• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

🐴 This movie now has 80% positive review score by audience on Rotten Tomatoes

herlig9

Active Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2021
Messages
804
I didnt realise its the same director who made "Eden of the east" which wasnt a good anime but it also was so massively insane that it did leave an impact on me.

But basically, my opinion on movie. It was alright, didnt love it, but i had fun time seeing it on release in cinema. (Which judging by box office wasnt a huge hit)
But on Rotten Tomatoes, audience seem to rate it 81%.

 
I haven't seen WotR, so take everything that I say with a pinch of saly, but I'm noticing a trend recently of decent-alright stories getting huge support from audiences. For instance, I thought Baldur's Gate III was a good game, but audiences and articles were treating it like it was, quite literally, the greatest game ever made. I suspect if it had been released 10 years ago (graphics notwithstanding of course), the reaction would have still been positive but not nearly as "Oh my gosh this is the greatest game I've ever played in my life!" as it was.

What I think is happening is that, since 2015, people have gotten so used to media released by big companies as insultingly terrible, r-selected drivel that anything that they make that has even an ounce of earnestness about it suddenly seems to be a sparkling diamond in a puddle of mud.

Most of what I read now is actually free fanfiction that came out before the dreaded 2015 singularity, and it's orders of magnitude better than almost all of the media I used to pay good money for that came out after that point. I do sometimes wonder what effect it would have on the global economy if a larger number of people worldwide came to this realisation.
 
Certain the decline has been widely (but not universally) noted noted in many film genres - SF, superhero, fantasy (Dr Who, Star Wars, Star Trek being those I am most familiar with). I dread the occasionally threatened but hopefully never realised reboot/reimagining/sequel/prequel to my all time favourite, Babylon 5. And has anyone made a romantic comedy post pandemic?

Why was 2015 significant, do you think?
 
Certain the decline has been widely (but not universally) noted noted in many film genres - SF, superhero, fantasy (Dr Who, Star Wars, Star Trek being those I am most familiar with). I dread the occasionally threatened but hopefully never realised reboot/reimagining/sequel/prequel to my all time favourite, Babylon 5. And has anyone made a romantic comedy post pandemic?

Why was 2015 significant, do you think?
2015 was when a confluence of factors all hit at the same time. Smartphones being universally adopted was one (you could see its effects on global mental health, such as rates of anxiety and depression, begin to hit in 2008). This lead to a whole host of other things, where things like social media were programmed to harvest peoples' time like massive Skinner boxes, and this bled into even storytelling and media. Take Star Wars like you mentioned; the film that came out in 2015, The Force Awakens, seemed to exist almost entirely as an "Internet attention mine", everything about it, from the lead up to the story and worldbuilding (or lack thereof) itself, was designed to create as much stir and buzz on social media and the internet as possible, by being intentionally vague with its subplots and backstories it created endless pointless discussions online that were never satisfactorally resolved (a strategy pioneered by the director of that film with a series called "LOST").

When I mentioned "Skinner Box", this refers to an experiment done where they found out they could program pigeons to press a button at certain times by dispensing food, any many have likened this to how social media hacks peoples' brain reward systems through notifications and the like. This even bleeds into video games, with games after that point having controversies over "Loot Boxes", which also attempt to hack the reward system of peoples' brains.

In terms of this kind of thing, I would really reccommend the 20th century author and media theorist "Marshall McLuhan", who's got quite a few lectures on YouTube. His work is mostly geared towards the sociatal and psychological effects of technology that was novel at the time (radio and TV especially), but so much of what he talks about and predicts is so close to the modern day internet and society that it actually feels scary. He died well before all of this stuff picked up, but honestly his takes are so good and so comprehensive that I believe they're actually somehow superior to the opinions of people who are still around today. If you dive deeply enough, you find that him and Tolkien were actually coming from the same philosophical roots, that being THE WORKS OF Thomas Aquinas (I first realised this when I recognised the similarity between McLuhan's observation of technology as an "extenstion of humanity" to Tolkien's idea of the One Ring being an extension of Sauron), so I think he should be of extra interest to Tolkien fans.
 

Today's events

Back
Top