But not before I agree with you about judicial murder: every one of those adjectives, and then some.Arthur_Vandelay said:Now, back to the topic at hand....
I don't think your friend Joyce would be happy about a suggestion that he was Brit/American, and there are other representations there for Ireland, as well as for Australia, Canada, and India. Who would you suggest from the wider world?!
Indy said that it was impossible for Tolkien not to hate because he believed in damnation. His logic was you can't believe it is all right damn someone without hating them. I said by the same logic you can't believe it is all right to execute someone without hating them. Therefore hateful in this sense means "coming from someone who is full of hate" not "causing a person to hate the something (ie death penalty, damnation)."
HLGStrider said:That said a lot of your minor theological points are off too.
According to Christianity EVERYONE has commited a crime at some point in their life.
Inderjit S said:....my original term was a bit of a misnomer....
....claiming that only Christians can be saved from damnation is wrong.
Beleg said:What basic purpose does fiction serve? Escapism, forwarding specific themes relating to social/political concepts or a mixture of them before?
And what is the answer to the basic question of life, the universe, and everything? 42.Beleg said:What basic purpose does fiction serve?
HLGStrider said:I'm old fashioned. I think the main purpose of any sort of writing is to entertain. The reason I write is to make myself and other people happy. I want them to enjoy what they read. . .
But generally literature teachers go so much deeper into that that I think they ruin the love of reading.
Yes, reading should have deeper meaning, convey deeper thoughts, and whathaveyou, but if you don't enjoy yourself it becomes a task, not an experience, and there is no point.
What great good did their erudition do for Varo and Aristotle? Did it free them from human ills? Did it relieve them of misfortunes such as befall a common porter? Could logic console them for gout?
I gladly come back to the theme of the absurdity of our education: its end has not been to make us good and wise, but learned, and it has succeeded. It has not taught us to seek virtue and to embrace wisdom: it has impressed on us their derivation and etymology.... We readily enquire "Does he know Latin and Greek" "Can he write poetry and prose?" , but what matters most we put last, "Has he become better and wiser?" We ought to find out not who understands most, but who understands best. We work merely to fill the memory, leaving the understanding and sense of right and wrong empty..
I am not prepared to bash my brains for anything, not even for learning's sake, however precious it may be, From books all I seek is to give myself pleasure by an honourable pastime...If I come across difficult passages in my reading I never bite my nails over them: after making a charge or two I let them be...If one book wearies me I take up another.
The portrait of the conversations of Socrates which his friends have bequeathed us to receives our approbation only because we are overawed by the general approval of them. It is not form our own knowledge; since we do now follow our practices: if something like them were to be produced nowadays there are few who would rate them highly. We can appreciate not graces which are not pointed, inflated and magnified by artifice. Such graces as flow on under the name of naïveté and simplicity readily go unseen by so course and insight as ours…Socrates makes his soul move with the natural motion of the common people: thus speaks a peasant woman…his indications and comparisons are drawn from the most ordinary and best known of men’s activities: anyone and understand him. Under so common a form we today would never have discerned the nobility and splendour of his astonishing concepts; we who judge any which are not swollen up by erudition to be base and commonplace, and who are never aware of riches except when pompously paraded.
What did he say; and what are these last two postings about?Arthur_Vandelay said:For example, you say:
Inderjit S said:I have also posted the same topic at a literature forum where I have been castigated as 1. someone who wants to burn all of the books I don't understand. 2. an idiot. 3. an idiot. Currently in a debate with, what seems to be, the whole darn forum.
Do Japanese maple trees serve a purpose or are they superfluous and not needed?
This question is overly-fastidious. What is anything and everything?
joxy said:What did he say; and what are these last two postings about?
Is something missing?
Inderjit S said:Do difficult to read authors serve a purpose or are they superfluous and not needed and do they simply pander to the demands of the intelligentsia? Shouldn't literature be able to be accessible to everyone rather then a select few? Authors such as James Joyce and Thomas Mann are notoriously difficult to read-whereas authors and poets such as Maya Angelou, Graham Greene and Toni Morisson as well as existentialists such as Franz Kafka and Albert Camus are pretty easy to read, even if their messages are a little more hidden. ...
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?