• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Incomplete Victory of the Last Alliance: Weaknesss or Inevitability ?

sorry to have split the discussion:

Dang it, Ron -- you've also split my brain! Now I have to reread all the posts on both threads every time, 'cause I can't remember which points were made on which thread!

I can feel myself becoming schizophrenic!
 
Foolish intent is certainly no barrier to invention. Nazi Germany had quite a few inventive ideas.
Its seem that you may have misinterpreted my point. I assert that foolish intention is NO barrier to invention ! (hence the existence of the Uruk-hai). Here is the reason for my Saruman posts in this thread:

Others have claimed that if he made a ring, its powers if put to the test would be illusory, or it would be somehow a counterfeit and therefore ineffective . Others suggest that because he is a deluded imposter and his ring only a poor imitation (fools gold), therefore it couldn't be a ring of power and he was some kind of lightweight player. However, I see it differently: I think that he made a fully-functional, lesser ring of power, he used the ring, he got real value from the ring as evidenced by all his exploits, and he was more than a little dangerous.
In conclusion: he was foolish, he was an imposter, but that foolishness didn’t prevent him from making and using his (Walmart-quality) ring to become truly powerful, thereby causing real trouble for the Wise and Sauron alike.

Hope that makes sense.

Dang it, Ron -- you've also split my brain! Now I have to reread all the posts on both threads every time, 'cause I can't remember which points were made on which thread!

I can feel myself becoming schizophrenic!
Sorry, but i had no idea that thread existed. As you know, this thread was originally about The Last Alliance, and then the discussion took a detour into Nan Curunir ! Is there a way to merge (relocate) posts into more relevant threads ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've seen some old threads where it seems to have been done, but I have no idea how. And it apparently happened to two threads that were begun around the same time, which is not the case here, of course -- that one is a "Nazgul-thread" -- risen once again!

Nevertheless, some interesting points made there, so thanks for reviving it. I think.

I'll just have to try not to repeat myself!
 
Reanimation bragging rights go to Barclay ! But I did post a link in that thread, leading to this one.
 
Oh, right -- see what I mean? I can't keep things straight!

Though that may just be one of my "innate powers". . .
 
Its seem that you may have misinterpreted my point. I assert that foolish intention is NO barrier to invention ! (hence the existence of the Uruk-hai).
I was actually agreeing with your statement, and reinforcing it

Yes, I understood what you were saying, but I still haven't seen anything in the book that leads me to believe he had a ring of power, no matter how weak. I still believe, based on the evidence I've seen so far, that it was just Saruman's innate, or learned, abilities that allowed all of the above. Other than the cross-breeding of orcs, I again refer to Hitler as someone who had the innate persuasive power to do foolish things.

He said he was Saruman of many colors. Maybe he made a mood ring and that made Gandlaf notice it

Umm..my apologies for further confusing this thread, I too seem to have thought I was in one of the ring threads.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…