• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Should the Fellowship have left Rivendale sooner to avoid disaster?

Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Messages
267
I get that they said that they wanted to make sure that the Nazgul were not still lurking about nearby (a good idea) but they apparently spent about two months scouting and going as far as Mirkwood. In all that time, it was:

1.) Giving Sauron time to get stronger.
2.) They'd have to go through the Wild in the Winter.


I'm curious, did it really take that long for multiple groups going off in different directions to come to the conclusion that the Nazgul had been bested (for now)? If they'd left after one month instead of two, then they could have crossed Caradras or whatever it's name was and not had to go through Moria, and they could have brought Bill the Pony with them. What's more, not only would they have avoided the fall of Gandalf in Moria, but they may have avoided the orcs at the falls of Rauros and avoided the fall of Boromir as well. (Though I think Boromir would still snap, though maybe the fall of Gandalf really pushed him over the edge and maybe he wouldn't have caved at all if the wizard were still present, though if he did fall, it's now up in the air if Frodo and Sam would ditch the company, as they might have sought Gandalf instead.)

What seems problematic here is that:

1.) Since they never encountered Gollum in Moria, he never would show them the way around the Black Gate.
2.) It's possible that if Merry and Pippin weren't taken by orcs, that the good guys wouldn't have arrived in time to save Rohan from Saruman.
3.) Moria would still have the Balrog.


At any rate, despite the perhaps long term benefits of the disaster at Carahdras, the short term plan of waiting so long to set out from Rivendale seems foolish to me. Even Bilbo thought it a bad idea.
 
All of this is actually adressed in the book. Yes, they are aware of all the issues, but they had to make sure Nazgul won't ambush them immediately upon leaving protection of Rivendell. And they couldn't go blind in general. So they had to wait for the scouts to return, and that took time.
 
I think they waited winter for 2 reasons:
1) It's easier to go on winter unnoticed by spies of Saruman and Sauron.
2) It's better to start of with winter while you're strong and fresh, and end up tossing the ring somewhere in the summer or autumn, then opposite.

Apart from above, as mentioned, they wanted to make sure Nazguls were not close, and I will add that probably Frodo wound needed to heal more. The fact that Frodo was in the council of Elrond, doesn't mean his wound was in the state that he could leave Rivendell soon.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top