• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Maeglin vs Snape

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well. Another interesting thread. It's neat when I stay away for awhile.
In the Maeglin vs. Snape debate, now the Good vs. Bad debate, aka the @Alice vs. @Tyelkormo the Fair debate, there is much to be said.
So many questions.
What makes one 'good or bad?' individual incidences, or the 'overall picture' ? Does the 'end' justify the 'means' ? Does the 'final condition' justify the 'life' ?
Clearly Snape did many 'bad' things in his life... and had many desires not consistent with 'goodness' resulting in his behaviors.
This cannot be contested, and one need not read very far regarding matters of Snape to find many of those instances.
Yet he remained on staff at Hogwarts, and to a degree, "in the graces of" the Headmaster. Why was this? Did the headmaster see farther than the rest?
All were suspicious of Snape. Even Dumbledore, at times.
Was it a case of 'keeping your enemies closer' as the saying goes? Or was it a case of keeping one who was 'on the brink of personal disaster close to the light', to aid in his ultimate condition.
Snape (and those around him) present us an unusual and excellent case for study indeed.
There are parallels between Snape and Boromir, Denethor, even Gollum... struggling with who to serve and for what reasons.
What an intriguing personage is Snape.
 

Snape wasn't 'struggling' after he understood that Lily's family was in danger. He was on so called good side for 18 years, since he was 20 years old. And he was on Voldemort's side for around 2 years. From that moment he was entirely on Dumbledore's side and the latter knew it and used Snape for his own goals. And later put his life in danger after asking to kill him. I consider Dumbledore true villain of this book, even Voldemort was less manipulative and less cunning.

And yes, you can hate me as much as you want, but I don't see anything bad in Snape's personality. He always was a good person who made mistake for serving Voldemort and later Dumbledore. And I don't blame him for that. Snape was great and selfless person and I respect him, while Gollum deserves only pity
 
I think some would call me biased to when it comes to Fëanorians, although I still think their case was very different from this. Each to their own, I guess.🤷🏻‍♀️
 
I think some would call me biased to when it comes to Fëanorians, although I still think their case was very different from this. Each to their own, I guess.🤷🏻‍♀️
Yeah you clearly are biased if you are Snape hater but defend Feanorians and their far worse actions. Like people who claim Anakin Skywalker was good and Snape was bad. Snape is harmless compared to most of Silmarillion characters, including Maeglin. Oh but all of them weren't teachers, so I guess it's different
 
They are different because they were fighting in a war, not the child play Rowling called war. And I never said I was a Snape hater, like I'm not a Maeglin hater either, or a marauders supporter. Again, this is what we call morally grey characters. I don't tend to defend Fëanorians for their crimes either though.
 
Then I guess you don't really understand what Silm is about because even Sauron is not considered a complete villain by Tolkien.

All of them are morally grey people with some good in them. According to Tolkien himself, some characters, especially Fëanorians had been viewed unfairly, and if he had the time, he'd have made some changes and I think I see it. Some accounts of events from the Silm doesn't make much sense to my logical side, lay of Leitian being one of them. Silm is told from the pov of Elrond's family, so I guess I get it.

Could be the case for Snape too, now that I think about, since all the book is from Harry's pov if I remember, or just a narrator.
 

Harry hated Snape from literally first time he saw him.

And I am not supposed to agree with Tolkien's opinion on this character
 
Last edited:
Well no one is in a very happy demeanor when discussing Snape.
We could be if everyone worked together. I'm not here for an argument, just a good discussion and a removal of any bad vibes.

You tried to be funny by trying to humiliate me by joking about my grammar?
This was not my intention at all, so I'm sorry you took it that way.

Why don't we start over?
 
Yeah, Snape. But sadly he doesn't exist. Most of good and noble men are fictional, unfortunately. The same with Tolkien characters
I'm sure there are still good and noble men in this world. They're hard to find, but they're out there! They may be hiding in plain sight, doing everyday deeds which change the world one small step at a time! Take heart. 💪
 
I'm sure there are still good and noble men in this world. They're hard to find, but they're out there! They may be hiding in plain sight, doing everyday deeds which change the world one small step at a time! Take heart. 💪
Yes there are. But sadly they aren't valued, like Snape wasn't valued both in fictional and real world. Because real heroes don't need fame or approval.
 
Often, this is so. It reminds me of Aragorn saying to Éowyn before he left to the Paths of the Dead-- "the deeds will not be less valiant because they are unpraised."
Hobbits weren't praised much in books. Oh and I consider Frodo a good person and Harry a bad person. Frodo suffered in the end of the book and couldn't lead a normal and happy life in Hobbiton. He was kind and sensitive enough to grieve many things. While Harry was happy in the end and didn't suffer or blame himself as he should have been, since people were dying for him (Snape was just one of them). That's the difference between them.
 
A lot certainly can be attributed to the worldviews of Tolkien and Rowling. It does make a difference in the themes and morals-- the variability within the work being dependent on the author; hence we read something as "good" or "bad" because our worldview may be similar, different, or the worldview is just universal. Now, this is all very philosophical and flounders into what Ent would call the Religion of Opinion. And, unsurprisingly, another successful derailment of a thread from the actual topic has taken place! TTF, Part 103802893. 😂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…