• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Osgiliath After the ⚔️War of the Ring

Élhendi said:
You don't have to build a city just so that you can have a bridge crossing the river...
Élhendi,
I promise you, I will write an essay about the infrastructure of Gondor through the years and I will post it in The Halls of Tolkienology. However, I will do it after a month because I have term tests this week.
 
Interesting, I recall reading somewhere that Osgiliath was never rebuilt and that Minas Tirith remained the capital. Maybe in the appendices? I don't have a copy of any books at the moment.

Ingwe, about what you were saying, the rebuilding of the bridge; I agree fully that bridges are one of the most important pieces of infrastructure to rebuild, especially as Gondor's realm would spread and settlers would doubtless begin to move east. The Easterlings would not remain hostile forever surely and trade eastward would be necessary. However, that doesn't mean that 1) the bridge would be in Osgiliath - why not at Cair Andros? or 2) that the city would be rebuilt around it - though logical to rebuild it around any transport route Tolkien may have had reasons for leaving the city ruined or even 3) that Tolkien agreed with our logic, for he may easily have decided that trade east would not benefit Gondor, and while he may have been incorrect in this his word is sort of final.

Of course, we don't have anything definite, which is why until a quote floats to the surface to prove that Osgiliath remained desolate I shall side with Ingwe.
 
Hammersmith said:
Of course, we don't have anything definite, which is why until a quote floats to the surface to prove that Osgiliath remained desolate I shall side with Ingwe.
Well, I can't say anything, but I can use emoticon :

Hammersmith said:
1) the bridge would be in Osgiliath - why not at Cair Andros?
Actually, I can answer your quetion Look at the attachment. Where is Cair Andros? It is norther than the line Minas Tirith - Minas Ithil. There is no road from Cair Andros to the other road around Mordor. If they build the brigde there they will have to build a new road.
 
Of course, we don't have anything definite, which is why until a quote floats to the surface to prove that Osgiliath remained desolate I shall side with Ingwe.
I did provide such a quote, in the 4th post here, from The Stewards, Rotk ("Osgiliath was finally ruined, and its great stone-bridge was broken. No people dwelt there afterwards"); I am curious why it went by unnoticed.
 
Why is it important to have line from Minas Tirith to Minas Ithil? There were noone living in Minas Ithil either!

And as we all can read, Thorondor_ has settled the question, hasn't he?
 
Why is it important to have line from Minas Tirith to Minas Ithil? There were noone living in Minas Ithil either!
If you don't like that passage then just look at this one: There is no road from Cair Andros to the other road around Mordor. If they build the brigde there they will have to build a new road.

And as we all can read, Thorondor_ has settled the question, hasn't he?
Be happy
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…