Last posted by Nenya Evenstar
Thanks again P/F!!! I always enjoy your poems. Pay no attention to the "sappy" criticizer...
Now, I know you where half-kidding here, but I'd like to nitpick all the same.
I don't think critisism should be neglected or ignored, because I personally have gained much through critisism. There are varyinf stages of critisism, some less pleasant than others (constructive, insulting and complimentary, I'd say). 7 expressed the feelings he got while reading your poem (which was touching, I think), and noted that he thought that the religious undertone was a bit too vivid. I happen to agree with him, but nonetheless I would have to say that all critisism is helpful, because it gives the writer and idea of the kind of feelings people get from reading his/her writings.
I am glad you wrote this poem (to somehow commemorate the many deaths that ocurred that day), and would never endeavour to write somthing like it myself, but I think you got a little carried away. The strong religious point of view was not harmful, but I got the idea that you were writing bitterly and angrily. Obviously I, and everybody here, encourage people to express their own opinions and beliefs (poetry is an excellent way to do this); but this poem of yours gave me quite vivid and clear imagery, which would usually be good, but for the angry tone. Perhaps you don't agree, but I think that it is a great
symbol of sadness and anger; I only think that you could have brought out the 'sadness' as well as the anger, and with less personal imagery.
I don't mean to offend, patronize or insult in any way; I call this constructive critisism.
I personally have learned a great deal from the negative/constructive input I have received about my poetry, and I hope you gain something from this little speech.
Evening
Did you taste the wind today,
did you watch it sway the
trees?
And did you feel your conscience stray,
while list'ning to the breeze?
Did you feel the leaves today,
and love their texture green?
Their branches, flecked with silver-gray
enchant when they are seen
Did you sip the lake today,
and feel its current swift?
It runs so deep, so cold and gay
in Nature's mindful rift
Did you touch the grass today,
caress it with your eyes?
And did you see the wind's great fray,
like angel's wings arise?
Did you look beyond the line,
beyond the boundaries?
For now is time for Man's decline,
and quests beyond the Sea