I couldn't decide between the choices, so I voted other.
Elrond and
Arwen
I loved their conversation in TTT when Elrond is trying to convince Arwen to forget
Aragorn and go to
Valinor. I think PJ did a good job of capturing the heartbreak Arwen's choice meant for them.
Arwen and Aragorn
Theirs is such a beautiful love story and it deserved to be shown. It is not an "invention" of PJ's that some people keep on insisting it is *grumble grumble*
Frodo and
Sam
They are completely devoted and loyal to one another, the way best friends should be. Again, I think PJ did a good job of portraying their relationship.
Aragorn and
Eowyn
This was handled much, much better than I had feared from some early spy reports that hinted at a love triangle between Arwen, Aragorn, and Eowyn. Aragorn never waivered in his love for Arwen, while Eowyn fell hard for Aragorn...the way it should be.
Theoden and Theodred
While this was an invention of PJ's, it totally worked. Theoden grieving for his fallen son was a heart rending scene.