Well. Another interesting thread. It's neat when I stay away for awhile.
In the Maeglin vs. Snape debate, now the Good vs. Bad debate, aka the
@Alice vs.
@Tyelkormo the Fair debate, there is much to be said.
So many questions.
What makes one 'good or bad?' individual incidences, or the 'overall picture' ? Does the 'end' justify the 'means' ? Does the 'final condition' justify the 'life' ?
Clearly Snape did many 'bad' things in his life... and had many desires not consistent with 'goodness' resulting in his behaviors.
This cannot be contested, and one need not read very far regarding matters of Snape to find many of those instances.
Yet he remained on staff at Hogwarts, and to a degree, "in the graces of" the Headmaster. Why was this? Did the headmaster see farther than the rest?
All were suspicious of Snape. Even Dumbledore, at times.
Was it a case of 'keeping your enemies closer' as the saying goes? Or was it a case of keeping one who was 'on the brink of personal disaster close to the light', to aid in his ultimate condition.
Snape (and those around him) present us an unusual and excellent case for study indeed.
There are parallels between Snape and
Boromir,
Denethor, even
Gollum... struggling with who to serve and for what reasons.
What an intriguing personage is Snape.