Originally posted by Mithrandir.
Hi I am new and wanted to get involved. So I wanna know what race you would like to be in ME. Elve Man Hobbit????? Anything and anyone. I love these books and read them all the time. This is a really cool place to talk w/ other LOTR "geeks". So c ya.
When I was a kid, I used to think that I would *love* to be an Elda... and I'm sure that I would -- but as I've grown older, I've become very comfortable with the "Fate of
Men", which is as mysterious in real life as in
Tolkien's works. I am glad to be who I am, I guess.
Originally posted by Iluvatar
But they can't be immortal. They're Men. Even wit the rings, Sauron would not have had the power to override Iluvatr's Gift.
Also, I don't get that they're not alive but exist as ghosts either, although this is the most tempting way around the problem. Unfortunately, the example of Gollum and the teachings of Gandalf argue against it. Gollum never died and turned into a ghost, and Gandalf stated that possession of the Ring would cause one to fade and become wraith-like, just like the Ringwraiths. His implication was that that would have been Bilbo's ultimate fate - even if it was put off for many years because of Bilbo's innate Hobbit toughness.
Not ghosts -- but "wraiths" (don't hit me.
)... That is to say that they have not truly *DIED* per say... but their
spirits are tied to the world because of the will of Sauron (via
the nine rings) and they linger just on the edge of death as long as their Master and the Nine Rings exist.
EDIT: I believe, in further thinking, that the terms Tolkien uses (can't quote, I'm afraid) are 'stretched' and 'thin'....
Frodo found this happening to himself to a degree late in his stewardship of the Ring.