• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190

Iarwain ... may indeed include a superlative (old-est), or maybe mean 'Old-new' according to David Salo, compare Narwain "New sun" (Sindarin *gwain)

Ben-adar (lenited from *Pen-adar ... cf PEN 'lack, be without") "without father"

Anyway ... I dunno if anyone posted the following yet from Letters but if not, into the mix (if so my apologies. Hey 16 pages!):

"There is no 'embodiement' of the Creator anywhere in this story or Mythology." JRRT

"The One does not physically inhabit any part of Eä." JRRT

" ... the One, of God, who indeed remains remote, outsde the World, and only directly accessible to the Valar or Rulers." JRRT
 
Last edited:

Thats what i always think. He just seems to exsit. He has the love of his life with him so what should he care about . a ring that Sauron needs to enslave everyone ? Nah!! Course not. he seems to me like a jolly old fellow that gives enjoyment to millions like me.
Tom is the best! (aplaude's please!)Lol
 
If I had to place Tom Bombadil as belonging to some race or being one person, I'd say he was Illuvatar (sp?) watching his creation and subtly helping some people. Since Tolkien explicitly stated that Tom Bombadil is NOT Illuvatar, I guess Ill have to accept it.

If Tolkien had written down all is opinions on controversial topics (i.e. Balrogs wings, Tom Bombadil, the Two Towers, etc.), what would we discuss??
 
Why doesn't Tom Bombadil turn invisible when he puts on the ring?

I was wondering how come the ring has no effect on Tom Bombadil. Also, how come it seems that he has some sort of control over the ring. It is said that the ring has power over all living things so is Tom living? What exactly is Tom? Has he more power than Sauron? The ring doesn't even tempt him.


"It seemed to grow larger as it lay for a moment on his big brown-skinned hand. Then suddenly he put it to his eye and laughed....THen Tom put the Ring round the end of his little finger and held it up to the candlelight. For a moment the hobbits noticed nothing strange about this. Then they gasped. THere was no sign of Tom disappearing! Tom laughed again, and then he spun the RIng in the air and it vanished with a flash."
 
well, during the council of elrond, someone (i think gandalf) says that the ring has no power over him; he's 'his own master'. so i think it just means that he's such a free spirit that it can't tempt him- and he doesn't care about gaining power. he just wants to be in his own house in the woods with goldberry, making his own way and not getting involved in the affairs of others. as for what he is, i have no idea. i think he just has the power of the earth in him... or something to that effect... well, this prolly didn't help, but hey, i tried right?
 
It's really hard to answer.It's believed that Tom is one of the Valar or Maia who stayed after The War of Wrath in ME.I suppose that Valar and Maiar are in power of the ring.For example when Frodo put the ring on his finger Sauron can see him and Sauron was Maia.I'm not sure whether my idea is correct but anyway......
 
Tolkien left Bombadil as an enigma. As such I don't think there can not be any real answer to the question other than Tolkien's own in the Council of Elrond:

 
Why do you think that Tom is Valar? Gil-Galad. I just find i strange for a valar to settle down in a place and just sitt there. I think that Tom is just mysterious, something that we know nothing about, neither Valar nor Maiar.
 
Well it's said that after The War of Wrath some Valar and Maiar decided to stay in ME.Now I don't have much time to find where is written(cause I'm too lazy ),but I remember that fact.
Actually Tom has strenght which only a Maia or a Vala would have.There was a post about Tom and his wife and it was said Tom is Vala or Maia try to find it and read it.
 
Gil-Galad,
I honestly don't believe that Tom is one of the Ainur,he is IMO simply a spirit of the earth,something that was intended to exist
from the very beginning,similar to Ungoliant
And he certainly cannot be one of the Valar/Maiar who remained in ME after the War of Wrath(if indeed any did remain) because Tom states that he was already there when the Elves journeyed West (from Cuivienen),that he was there before the river and the trees and so on....
So Tom was there before any of the Ainur entered Arda.
 
This is a good example of what I call the "what the factor"
Every writter worth his/her ink will intentionally put something in his/her work that causes the reader to step back and wonder.

There are two reasons why nobody knows why the Ring does not effect Tom.
1. Tolkien himself did not know.
or
2. He knew, but he's not telling.

Personally I prefer #2. I like to think that he sat in his Oxford study and thought, "this'll get em".


RD
 
I personally think that bombadil is infact the (or an) incarnation of illuvatar there is quite alot of evidence to suggest thi. I wouldnt mind debating this with someone but i forsee it ending in a stalemate
 
Tom bombadil

what, who is he? I saw an essay somewhere that said he was he one. What do you guys think? Ive always personally wondered what he was. Hes not that important in the story except to show that the ring does not have power over every one. But why does the ring not have power over him?
 
I've read all the research on Bombadil, but not this topic... so forgive me if i say anything that was already said.

I have 3 theories:

1) He was one of the Dwarves of Aule, but was given life before all the other Dwarves. Perhaps this is unknows to everyone else because it was an Iluvatar-Aule only secret. This is only a weak theory though.

2) Bombadil was Melkor's first creation and the only good thing Melkor made (probably meant to assist Melkor in furthre creation). When he says "Before the 1st Dark Lord" he probably means that he was there BEFORE Melkor turned dark.

3) Bombadil was an offspring of Melkor's thought (also before he turned dark). He was perhaps created when Melkor sang not in harmony with everyone else and he was just... there... in the void. Until Arda was created.

Anyway, both of my stronger theories have to do with Melkor. IMO it's the only real reason to explain everything that was said in Tolkien's works... so, yeah.
 
Tom in The movie??

So why the hec wasn't Tom in the movie?? I know he doesn't have that much of an important part to the entire story....but still. Tom is damn cool.....I would have loved to see him in the Fellowship movie. Also, The Downs would have been cool too
 
Re: Tom in The movie??


Because Peter Jackson thought there wasn't enough time for him with everything else he had added in.
 
Tom Bombadil - Fasinating Fellow "Bright Blue His Jacket Is and His Boots Are Yellow"

Ever since my dad read the Lord of the Rings trilogy to me, I have always had a fasination with the creature Tom Bombadil. He is probably the most unique character in LOTR. He is neither man nor hobbit nor elf nor wizard. Yet he obviously has a great deal of authority and power in a unique way. The ring has no hold over him. Laughter is his weapon and joy is his shadow. Some say he is ridiculous. I say he his cares do not way heavy on him and he finds pleasure in all aspects of his simple life.

What do you think about him?

~Ariana
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…