- Joined
- Jun 28, 2022
- Messages
- 5,019

If I can get some audio recordings of these projects, would you guys like to hear them?
I had heard about this from the ill-lustrious Maedhros, and was going to send you a PM congratulating you on the discovery. Now I'll just do it here.Yesterday I went with @Maedhros_Nelyafinwë to her voice lesson
Your composition is astounding, and has touched me very deeply. 😂I'm sure we would, but give me a little time to work up some parameters with the other admins and get them posted here.
Being a family site, and having 'religious and political' guidelines/restrictions, we'd likely need to consider some restrictions.
(Personally, I think it would be terrific to be able to post stuff here for review, suggestions, the 'aww' factor, etc. But we'll see.)
Meanwhile, I came up with this stunning composition all on my own last night with my new piano. (Actually, I stole it off the internet. 😁)
View attachment 33531
Cool, thank you sir!OK, for @Andromadus the Invictus and the rest, the verdict is in.
We have the Prancing Pony, where members can showcase their musical art (as well as other art) already in place.
Feel free to post your creations, recordings, and/or personal work/accomplishments there, and let our Music thread here know it's up so we don't miss it.
Just keep in mind all the usual 'rules' - needs to be family-friendly stuff, not 'unseemly', not contrary to the political and religious guidelines etc.
(This does NOT mean a religious or political song can't be posted, as long as the purpose is to showcase your achievement/accomplishment/composition or whatever. But sometimes some of them may, I fear, be just "too much" for general public consumption. We need to be sensitive. We may recall on the news recently for example, reports about the singing of a certain political song regarding a certain country, which created quite a stir. of course, the purpose there was not to showcase talent, but to show support - yet it did not go over well with many at all.)
We look forward to seeing you all in your creative elements..!!
I keep forgetting to ask Finno about this, but I would love to! (Maybe we could attempt Angel 1 and Angel 2 from GOC? 👀)@Fingon_Findekáno - i connfess. I got reallllyyyyy selfish once.
I asked @Maedhros_Nelyafinwë, when I found out you two sang together at times, if you could team up some day and do a recording for me of O Holy Night - one of my all-time favorite songs.
So.. IF the opportunity ever areises and you have a very few minutes to spare in the next 9 or 10 years, and it showed up, I'd be REALLY appreciative..!
If not, that's OK too. 'Twas just a thought.
I'll be playing it myself on the piano here soon, working out my own accompaniment etc. to produce my own 'favorite version' so... no real need. Just selfish of me, as I say...
What a fun idea! “O Holy Night” is one of my all-time favorite Christmas songs as well. The version my church used in the Nativity scene for the last several years when we did our big annual Christmas show was absolutely gorgeous, being the Annie Moses Band one. Very classical sounding, and the choir parts were custom written for our church by the band itself. Paired with the scenery (and random singing goats 🤣), it was one of my favorite songs to sing.@Fingon_Findekáno - i connfess. I got reallllyyyyy selfish once.
I asked @Maedhros_Nelyafinwë, when I found out you two sang together at times, if you could team up some day and do a recording for me of O Holy Night - one of my all-time favorite songs.
So.. IF the opportunity ever areises and you have a very few minutes to spare in the next 9 or 10 years, and it showed up, I'd be REALLY appreciative..!
If not, that's OK too. 'Twas just a thought.
I'll be playing it myself on the piano here soon, working out my own accompaniment etc. to produce my own 'favorite version' so... no real need. Just selfish of me, as I say...
Thank you for discussing it.random singing goats
Yes, it would be fun to attempt the angel parts! (Is that high note really only an A5? It felt higher to me.)I keep forgetting to ask Finno about this, but I would love to! (Maybe we could attempt Angel 1 and Angel 2 from GOC? 👀)
In our church's Christmas show every year, they have this gorgeous arrangement of O Holy Night by the Annie Moses band. We sing in the choir, but there are these two duet parts that are very high. I believe the high note is an A5 for one of them. (I could probably do that because A5 is part of my comfortable range, for the most part.)
Haha! I’m sure you would sound better than the goat, Ent!Thank you for discussing it.
You see - the above part would be me if I sang it. A "random singing goat."
I'm sure your voice can't be that bad...I feel the whole thing would be very Tolkien. I can't imagine him missing an opportunity to sing O Holy Night at assembly..!
(Nor missing enjoying a random goat trying to steal the show. Sounds very like his sense of humor to me.)
There are those who do say I have a 'good voice' - but I think it's been after they've been in their cups a bit too long.