• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Drawing Thoughts on Idril Picture?

ZehnWaters

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Messages
1,673
I came across an artist (Morgan Rogers) and she reimagined Idril Celebrindal, taking her epessë literally. Presumably Idril lost her feet to frostbite in the crossing of the Helcaraxë (she IS stated to go barefoot) and has silver prosthetic feet for a replacement. It's...kinda steampunk, which I don't like for Tolkien, but I DID like the thought behind it. What do you all think?

e771f3daa3cf93ff955b2ccccbf9da71d67990e3.jpg
 
It is quite creative in its aim, but the face doesn't seem to quite fit, and the futuristic-looking prosthetic feet completely ruin the feeling of the image in my opinion. More fitting for a fan-fiction time-travelling LOTR character than an established canonical character, even if there is good reason for it.

That said, some of her other LOTR art looks amazing.

Thanks,

ArnorianRanger
 
My ex-wife? (She used 'Idril' as an online name and even had vanity license plates on her car)
As far as the actual character, it misses the mark a lot in my opinion.
 
It is quite creative in its aim, but the face doesn't seem to quite fit, and the futuristic-looking prosthetic feet completely ruin the feeling of the image in my opinion. More fitting for a fan-fiction time-travelling LOTR character than an established canonical character, even if there is good reason for it.

That said, some of her other LOTR art looks amazing.

Thanks,

ArnorianRanger
Yeah, it's a clever idea but it's out of place. I just thought I'd share.
 
... Presumably Idril lost her feet to frostbite in the crossing of the Helcaraxë (she IS stated to go barefoot) and has silver prosthetic feet for a replacement. ...
IIRC that bit about going barefoot is from the time in Gondolin - though after going through the page-references in the published "Silmarillion I have not found any mention of it.
At any rate, in my mind it runs counter to JRRT's view of the Elves - and I would think very especially those returning to Middle-earth from Valinor! - of being so immensely more resistant to hurts of all kinds than Humans, and recovering from non-lethal ones far more swiftly. Think of Legolas thousands of years later, going about only in light shoes, including in that snowstorm on Caradhras - and he was certainly not a Noldo fresh from Valinor.
 
IIRC that bit about going barefoot is from the time in Gondolin - though after going through the page-references in the published "Silmarillion I have not found any mention of it.
At any rate, in my mind it runs counter to JRRT's view of the Elves - and I would think very especially those returning to Middle-earth from Valinor! - of being so immensely more resistant to hurts of all kinds than Humans, and recovering from non-lethal ones far more swiftly. Think of Legolas thousands of years later, going about only in light shoes, including in that snowstorm on Caradhras - and he was certainly not a Noldo fresh from Valinor.
True.
 
*SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE* I LOVE MORGAN ROGERS' SIL ART!! Recognizing that their headcanons are not necessarily my headcanons, I LOVE how adventurous they get with their headcanons and I LOVE that they are allergic to drawing Elves with shoes. The CONVICTION in that is just. *chef's kiss*
 
*SLAMS HANDS ON TABLE* I LOVE MORGAN ROGERS' SIL ART!! Recognizing that their headcanons are not necessarily my headcanons, I LOVE how adventurous they get with their headcanons and I LOVE that they are allergic to drawing Elves with shoes. The CONVICTION in that is just. *chef's kiss*
Hey! Good to see you back HobbitGirl! It's been what... five years?

I've certainly seen weirder stuff! 😅
Damn... yes... some weird stuff. Found this on a search for Idril artwork with the captain of 'Idril and Tuor with newborn Erendil.

eef1ef679065f23054bc4f3a2775042e.jpg
 
I think you mean "duplication". 😄

But this thread's fine.

Of course, if we start having a separate thread for every character, this place is going to get a bit crowded. 😅
 
Last edited:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top