• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What have you been doing lately? Your current writing project?

Are there any specific expectations for posting fanfiction here? (I'm wondering because my fanfiction kinda goes back and forth between the books and movies). Is it preferred that I stick to book canon?
 
Awesome. I am just a bit wary because I've had people totally tear me apart for writing movie fics instead of book fics. Eek.
 
That sort of behavior is not tolerated here.
Yeah it's kinda a problem on fanfiction net... people do that. Always anonymous, of course 😑 it was pretty disappointing because it was my first fanfic and I warned everyone that I was just being creative and I knew it was, well, fiction. 😂
 
It is a shame people tend to be very judgmental about others' creative works, not taking into consideration the love and time the author put in. Sure, not everything is for everyone, but there's no need to attack it and tear the author down. It's meant to be for fun, people!

Now, here on TTF you will find lots of general conversations of people passionately discussing the books vs. the movies (we don't allow foul language or bullying, thankfully), but when it comes to fanfics things are pretty chill. Many of us write fanfics for The Silmarillion, and there are several from other eras too, closer to LOTR. Even some role plays kind of take on the form of being like a fanfic too (mainly for us Elves in the Silm here 😂). From everything I've seen, when it comes to commenting on each others' stories, we're all pretty encouraging and friendly. And don't take it personally if you don't always receive feedback; people are often busy, or maybe they haven't seen it. Not everyone here on the forum reads fanfics. Still feel free to keep posting your story, though! We love people to share their creativity and passion for Tolkien!

As you'll see in the Red Book of Westmarch, what you can do is create a thread for your story (and since you're the author, only you can post in it), and then if you want to allow for feedback, you can create a discussion thread for your story. If you take a look at the fanfics already posted there, you'll get an idea of what this looks like, and maybe even find some great stories to read! 😉

Oh, and besides FF.net, maybe you could try posting your stories on Archive of Our Own (Ao3). I actually like it better than FF.net, and find it to be a nicer community generally. Several of us post our stories on there and seem to have no problems. Good way to get your stories out there, and maybe you'll find even more people who appreciate your movie/book-based fanfic. I, for one, love both the movies and the books, so I wouldn't argue against a fanfic blending the two together. 😁
 
Yeah I tend to blend the books and movies together because, to me, it's all become part of what we consider middle earth. I mean, if you've watched the movies and don't like them, the images will still be in your head, right? I'm a very visual person so I hold the movies dear even though they are well.... what they are. 🤣 Because for me, I see a scene from the movie and for five seconds, I'm in middle earth. If that makes any sense. Because there are things about the movies, random little moments, which I feel are really good. 😍
Besides, if you don't own the copyright there's only so much you can complain about, right? 😆😆
 
Are there any specific expectations for posting fanfiction here? (I'm wondering because my fanfiction kinda goes back and forth between the books and movies). Is it preferred that I stick to book canon?

I don't think there are any 'canon-cops' in the Red Book of Westmarch. I think Fan-fiction by its very nature is given a wide berth as far as 'canon' goes. I've read a few alternative timeline/world-crossover Middle Earth fanfics, and some that have modern welfare incorporated into Middle Earth battles, so I don't think you'll have any issues with Tolkien book/movie crossovers.

In my Middle Earth story writing, I tend to take one of the summarised scenes Tolkien gives us in the book appendices and develop it out from there (Kin Strife; Division of Arnor; Cardolanion Royalty, etc.). I make attempts to color within the lines of book canon, but there are always certain tweaks working their way into the story that pushes the edge or slightly exceeds those lines.

Stories in the Red Book of Westmarch forum can only be posted to by the author/thread-starter, so there will not be any interruptions from others posting in them. A separate thread can be opened in the 'Discussion' sub-forum to discuss stories. These are usually opened by either the story author or a story fan. There may be some criticism, but as the Squinty-eyed Southerner says, negative 'bashing' is not tolerated here.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…