• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
Tom's (and Goldberry's for that matter) mysteriousness is the most appealing feature of his. Some people find him irritating and annoying but to me he's just swell.
 
Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel


Upon what do you base these beliefs? How do you know that what you are saying is true?

Well, I base them upon real life experiences, and upon several years of intensive religious exploration (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism and Taoism)...

How do I know that what I'm saying is true? Well, what I'm *SAYING* isn't true -- the words are just symbols that communicate in a limited fashion. Beyond the words is the meaning... trees throbbing with life, flowers of brightest shades, the beautiful melody of a spring day... In every day experiences, my way of living is validated.

As for my beliefs? Well, beliefs are tools. Use them while they are useful, while they resonate with meaning. When you've used them, and learned, and grown, often times, you then outgrow your beliefs, and acquire new ones to learn from, use, and outgrow...

So I wouldn't claim that my beliefs are true -- but my whole body resonates with the world around me, and I feel almost constantly in harmony with all of my surroundings. This in stark contrast to how I might have felt about things, say, 15 years ago.



Well, having had a good father, I can tell you now that a good father doesn't just 'lay down the law'. A good father finds ways to help his children understand WHY the law is the way it is -- not just "Do this -- or you will BURN FOR ALL TIME." That's a bit of extremist parenting, if you ask me.

Now first of all: The Bible as a document did not exist when Jesus was alive, although the Old Testament itself was in existence in the Judaic religion. So are you saying that everyone who lived before the Bible was created (first instances of a -codified- Bible seem to come from Roman times -- several hundred years after Christ was crucified) is at this very moment burning in Hell? Isn't that a bit extreme, considering that there WAS no Bible to follow? How about the vast majority of humanity that WASN'T in Palestine to receive the Old Testament or the words of Christ, etc. during this era? Are THEY burning in Hell because God made them Chinese or Ameri-Indian instead of Semitic?

I just don't know that I can really believe that the Bible is God's ONLY communication to mankind. Especially considering that God's presence is OBVIOUS (well, at least to me ) in texts such as the Koran, the Bhagavad Gita, the Dhammapada.

God IS a Gentleman (and a Lady, I suspect ) -- and gentlemen don't condemn you to eternal damnation with no chance of redemption. A gentleman is inclined to give an individual a chance to learn from his/her mistakes, and to make redress in the world with his/her improved perspective on life...



I *definitely* have SERIOUSLY contemplated death, not to mention having witnessed it in several less than savoury circumstances.

The only scientific and valid conclusion one can have about death is "I don't know", however. As I said before, I have no idea really what happens when we die, and even if I *would* be inclined to believe in reincarnation, or the Heaven/Hell dichotomy, I would have no basis on which to claim it to be truth.

Actually, I think that death is a great mystery... I have watched people as they pass from this life, and it is a *great* mystery. I have seen my grandfather, whom I roomed with until his death, slip away peacefully into the night, and I've seen a person decapitated on a motorcycle when the guy had to slam on his brakes because a car cut him off (the biker wasn't exactly driving "smart", either -- WAY too fast in traffic) and he flew off and hit the freeway guard rail... My aunt died from a brain tumor and her ashes are now in the Atlantic...

With my Grandfather, he heard my Grandma Bella calling to him, and he said, "Coming, dear..." and passed away. I'm inclined to "believe" that she DID come for him, with the grace of God... but I don't KNOW, of course!

Scientifically, there is far more to indicate that we simply go to the dirt when we die... of course, science grows, changes, evolves as we learn more about the universe, so it may come to be that it is just as likely that we go to Heaven/Hell, or are reincarnated once we discover some scientific 'key log' that allows us to explore these concepts more...

But I just don't really know...! I *HAVE* experienced real ghosts, but do I know how to explain them...? Are they really *spirits* of people, or maybe echoes, or is my brain interpreting a natural force that it can't quite comprehend in the only way it can...?

I just don't know.



I don't think it -- I experience it, feel it. Live it. I would say that it is NOT a possible (or at least: probable) concept that before there was time (a false concept in and of itself based upon our limited comprehension of 4 dimensions of multi-dimensional space) or life that there was an intelligent, omnipotent, omniscient being who created time, the Earth, the Universe.

First of all, there IS the Universe. The scientific concept of the Universe is that it encompasses *ALL*. By definition, this includes God. So therefore, even if "in the beginning", there was "just" God, then we would say that "God is the Universe". If God creates everything else, etc... "God is STILL the universe -- and so is the rest of it too."

God IS the Universe. The Universe IS the Universe. The Universe IS God.

This has absolutely nothing to do with the utter mess of New Age religious belief. It is -scientific observation- of external and internal influences of life. A very personal experience that I am communicating to you.


All indications lead me to the understanding that human suffering is based upon a false sensation of isolation that is utterly ridiculous. You are never any more alone -- or NOT alone -- than you were at any given moment in the past, present, or future.

Many people who "believe" in God can actually tell you of no experiences of God... and many people who "don't believe" in God can tell you of experiences that were quite "sacred"...

What's going on here? What is going on is that every sunrise is an ABSOLUTE miracle that almost *demands* our participation. Every flower that opens. Every child that speaks it's first word...

These are MIRACLES, and are no less significant than someone who walks on water, or creates much from little. To experience these miracles with a truly open heart -- one at that moment touches God.

Most of us don't understand this, so we start taking things like the Big Dipper, ice cream, good music, the United States, etc. for granted... we allow our mental construct to create a programmed response, instead of giving our all and getting it all in return.

Likewise, war, pain, famine, murder -- doom. These are all likewise from God, and are likewise miraculous, albeit terrible from the human perspective.

Yes, my experiences lead me to feel that you and I, and everything else, are all little bitsy-witsies of God all "playing together" in the universe. God IS the Alpha and the Omega -- and everything in between.

But WE make up the bits of God in between. And why that is, I don't know, and what the point is, I don't know, but that is certainly my -personal- experiences to this point.

Peace to you, and all.
 
Hi, Tyaronumen! I was just reading this debate that you and Ariana are having and was going to add my two cents worth in. Hope you two don't mind.

Originally posted by Tyaronumen

How do I know that what I'm saying is true? Well, what I'm *SAYING* isn't true -- the words are just symbols that communicate in a limited fashion.

I'm not trying to be mean or rude, but I must admit I am lost. Why would you state that what you are saying is not true? I understand your next statement but I do not see it validating this one... could you explain?


... In every day experiences, my way of living is validated.

What are you basing your standard for living on? On every day experiences? Is any person's life validated simpy by their everyday experiences?



...beliefs are tools. Use them while they are useful, while they resonate with meaning. When you've used them, and learned, and grown, often times, you then outgrow your beliefs, and acquire new ones to learn from, use, and outgrow.

So having a belief in anything is just a step in the ladder... an ever on-going evolution of thoughts that changes and grows as the mind grows. This is what I understood from your statement above. What happens, then, to the beliefs that "resonate with meaning"? The meaning becomes void once we have learned all we can from it? Why then did we spend the time to believe those beliefs that resonated with meaning if the moment we've grown and learned what we can, we "outgrow" them?

I wouldn't claim that my beliefs are true.

You have eternity at stake here and you are not even willing to go as far as to claim that your beliefs are true?



I do not doubt that you had a good father. In fact, you might have had the best father any young person could have asked for. But your father was not God, nor was he omnipotent or omnipresent, nor could he step outside of time and look at eternity as a whole. Ariana seems to be a Christian and if I understand Christianity correctly, this is true for God. So, comparing your father to Ariana's God is a little steep. Besides that point, I have read the Bible, and although there is some blind obedience asked of people, more so than not, God seems to have had some good reasons for saying what He did. If you had read the Bible, you might have also noticed this.



Wonderful question! In fact, I think this is one that gets Christians tripped up alot. I would love to answer it, but in order for me to do so, you will have to answer this question of mine: What will you accept as evidence?


So you are saying that because it is "OBVIOUS" to you that God is present in ALL of these books, that makes it so? Even when books like these contradict each other? I am sorry, but if "God" really was present in ALL of these books, I think I could pitch "God" out the window for being a lier.


You have made the statement several times that you really don't KNOW what truth is or that if what you are saying is true (in fact you denied it), so to make a statement like the one above seems a little odd and out of character. As for as "gentlemen" are concerned, have you ever encountered any gentleman who could span the entire universe in the palm of his hand, or simply speak creation into existence??? Neither have I, so I would not be so hasty as to lable God a "gentleman". Is He gentle? YES. Is He a "He"? YES. God does not condemn anyone to eternal damnation. We condemn ourselves. He created us all with the divine ability of a thing called "choice". And He did provide a way of redemption... He came down in the form of a man and lived among men and died by the hands of those He had created. He also rose from the dead and conquered death so that those of us that CHOOSE Him, would have a way of escaping eternal damnation. So in a way, you are right. God does not condemn anyone.



No, you wouldn't have any solid conclusions because you only believe what you beleive until you have decided it no longer "resonates with meaning".

With my Grandfather, he heard my Grandma Bella calling to him, and he said, "Coming, dear..." and passed away. I'm inclined to "believe" that she DID come for him, with the grace of God...

Here you referred to God as a personal someone who could give grace...

God IS the Universe. The Universe IS the Universe. The Universe IS God.

...And here you refer to Him as everthing... impersonal and vague. What is your evidence for making the statement above? That is a pretty definite conclusion to come to, especially when you claim you do not know what is truth.


I agree. It is because of the fact that I am only the CREATION and not the CREATOR that I cannot comprehend it. I am limited in my dinky little brain... I cannot fathom SCIENTIFICALLY a God who can exist outside of time and space and who has the past, present, and future in His hands. That is simply too much. That is why He gave us a little gift called faith.
By FAITH...


A soldier in a POW camp who is starving is suffering only because he has a false sensation of isolation?

Likewise, war, pain, famine, murder -- doom. These are all likewise from God, and are likewise miraculous, albeit terrible from the human perspective.

No. these things are not from God and I will debate this issue till the cows come home if you want to. God did not intend for there to be War and Sickness and Hunger and Pain on this Earth. But Man messed things all up. As a result of Adam and Eve's sin in the garden, we have a corrupt and filthy world that is steeped in evil. That is why there is suffering. We brought it on ourselves.


You can "feel" like the earth is square or that the Sun is the biggest star in the sky or that eating ice cream day in and day out is healthy, but that does not make any of it true. TRUTH is absolute and so it cannot simply be felt. It is.

Peace to you, and all.
I am sorry, but there is no peace in uncertainty. You have stated that you do not know what is truth, or what happens when you die, or what God is, or what on earth we are doing here on this earth... there is no peace in any of that. True peace lies in the assurance that Christ died for every soul and then rose again from the grave. True peace is resting with in God's plan for your life and holding on to Him... because He is the only thing that was always there, and that will always be there for you.

So I would ask you to think about what you yourself have said about what you believe and decide what is TRUTH... your eternity hangs on that decision.

-me
 

Because words are imperfect, and cannot completely communicate 'reality' or 'truth'. The word 'orange', when referring to the fruit, points you to the idea of a spherical object with a somewhat pitted surface that you peel to reveal a fruit within that has wedge-shaped pieces, etc. etc. Basically, the word 'orange' only indicates meaning, and only contains meaning because of our common vocabulary. But the word does not necessarily have meaning in and of itself. That's why I wouldn't say that I'm stating 'the truth'. There are many ways to state 'the truth' that are equally valid or invalid, using different combinations of words that approximate meaning.

What I'm really trying to say is that I make no special claim that my particular combination of symbols, words, etc. is any more true than any other combination of symbols, words, etc.



What are you basing your standard for living on? On every day experiences? Is any person's life validated simpy by their everyday experiences?

I would say so. To me, it is more valid to self-evaluate to judge how successful one's personal life choices are for oneself than to try to fit into a cookie-cutter template from the psychiatrist, books, etc.

Obviously, there will be some who feel that their life choices are VERY valid for themselves, even though many others may feel that their choices are very wrong... that is one of the quandries of life.



If the meaning becomes void, then so be it. If the belief continues to be of service in your life, providing a framework for operating, etc., than so be it.

Why ask why? People believe what they believe in -- there is not necessarily a *good* reason for it. But it is certainly possible to have new experiences that help one to realize that certain beliefs are valid, not valid, or lead to new beliefs, or back to old ones, etc.



You have eternity at stake here and you are not even willing to go as far as to claim that your beliefs are true?

In the face of eternity, it is hubris to claim such. Just because everything that I personally have experienced indicates that my experiences are valid (and that, only personally) does not give me the right to claim that my experiences and beliefs are 'true' or 'the truth'.




Hey -- Ariana compared God to a 'good father'. I just ran with it.

As for 'stepping outside of time', how can you step outside of something that doesn't exist in the physical universe outside of mankind's perception of the progression of events? Scientifically, the concept of 'time' that we humans commonly carry around simply does not exist.

If you can look at eternity as a whole, then you are not looking at 'eternity', you are looking at something else.

I HAVE read the Bible -- thank you very much -- and have noticed an awful lot of blind obedience being asked for, also. A lot of the 'good reasons' are left unsaid for your local pastor to interpret.


Wonderful question! In fact, I think this is one that gets Christians tripped up alot. I would love to answer it, but in order for me to do so, you will have to answer this question of mine: What will you accept as evidence?

To be fair, I don't know. I generally will entertain as evidence anything that has some sort of factual, observable base.

I'm definitely interested in what you answer, though...!




Hmmm -- instead of realizing that God's interpreters simply write in the same context that they live...?


I don't think it's odd, nor out of character. I'm speaking from my own experiences of things -- and make the careful caveat that my own experiences are NOT synonymous with an objective 'truth', necessarily, and that I have no desire of representing it as such.

My experience of God is that (S)He is a gentle-person. Your mileage may vary.

I agree with you when you say that God does not condemn anyone to eternal damnation. I also agree with you that we condemn ourselves.

However, nothing I've experienced leads me to believe that He came down as just ONE man, nor that this one man rose from the dead, etc. In fact, *scientific* knowledge makes it quite clear that Jesus 'died' *FAR* more quickly than anyone else being crucified in such a fashion in those days (according to Roman information, it took around 3 days to die by crucification), so I would tend to wonder whether he was actually dead in the first place.

Also no indication that there is eternal damnation/reward -- any more than there is an indication that there is reincarnation, or nothing at all...

So I can't really comment on those.

NOTE: This reply got a bit long, so I had to split it into two parts!!
 
Last edited:
 
i voted for other because to me he seems like a mix of each.
 
I find in interesting that this was never mentioned:

Gandalf was a Maia, and he couldn't see Bilbo or Frodo with the ring on:
Source: A Long Expected Party


Tom B could see Frodo...but Gandalf couldn't....

What does everyone else think of this?
Just to add some fuel to the fire, and get this thread moving again.

P.S. Cian, please PM me
 
Last edited:
In a "Characters from Tolkien" book, wich is pretty much an encyclopedia of Tolkiens works, under the topic of Maiar, it sais:


He was therefor a Maiar, but with an unknown past.
 
who wrote the book that you got that quote from? because if it wasn't Tolkien himself or his son or someone else he was very close to, I don't believe it, I think that a lot of things put in books related to Tolkien's works but not actually written by him or his son have made up things in it, they are unreliable.
 
Yes, that's probably just the opinion of the author. Tolkien even said that Tom B was an enigma. We're left to guess.
 
well, i think it would help if i read the book. because i have no idea who he is!!
 
Re: The Witchking of Angmar

I found this theory under 'Crackpot Tolkien Theories' on The Tolkien Sarcasm Page :

The Truth about Tom Bombadil
From a rec.arts.books.tolkien posting dated 3 May 1996.
At last, the mystery of Tom Bombadil's identity has been solved.
Ready?
Tom Bombadil and the Witch-king of Angmar are the same person.
1. We never hear of Tom at all during the whole of the First Age. The Nine Rings aren't forged until the Second Age. QED.
2. You never see the two of them together.
3. In the first part of Fellowship of the Ring, the Nazgul are sent to the Shire to look for the wandering Baggins. Interestingly, Tom says to Frodo at the dinner-table: "...I was waiting for you. We heard news of you, and learned that you were wandering... But Tom had an errand there, that he dared not hinder" (Fellowship p.137 hardback, emphasis mine: note the fear Tom has of his master, Sauron!).
4. In Tom's questioning of the Hobbits, JRRT notes that "there was a glint in his eyes when he heard of the Riders." (Fellowship p. 144) I think he was concerned that his double-life might have been noticed. Interestingly, Tom immediately changes the subject of conversation!
Furthermore, the One Ring had no effect on Tom - which seems consistent with Tolkien's observations about how the Nazgul would have handled the same priceless object (Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, #246): "They were... in no way deceived as to the real lordship of the Ring."
5. It's also interesting to note that Tom could see Frodo clearly while Frodo was wearing the Ring (Fellowship p. 144 hardback) - just as the Witch-king could see Frodo clearly while he was wearing the Ring at Weathertop! (Fellowship p. 208 hardback)
6. Perhaps most damning, however, is the incident with the Barrow-wights (Fellowship pp. 151-155), where Tom - with nothing more than a few simple words (p. 154) - commands the Barrow-wight to leave. And it does, without argument. Why would the Wight be so completely under Tom's control? Because in his alternate guise as the Witch-king of Angmar, Tom ordered the Wight to inhabit the barrow in the first place! Turning to Return of the King, Appendix A, p. 321, "evil spirits out of Angmar... entered into the deserted mounds and dwelt there." Obviously the Witch-king was reponsible for sending the wights there; just as obviously, the Witch-king (disguised as Tom) would be capable of ordering them to leave!
(This is related to another passage, which has since been brought to my attention. On Fellowship page 158 hardback, Tom is guiding the Hobbits back towards the Road when he gazes towards the borders of Cardolan. "Tom said that it had once been the boundary of a kingdom, but a very long time ago. He seemed to remember something sad about it, and would not say much." Since Tom, as the Witch-king, was the one who destroyed the kingdom of Cardolan, it's little wonder that he wouldn't say much about his involvement. Perhaps his remembering "something sad" reveals some remorse at being the instrument of Cardolan's destruction...?)
...Yep: I think we have an airtight case here.
...It's worth noting that, after the Witch-king was dead, Gandalf said he was "going to have a long talk with Bombadil" (Return of the King, p. 275). Curiously, he never tells anyone about the meeting later... and he's right there at the Grey Havens at the end of the book, undelayed it seems by long conversation. I think we can therefore theorize that Gandalf made it to the Old Forest, but that Tom (once the so-called "Witch-king" had died) was nowhere to be found!
...Of course, all this brings up the curiosity of motive. What would make the Witch-King of Angmar sport such a double identity? I suppose that the Witch-king, once of proud Numenorean ancestry, felt trapped by the guise of evil which Sauron had tricked him into, and in the fullness of time forged this alternate identity for himself so that he could occasionally feel happy, helpful, noble, and more at one with himself and his lineage. The situation is perhaps analagous to a crossdresser who, feeling trapped in a man's body, would occasionally assume the identity of a woman. It therefore makes sense that the Witch-king's other identity would be so peculiarly enigmatic, and perhaps sheds light on JRRT's observation in Letters #144: "And even in a mythical Age there must be some enigmas, as there always are. Tom Bombadil is one (intentionally)."
...Who else would be aware of Tom's double-life, I wonder? Since Tom repeatedly claims to have been around "before the river and the trees", and indeed even claims to be older than the Ents (Fellowship p. 142), surely the eldest of the Elves would know he was lying. Elrond plays along with Tom in public, being kind enough not to reveal his secret, but also seems to know that Tom and the Witch-king are one and the same; hence his refusal to give the Ring to Tom for safekeeping (Fellowship p. 278-9): "Power to defy the Enemy is not in him."
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…