinced, royalstar old Forum-friend, that you deserve to be drawing a comfortable stipend from the huge NewLine moneypile, for exegetical services provided after the fact. Had Fran and Philippa (and PJ, too) brought as much love and lore (which might be otherwise phrased as "sensitivity to, and respect for, the original") to their screenwriting as you do to defending them, Thorin and I would be considerably happier. Your thoughtful explication is almost enough to soothe this dull pain in my ear; can you help me (I'm just teasing, unsure that you can) to feel any better about Frodo's having to three-peat his offer and shout down the Council of Elrond?
 
I'm glad that I can convince someone of something! Newline need not pay me for my seervices. A small role in the upcoming Hobbit will suffice- say Bard or Thranduil. You listening, PJ?

Don't know what you want out of the council of Elrond. PJ chose to play up the dividedness of the 'free-folk'. It is an element quite central to the book (though not as much to the book Council), and it is clearly explained by Haldir in Lorien (don't have the book to quote, but something along the line of ~"In nothing is the joy of the enemy so great as in the estrangement of those who should be united against him").
The lack of unity is so great that the Council disolves into a shouting match. It is the great courage of Frodo (and many people call the movie incarnation a coward) who unites the free people (as represented by sword, bow, and axe) to one common purpose: the destruction of the Ring. Why should he have to shout thrice? I dunno. I like the symbolism of the scene, though- the humble coming forth to disturb the counsels of the mighty. I suppose the triple-shout would then represent in some measure the determination of the little folk to accomplish this task.

On somewhat of a side note, I prefer the 'choice' of Frodo to the book version, where Elrond implies that Frodo himselfwas chosen ("... this task was appointed to you"), so that Frodo's offer to take the Ring becomes effectively meaningless- he'll take it whether he will or no!
 

Yup, that Tolkien. What a nut job. Thank God for Peter Jackson getting the story right. Hoo boy! What was that Tolkien feller thinking?
 
Actually, I never said Tolkien was a nut job. I said that in this particular case I preferred what the film did, and I said it in such a way as to try and indicate that liking the film version better was less likely for me than preferring the book version. Any thoughts regarding what I actually said, i.e. what the film did vs. what the book did in this particular case?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…