• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What race would you be if you were to live in Middle Earth???

What race would you be if you were to live in Middle Earth?

  • Man

    Votes: 23 21.1%
  • Elf

    Votes: 45 41.3%
  • Dwarf

    Votes: 7 6.4%
  • Hobbit

    Votes: 28 25.7%
  • Eagle

    Votes: 9 8.3%
  • Ent

    Votes: 6 5.5%
  • Dragon

    Votes: 10 9.2%
  • Ainu

    Votes: 12 11.0%
  • Wraith

    Votes: 4 3.7%
  • Orc

    Votes: 3 2.8%
  • Dragon

    Votes: 4 3.7%
  • Balrog

    Votes: 2 1.8%
  • Other

    Votes: 2 1.8%

  • Total voters
    109
They are Immortal Merlin, because they are fallen elve kings, so it never says anything about their immortality being taken away.
 
I wouldn't say their imortal, since they are dead in a way.. They are not living beeings, they are ghosts..
 
But they can't be immortal. They're Men. Even wit the rings, Sauron would not have had the power to override Iluvatr's Gift.

Also, I don't get that they're not alive but exist as ghosts either, although this is the most tempting way around the problem. Unfortunately, the example of Gollum and the teachings of Gandalf argue against it. Gollum never died and turned into a ghost, and Gandalf stated that possession of the Ring would cause one to fade and become wraith-like, just like the Ringwraiths. His implication was that that would have been Bilbo's ultimate fate - even if it was put off for many years because of Bilbo's innate Hobbit toughness.
 
I'd definately be a Hobbit, I went to a fancy dress party as Frodo in the summer coz everyone was telling me how hobbit-like i am!

It's true I'm small (5'3"), have brown , curly hair, a large red mouth that's prone to laugh or smile alot and I often just want to crawl back to my hobbit-hole and sleep! Or eat six breakfasts and then make lunch!
 

I don't think Gollum had the Ring long enough for it to "wraithify" him. Bilbo certainly didn't. I don't know how long the Nazgul bore their Rings, but I think it's safe to say it was either for a longer time than Gollum, or Sauron sped up the process to allow them to become wraiths. They probably went through similar phases- first like Bilbo when he was covetous of the Ring, then like Gollum, then wraiths.
And I don't think that they were ghosts, per say; they weren't actually dead, and had not left the world. However they were permanently invisible and had lost all contact with the worldd save their bond to Sauron and the Ring. This makes them ghosts, in essense.
 
Hi, i'm new here, and i thought this would be a good question to answer first time...

The race i'd most like to be would be an eagle, because they are not at all afraid of goblins and wovles. And are really smart and get to live in the misty mountains. Plus, they are also one of the good guys.

If i wasn't a eagle the i think i'd be a wizard.

Bye...
 
I must say it is nice to see someone reverting back to the origanal topic Just joking, now as for my take on the Nazgul being immortal, here it is.


i would be forced to say that they are only alive due to the fact that the ring is still in essence, in other words the RingWraiths will stay alive for as long as the Ring is in creation.
If we look @ The Return of the King, we see that when the Ring is destroyed so are the Nazgul. So that is my take on the subject, no theat they are immortal, just that the have something keeping them alive
 
I would be a dragon and wast those stupid wraiths,or I'd be Hurin
and keep all the dragon gold!


"And out of the blackness came many eyes"
 

When I was a kid, I used to think that I would *love* to be an Elda... and I'm sure that I would -- but as I've grown older, I've become very comfortable with the "Fate of Men", which is as mysterious in real life as in Tolkien's works. I am glad to be who I am, I guess.


Not ghosts -- but "wraiths" (don't hit me. )... That is to say that they have not truly *DIED* per say... but their spirits are tied to the world because of the will of Sauron (via the nine rings) and they linger just on the edge of death as long as their Master and the Nine Rings exist.

EDIT: I believe, in further thinking, that the terms Tolkien uses (can't quote, I'm afraid) are 'stretched' and 'thin'.... Frodo found this happening to himself to a degree late in his stewardship of the Ring.
 
I think that being a hobbit would be cool, but they live such uneventful lives, i would rather be a race that lived with a little more danger, had a little more fun. I would proably want to be an elf.
 
Why does no one want to be a dwarf, the working class of middle earth.

That out of the way, dwarf would be tied for with hobbit for second.

I would want to be from Westernesse, a man of Anor, a rider in the grey company. They are exceptionally long lived, but don't tire with life like elves. They are one with nature, but can travel far an wide, unlike ents. They can enjoy beer and a good time at the prancing pony, sing with elves and wander.

That is the life for me.
'foots
 
Well, I'm another newbye here. Hello to everyone.

Well, I gues i would be an elf, but one of the elves that live in the forests with Galadriel (Dammit, i can't remember the name of that forest at all... ) because they are almost one with the nature, they don't have as much problems as the High Elves and because of Galadriel, of course .

See You

Salva
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…