• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Did Eru bring about evil?

Well, the King James Version was done by a committee in the early 17th century. It deliberately mistranslated things people were squeamish about, mainly by using (now) obscure euphemisms in relation to sex, sexual organs, and slaves. It also deliberately fudged some wording to make the KJV look more like it supported royal authority. So it was not what we would consider a scholarly translation and it very much had an agenda, or perhaps a couple of agendas, as we would say today.
 
Hypocrisy rampant - why does this not surprise me in the least? (Not that the KJV was the worst mistranslation, I would guess).
 
With respect to Isaiah 45:7, like many things, it depends upon translation/interpretation. Sorry, forgot to jot down all the sources below, but a quick search on the web can unearth the following and more (with respect to similar commentary). First, a bit of context:












And another couple of examples:



 
Last edited:
When an omnipotent being: Eru or just God creates a world it/he/she creates in equal amount creation and destruction, they are as the opposite poles of a magnet and cannot go without eachother.
exemple: when a song is created, silence is broken. As long there is balance there is no trouble - and no story either - when on side goes aacting on its own, you get a Morgoth or Satan.
We can call creation Good and destruction Evil, therefore both have there source in Eru.
 


And/or we can say that creation is good and destruction -- if we are going to call it "evil", is the choice of a Morgoth or a Satan or others -- which to me negates (or at least amounts to "not necessarily") your therefore about "source" -- the very word Tolkien, in his poem (see page one of this thread "not in the source . . ."), uses.
 
It's the problem faced by every theodicy.
And thus unsolvable. As are all circular "arguments".
The problem is assumptions - unquestioned ones (by "believers").
Nothing gets me riled as much as the statement I've heard far too often, that there are "assumptions that may not be challenged".
"Shove it where the sun don't shine", is the only comment that may be fit to be posted here.
Or perhaps not, I do not care …
 
Hi. Ando here. And I'm surprised no one has argued that JRRT's poem (quoted in part by that handsome cat, Elthir) is not part of the world of Middle-earth, and thus, it doesn't necessarily follow that whatever it has to say about evil and God (however it is interpreted) pertains to Eru.

From one of Tolkien's draft letters, dated 1958 (also published in Morgoth's Ring):



I read this as: Creator Eru creates Free Will = allows the possibility of evil. Evil is now possible (not inevitable) and is introduced by Subcreators.

What?
Oh Yeah.
Ahem.

Elthir coloured some words red
and wants me to add that he thinks
this fits nicely with the part of JRRT's
poem he quoted earlier.

I am not surprised that Elthir thinks this
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…