• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Trekky Thread, going where we have been before, or something like that

I LOVED the new Star Trek !!!

It was great !!!

Khan still ranks as my favorite Trek movie but I may have to put the new Star Trek (Star Trek XI) as possibly my second favorite !!

Anybody who has not yet seen it - PLEASE DO - it is worth the money !!:D:D
 
Alas, I won't be able to see it until next Friday, so go ahead and discuss, guys. I won't hold you up, I just won't look in here again until I've seen it. Can't wait! :D
 
K, so, just a mild, barely a spoiler at all subject in case she accidentally looks back . . . did anyone else really loathe that one scene where Kirk got chased by the yeti beast and the fleshy red beast on the ice planet? I found that scene completely pointless and rolled my eyes through the whole thing. Did they just need something to fill ten minutes? Something for a video game tie in? Something because the CGI guys didn't have enough crazy stuff to do?
edit:
Oh my gosh! I just said crazy. Yay is getting to me.

Actually, the fact that I use the word crazy and automatically assume Yay is getting to me when it is actually a fairly common word I have every right to use without channeling Yay suggests that I simply have been on this forum too long. . .
 
Originally posted by HLGStrider
did anyone else really loathe that one scene where Kirk got chased by the yeti beast and the fleshy red beast on the ice planet?

LOL! Strider, you are a riot. No, I enjoyed it.

I would have rather seen the big monster graphically (with blood) eat the smaller one (giving it way more to eat than little Kirk), but it reminded me of some of the campy fun in The Original Series.

My only gripe is something that most of you probably wouldn't care about. Considering I do the astronomy thing, the whole supernova thing bothered me. I know it's just Star Trek, but this was just too much for me to deal with. Even with a theoretically "larger than life" supernova, the damage they do is local; and would have to be within (at the absolute maximum) 40-50 light years for them to physically hurt a planet. Past that, they can't even change the shape of a fragile puffy white cloud high in the sky. For a supernova to destroy a planet (vaporize it), the planet would have to be actually orbiting the star that explodes. Even from a light year away, an unrealistically HUGE supernova can't wipe out a planet. And remember, our galaxy is 100,000 light years across. To me, the idea of a supernova taking out a whole galaxy even crosses the line of Star Trek fantasy science. Too much :rolleyes:.


That was the only thing that "hurt me" to watch. I was very restless in my chair; kind of like Kirk in the beginning of "Generations":

Scotty - "Captain, is there something wrong with your chair?"

Other than that, it exceeded my expectations by light years. Definitely seeing it again next weekend (by myself this time - so I might have more to gripe about :D).
 
K, so, just a mild, barely a spoiler at all subject in case she accidentally looks back . . . did anyone else really loathe that one scene where Kirk got chased by the yeti beast and the fleshy red beast on the ice planet? I found that scene completely pointless and rolled my eyes through the whole thing. Did they just need something to fill ten minutes? Something for a video game tie in? Something because the CGI guys didn't have enough crazy stuff to do?
edit:
Oh my gosh! I just said crazy. Yay is getting to me.

Actually, the fact that I use the word crazy and automatically assume Yay is getting to me when it is actually a fairly common word I have every right to use without channeling Yay suggests that I simply have been on this forum too long. . .

I can't say I was bothered too much by it, but it did irritate me a bit. However, it was for a different reason. It reminded me WAY too much of the Gungan Sub scene in Star Wars: The Phantom Menace, you know, the "there's always a bigger fish" scene? WAY too similar. I think, if I had to find a reason for the scene, that it was a more dramatic way to introduce the **SPOILER** older Spock into the story. Kirk was unlikely to walk into the cave unless it meant his life. He knew there was a base on the planet, and we can assume that's where he was headed. He's "too tough" to have stopped in the shelter of the cave. Had I been in charage, I would have had Spock waiting for him at the base, have him be the one to greet Kirk at the door instead of that really cheasy little alian. You know?

As far as the "crazy" thing...I think we're all missing Yay's constant presence on TTF. Using "crazy" is a subconsious reminder of our friend. Where is that bigger anyhow???

My nitpicks:

* That they set the whole movie up to demand a sequel. While yes, the actors have signed on for two sequals, everyone knew that this movie was going to either create an entirely new generation of Trekkers, or it was going to flop terribly. And I would have been SO mad if it did flop, leaving so many loose ends.

* I was not all that impressed with the casting for Scotty. Everyone else, but not so happy with Scotty. Granted, he had the least diologue, so any luck, he will develop to my approval over the course of the next two films.

* The bad guy...does this look like a Romulan to you? :confused:

Okay, that should start me off. I'm hoping to see it again while its still in theater, but $$$$$ is always tight, so we'll see. I may have to wait till it comes out to rent to see it again. :(
 
Illuin said:
I would have rather seen the big monster graphically (with blood) eat the smaller one (giving it way more to eat than little Kirk), but it reminded me of some of the campy fun in The Original Series.
See, I thought that was what would happen and it would end the sequence. Kirk gets chased by big monster. Big monster is eaten by bigger monster. . .

Of course, Fir is right, they had to drive Kirk into the cave somehow. I would've personally had him fall in through a crevice or something while backing up from the bigger monster crunching on big monster bones.

I really didn't know what to think of the (SPOILER)




Spock/Uhura thing. Of course, a Kirk/Uhura thing would've been unbearable and I feared that was coming, but still it just didn't seem to fit with the Spock I've always kept in mind. I kind of like how Spock kissing her rather deflated Kirk after all that flirting he had been doing, but Uhura had such a professional thing going on the bridge . . . now to have her "involved" kind of changes another dynamic.

Also, uh . . . wasn't Vulcan always there before? The resettlement explanation only partly works.

And, uh . . . didn't Kirk have a brother? Where does that fit into his family life as posited by this current movie?

Partially, though, involving Kirk's family life, I'm just glad the House chick got screen time. Sorry, Cameron/Morrison. You are the House "Chick." You will always be the House Chick.

Yeah, the Romulans were weird. In fact, I totally missed they were Romulans until the attack on Vulcan. In that opening sequence I am not sure if it was mentioned, but if it was it went right over my head. . . and does anyone really buy that that huge thing was once a "Mining Vessel?" When did he have time to refit it like that? Sometime in between Romulus going BOOM and reaching the other side of the black hole apparently. Vulcans, too, were a little to mono-chromatic. We all know that there are black Vulcans (Tuvok), so why were all the pod-educated Vulcans little dark haired white boys? That said, I loved that shot. It put you right into the society.

K, now those are my complaints.

Honestly, I really liked Simon Pegg as Scotty. I didn't think I would, but I did. He doesn't really look the part, but he is believable in the part to me, and that kind of overrides the fact that he is a stocky blond.

so much of what I saw on screen was awe invoking though. I ooohed through a lot of the movie.

My brother kept on moaning that they didn't use the theme music. They threw it in at the end, but by then you wasted a lot of opportunity to stir up some nostalgia.
 
Originally posted by HLGStrider
Vulcans, too, were a little to mono-chromatic. We all know that there are black Vulcans (Tuvok), so why were all the pod-educated Vulcans little dark haired white boys? That said, I loved that shot. It put you right into the society.

lol.gif


It's so interesting to see that people watch movies like these with a completely different set of eyes than others. It takes multiple viewings for me to notice the intricacies of the characters in sci-fi movies. I'm too focused on the science and the space stuff. I was a little disappointed in the lack of "shock moments" in the film. The reason Wrath of Khan was so intense is because it was like a horror movie in parts - like when they first boarded Regula I and the dead bodies kept popping out at you. I jumped out of my seat a few times. It was like Halloween or Alien in some scenes (and of course, the Ceti Eel Larvae :D). I like movies with 'good taste' (i.e. no unnecessary bad language or stupid sex stuff), but I do like a little shock and a few disturbing scenes to balance out the overall tone. The very first encounter with the Borg had that effect (disturbing). This was a bit too "light" in my opinion. But no worries, Éomer made up for any of my complaints :D; and on the whole - like you said before - it rocked!
willy_nilly.gif
willy_nilly.gif
willy_nilly.gif
 
Illuin, please tell me you've watched the Firefly series. If not, you must. It's right up your alley.

Elgee,

I do agree about the Scotty thing. Yes, he did play the part well. I'm just more of a visual person and I couldn't SEE Scotty. And I love Scotty. Almost more than Bones. In order, I'd say for me it's Bones, Scotty, Spock, Kirk, Chekoff, Uhura, Sulu. Favorite to least. Not that I dislike any of them. :rolleyes:

Of course, Fir is right, they had to drive Kirk into the cave somehow. I would've personally had him fall in through a crevice or something while backing up from the bigger monster crunching on big monster bones.

*giggle* I love being right! ;)

Spock/Uhura thing. Of course, a Kirk/Uhura thing would've been unbearable and I feared that was coming, but still it just didn't seem to fit with the Spock I've always kept in mind. I kind of like how Spock kissing her rather deflated Kirk after all that flirting he had been doing...

Oh yea! Bleck. I was a bit annoyed about that myself. Kind of like that Caspian/Susan thing in Narnia...oh bad. Soooooo bad. :eek::mad: I really don't think it was nessasary, first off, and that they only put it in there because they are Hollywood and had to have someone getting snogged. Second, while yes I would have also been revolted if there had been a Kirk/Uhura thing...but...Kirk always gets the girl. That's part of what makes Kirk, Kirk. Heck, even in The Voyage Home, Kirk gets the chick from the past (Dr. Gillian Taylor). There was what - two origional shows with romance that had nothing to do with Kirk? :rolleyes:

. . . and does anyone really buy that that huge thing was once a "Mining Vessel?" When did he have time to refit it like that? Sometime in between Romulus going BOOM and reaching the other side of the black hole apparently.

Well, if I remember correctly (and I usually do), the *spoiler* older Spock mentioned something about how while it was only minutes for him going through the black hole thing, it was years for Nero. Years of floating around the galaxy, waiting for the right time and place to strike at Spock and get his revenge, blah, blah, blah...Probably stopped by Remus (very uncivilized people who don't ask many questions) to pick up some stuff that goes BOOM...and walah! The timeline is that Nero arrives on the day of Kirk's birth, he kills Kirk's dad, etc, etc, life goes on. Years later, when Kirk is all grown up and causeing more mayhem than his dad, Nero reappears. There was only one black hole, prior to the end of the movie, so Nero had what - 20 years to beef up his little mining vessel?
 
I get your point, but what I am referring to is that first scene where Nero takes on the Kelvin with his working man's machine. Not only does this monster ship have the ability to totally destroy the Kelvin (albiet an outdated ship by Nero's standards), but it can survive a full on collision with the Kelvin? Huh? K, so I guess the dang thing is just that big.
 
**SPOILER ALERT**

*spoiler alert*

Although I LOVED Star Trek XI - I think I may need to see it again because I got a bit lost with the time traveling.

Nero went into the past - before the birth of Kirk - destroyed The Kelvin - thinking he would find Spock at that time ?

Then he hung around for 25 years waiting for Spock ? then I got a little lost by Spock traveling to/fro the past/present.

So, history was changed - Kirk's father died when he was an infant and would not be around to encourage him to enter Starfleet as the elder Spock told the young Kirk in the cave??

Anyway - I loved it. I thought Chris Pine did a great job adapting the Shatner/Kirk swagger. And I loved the mention of the Korbiyashi Maru test (from Star Trek II/Khan).

If anybody can clear up the time sequences for me :( - I would appreciate it :eek:
 
**SPOILER ALERT**

*spoiler alert*

Although I LOVED Star Trek XI - I think I may need to see it again because I got a bit lost with the time traveling.

Nero went into the past - before the birth of Kirk - destroyed The Kelvin - thinking he would find Spock at that time ?

Then he hung around for 25 years waiting for Spock ? then I got a little lost by Spock traveling to/fro the past/present.

So, history was changed - Kirk's father died when he was an infant and would not be around to encourage him to enter Starfleet as the elder Spock told the young Kirk in the cave??

Anyway - I loved it. I thought Chris Pine did a great job adapting the Shatner/Kirk swagger. And I loved the mention of the Korbiyashi Maru test (from Star Trek II/Khan).

If anybody can clear up the time sequences for me :( - I would appreciate it :eek:

First of all, the "red matter" was created as a means to suck in a supernova that was going to destroy Romulus, correct? It was never intended to be a time traveling devise, it just happened to work out that way. Older Spock sets it off, too late, Romulus is destroyed, and both Nero and Spock get sucked into the hole, only to come out in the past, we can guess years apart. Nero gets to the other end first, happens to run into The Kelvin, which he destroys because (again, we can guess) he's mad with grief, and it is a Federation vessel, from the Federation that in his mind is to blame for his loss.

At some point (again, guesswork) Nero realizes what year he is in, and decides to just wait around for Spock to grow up, so he can kill him (why he didn't hunt down Spock the moment he was born I don't know!). His fight with James Kirk only comes around because Kirk has a knack for getting in the way of the bad guys.

About the time Spock of the movie's present grows up, Spock of the future pops out the other end of the red-matter-black-hole thing. :confused:

Older Spock gets involved, the story goes on. History, of course, was changed. I suspect that by the end of the third movie, older Spock will have returned to his own time, as will Nero, causing history to somehow repair itself and bring Kirk, Spock, and the others to the future that we know as "The Original Series".

Did I miss anything?
 
I suspect that by the end of the third movie, older Spock will have returned to his own time, as will Nero, causing history to somehow repair itself and bring Kirk, Spock, and the others to the future that we know as "The Original Series".

I don't know about that. I kind of expected this to happen in the first movie, to have a "Year of Hell" (the Voyager two parter) ending where they destroy Nero's ship in such a way (I figured a Kirk suicide run into it . . . like his dad . . . or Janeway in that episode, for that matter) that it reset the timeline and everything goes back to normal. To continue that as a story arch over three movies, to me, would just be cumbersome. Also, they are trying to fix things up with Spock and Vulcan in different ways (the Vulcan settlement and Spock coming to terms with . . . well . . . Spock in that very UnStar Wars, "I am not our father" moment). It seems to me that they are making an alternate timeline for this Star Trek to fit into which will run opposed to the old timeline and therefore they won't need to be so careful getting every single detail exactly right.

Sort of like that alternate universe in the Original series episode that came back in DS9 when Kyra (spelling? It's been awhile) got transported through a transporter accident and found herself faced with herself, or whatever.
 
Originally posted by HLGStrider
To continue that as a story arch over three movies, to me, would just be cumbersome. Also, they are trying to fix things up with Spock and Vulcan in different ways (the Vulcan settlement and Spock coming to terms with . . . well . . . Spock in that very UnStar Wars, "I am not our father" moment). It seems to me that they are making an alternate timeline for this Star Trek to fit into which will run opposed to the old timeline and therefore they won't need to be so careful getting every single detail exactly right.

Sort of like that alternate universe in the Original series episode that came back in DS9 when Kyra (spelling? It's been awhile) got transported through a transporter accident and found herself faced with herself, or whatever.

Have to agree here 100%. Very similar to my thoughts on this (good - now I don't have to type anything :D).

320x240fd.jpg


And don't forget:

800pxspockanduhuramakem.jpg


:D
 
Illuin you lazy arse. Type your own opinion (and back me up?! ;))

I don't know that. Part of what I thought was the hype of NOS (New Original Series, as I've taken to calling it) was that it was to supplement TOS, therefore it needed to fit. You know, all the high expectations and such?

OR...:eek:...maybe we'll get to the end of movie three and they'll show that it was just (William Shatner) the REAL Kirk having a really long dream about an alternate past because Spock did some weird mind-meld thing...I don't know. An idea. :rolleyes:
 
Patrick Stewart is the reason Star Trek became huge. He is the reason Star Trek went from being “moderately popular” to being warped into the stratosphere! Kirk, Spock, Data, McCoy, Scotty, Riker, Chekov, Worf, Jorde were all incredible, but Picard brought to life an in-depth character that can not be duplicated. No cinema or TV can ever replace the unique magic of Star Trek (especially “The Next Generation”). One viewing of the episode “The Inner Light” will convert all naysayers.

You aren't serious, are you?

Star Trek was HUGE way before Patrick Stewert ever heard the word "enterprise"......

The original casts were legends even before they started making movies soon after Star Wars, which all happened way before Stewart.
 
Originally posted by Bucky
You aren't serious, are you?

Star Trek was HUGE way before Patrick Stewert ever heard the word "enterprise"......

The original casts were legends even before they started making movies soon after Star Wars, which all happened way before Stewart.


Well, let me rephrase it a little differently. What "The Next Generation" did for Star Trek's popularity is exactly what "In The Dark" did for The Dead's popularity :D. The fan following was already there beforehand, but the "cult barrier" was broken, and it universally exploded.
 
I'm pretty sure most of us have seen this before. A friend emailed it to me almost a decade ago, but for some reason tonight lines from it kept going through my head so I decided I needed to look it up. Here it is so you may now get it stuck in your brain too.

If Dr. Seuss wrote for Star Trek: The Next Generation...

Author: Dave Fuller

Picard: Sigma Indri, that's the star,
So, Data, please, how far? How far?

Data: Our ship can get there very fast
But still the trip will last and last
We'll have two days til we arrive
But can the Indrans there survive?

Picard: LaForge, please give us factor nine.

LaForge: But, sir, the engines are offline!

Picard: Offline! But why? I want to go!
Please make it so, please make it so!

Riker: But sir, if Geordi says we can't,
We can't, we mustn't, and we shan't,
The danger here is far too great!

Picard: But surely we must not be late!

Troi: I'm sensing anger and great ire.

Computer: Alert! Alert! The ship's on fire!

Picard: The ship's on fire? How could this be?
Who lit the fire?

Riker: Not me.

Worf: Not me.

Picard: Computer, how long til we die?

Computer: Eight minutes left to say goodbye.

Data: May I suggest a course to take?
We could, I think, quite safely make
Extinguishers from tractor beams
And stop the fire, or so it seems...

Geordi: Hurray! Hurray! You've saved the day!
Again I say, Hurray! Hurray!

Picard: Mr. Data, thank you much.
You've saved our lives, our ship, and such.

Troi: We still must save the Indran planet --

Data: Which (by the way) is made of granite...

Picard: Enough, you android. Please desist.
We understand -- we get your gist.
But can we get our ship to go?
Please, make it so, PLEASE make it so.

Geordi: There's sabotage among the wires
And that's what started all the fires.

Riker: We have a saboteur? Oh, no!
We need to go! We need to go!

Troi: We must seek out the traitor spy
And lock him up and ask him why?

Worf: Ask him why? How sentimental.
I say give him problems dental.

Troi: Are any Romulan ships around?
Have scanners said that they've been found?
Or is it Borg or some new threat
We haven't even heard of yet?
I sense no malice in this crew.
Now what are we supposed to do?

Crusher: Captain, please, the Indrans need us.
They cry out, "Help us, clothe us, feed us!"
I can't just sit and let them die!
A doctor MUST attempt -- MUST try!

Picard: Doctor, please, we'll get there soon.

Crusher: They may be dead by Tuesday noon.

*COMMERCIAL BREAK, COMMERCIAL BREAK
HOW LONG WILL THESE DUMB ADS TAKE?*

Worf: The saboteur is in the brig.
He's very strong and very big.
I had my phaser set on stun --
A zzzip! A zzzap! Another one!
He would not budge, he would not fall,
He would not stun, no, not at all!
He changed into a stranger form
All soft and purple, round and warm.

Picard: Did you see this, Mr. Worf?
Did you see this creature morph?

Worf: I did and then I beat him fairly.
Hit him on the jaw -- quite squarely.

Riker: My commendations, Klingon friend!
Our troubles now are at an end!

Crusher: Now let's get our ship to fly
And orbit yonder Indran sky!

Picard: LaForge, please tell me we can go...?

Geordi: Yes, sir, we can.

Picard: Then make it so!


Copyright © 1995 Dave Fuller.
 
I for one have never heard that before! ROFL!! :D

Thanks for posting, that's fantastic! I think I may actually save a copy of it!
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top