(While I have read a good deal of the previous posts on this question, I did not get to all of them, so forgive me if this has already been said)
The possibility of
Tom being a
Vala or
Maia is a very attractive one to me and I think a decent case can be made with
Aule as the culprit, as has been done so nicely here. However, we have to take into account everything
Gandalf says about Tom at the
Council of Elrond.
When asked if Tom might take
the Ring to keep it safe and hidden, Gandalf says he would not take it unless "all the free folk of the world begged him, but he would not understand the need. And if he were given the Ring, he would soon forget it, or most likely throw it away. Such things have no hold on his mind. He would be a most unsafe gaurdian."
It seems, to me, unlikely that a Vala or Maia, especially one who was so involved in the creation of the world (Aule), which seems to require a certain attention to detail and understanding of how things work etc., would forget something, even a small thing, of great importance. As the rulers, creators, and guardians as chosen by
Eru, the
Valar should not be forgetful. For someone like Aule, who cares much for the Children of Iluvater, forgetting that the Ring is dangerous would be like forgetting
Sauron exists. For me, the fact that Tom "would be a most unsafe guardian" proves that he can not be Aule.
Now, there is the fact that
Manwe is incapable of comprehending
evil, which coincides nicely with Tom not understanding the need to keep the Ring safe. I originally had something concrete to disprove any connection between the two, but I seem to have forgotten it. In any case, I still think that Tom's carefree and forgetful nature would be uncharacteristic of a Vala.
(Looking back, it's a little rambling, but I hope coherent. Anyway, that's my take on Tom.)