• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What happened - and why

Mrs. Maggott

Home is where the cat is
Joined
Oct 2, 2002
Messages
3,463
Many of the film threads - both those which defend and those which criticize - ask the same questions: what happened and why? However, it wasn’t until someone mentioned Jackson’s fixation with the character Lurtz in FOTR that the answer came to me. The poster asked why Jackson put so much time and energy into the character and I realized that Lurtz was an insight into what went wrong in these films.

It is the film director’s responsibility to take the written word and translate it into a visual medium. A good director can take a fair to mediocre book and make of it a decent, even good film. And, of course, he can make a good or great book into a classic of the medium. Naturally, even the best director has his flops but there are certain qualities that a director must possess in order to successfully translate his “book” into film.

Firstly, he must respect his source material. A film made from a book which the director does not respect is almost immediately obvious to the audience. This sort of thing has nothing whatsoever to do with money and everything to do with imagination, “vision” and heart. How many so-called “B” movies are better cinema than huge bloated “extravaganzas” and who would not choose “Laura” over “Cleopatra” or “Treasure of the Sierra Madre” over mindless wide-screen “shoot-em-ups” with their dozens of explosions and idiotic car chases?

Secondly, the director must be willing to work within his story. This means that he must be able to determine what should be eliminated either for time consideration or because it complicates the plot to the point of chaos, what should be relegated to the background as unnecessary to the “flow” of the story and what must be highlighted in order to make the film “work”. This ability to take the written word and “see” it in film is a gift bestowed upon very few. Those who do have it are able to “print” on our minds memories which never leave us.

However, one thing a director should never do is attempt to become a “co-creator” with the writer(s) unless, of course, the story is his! When a director decides that his “book” needs more than translation or he gets the yen to do some “rewriting” himself, he runs the risk of being unsuccessful not only as an author but as a director and this is what happened to Peter Jackson in LOTR. At some point in the process of bringing LOTR to the screen Mr. Jackson decided that he wanted to become a “co-creator” of the story with Professor Tolkien and when that happened, it was the end of any hope that these films would become what Jackson himself probably wanted: the definitive film version of the book.

For what I ask was all the “rewriting” of characters but Jackson’s attempt to co-create the story? It is one thing to delete a portion of the tale for time constraints or to “telescope” the passage of years between the time Frodo inherits the Ring and the beginning of the Quest or even to “combine” characters in order to avoid excessive plot complications, but when you fundamentally change the characters - who they are, what they think, their motivations, their very essence – you no longer have “translation” but in fact, “creation”. And nowhere is this more truly revealed than in the character of Lurtz, Jackson’s own invention! Jackson absolutely fixates on him and does so in the “truest” of the films - FOTR.

Now, one of the things we know from Tolkien is that the orcs were very much anonymous – a “hive” culture very different from any of the free peoples of Middle-earth. Indeed, we only learn the name of a very few orcs in the entire book and interestingly enough, one of those is the leader of Saruman’s Urak-hai: Ugluk. Why, if Tolkien had already provided a name for Saruman’s lead orc, was it necessary for Jackson to choose an entirely different name? Why did Jackson simply not name his character “Ugluk” and thereby maintain at least the appearance of faithfulness to the book? The reason, I believe is that Jackson wanted his own character in the film rather than to simply re-develop Tolkien’s.

Consider the difference in the fate of the two orcs: Tolkien’s survives the attack at Parth Galen and leads the troop of orcs with their hobbit captives across Rohan where he eventually is slain by Eomer in the battle before Fangorn. There is nothing to suppose that Ugluk personally killed Boromir although certainly he may have had a hand in that action. On the other hand, Lurtz not only shoots the arrows that kill Boromir, but he engages in a battle to the death with Jackson’s “new” hero of the story, Aragorn and almost kills him although he himself is killed in the encounter. Thus does Jackson raise Lurtz from a mere factotum of Saruman, another orc among the many being bred in Orthanc, to almost “heroic” stature.

It is this care and excessive prominence and screen time given to a character which is purely Jackson’s invention that reinforce my belief that Jackson desired not merely to “film” J. R. R. Tolkien’s LOTR, but to in effect write the story that appears on the screen under the rather disingenuous disclaimer that it is “based” upon the book of that title.
 
That was a very good analyzis, Mrs M.

I am wondering: if this is so, then obviously mr. Jackson don't think that The Lord of the Rings is good enough. At least by his standards...

And this is done by the same director who claims that he loves the book, and who have always wanted to see it as fil.
If my memory doesn't fail me totally, I think that the director said that he expected someone to make a film of it while he himself were a youngster.

If only somebody had...:(
 
Interesting post Mrs M! Now, the thing u mentioned which stuck in my mind was the term "co-creator".
I believe this is unfortunately true. Tolkien has created something magnificent, PJ is a mere forgery of that, which is cool, however, he must do justice to the original or "source" material as u put it Mrs M.However, PJ deviates, no, changes and creates scenes which are in no way true to the book. It is an awesome effort to translate book to film, yet, in FOTR PJ in particular the EE was done overall well. Yet TTT was Ok at best, and Im being kind to the man seeing that he bothered to produce Lord of the Rings in the first place (hope the EE will improve my opinion). The funny thing is the amount of detail that went into sets, live location shoots, lighting and costumes WOW!! What happened to the story!!

Tolkien's work has great depth, yet PJ's touches the surfaces. However, there is really and absolutely NO EXCUSE and REASON for adding misc storylines, or over developing particular characters who in book form play small, if not minor roles. Mrs M for gave Lurtz as an example, good point.. Tolkien has provided you (PJ) with a rich and full story.

The movies of PJ are to appeal to a wide audience, however, by making J.R.R Tolkien's work so "user friendly" so to speak, he has simplified/modified call it what u will his work.. I sit back and although I am very happy that PJ made LOTR overall, I cannot help but think that if it were mandatory for any audience member to have read the book, I would be viewing a very much different version from PJ. The EE's are the compromise for fans of the book!!

There are moments when I wonder why PJ even bothered to produce LOTR at all, he assumes (perhaps) that we, the audience are incapable of following a storyline based from Tolkien, hence the changes. FOTR EE was done very well, yet TTT started to meander off course, which makes me cringe in anticipation of ROTK, imagine some of the new "PJisms" introduced. YUKK!!.
Yet non readers of Toliken's work have thought the movie "great".
So what was the purpose of this post, buggered if I know!!

I have always, for the most part attempted to be positive in relation to PJ and his "adaptation" of Tolkien's work. I have taken things on the cheek so to speak, yet after reading several recent posts about what to expect/spoilers of ROTK, I am now, truly concerned. The EE of TTT hopefully will improve my opinion of TTT in general, however, if ROTK has been raped by PJ like TTT then I will again leave the cinema disappointed.... Unfortunately I am going into the ROTK in December fearing the worse!!

ADDITIONAL: PJ, if u ever read these forums (unlikely to be honest, yet who knows), I would appreciate if you could have an honest look into the script that u present to the audience, and ask yourself did I do justice to the "source" material, (sorry Mrs M, just love that phrase). Could I have presented it better, or perhaps more accurately, leave out the extra rubbish, and focus on the characters and sub plot lines....

Sorry, long post, I am tired, getting frustrated, and in need of bed.
Goodnight HH
 
You have cogently pointed out (tired as you are) the problem here. We are told that the plot was too complex to be filmed and had to be "simplified" and so we had the removal of the Old Forest, T. B. and Barrow Downs sequence, combining of Glorfindel and Arwen, editing out of Arnor, the Northern Rangers, the sons of Elrond, the 17 year hiatus between Frodo's inheritance of the Ring and the beginning of the Quest, Radagast (who gave Gandalf Saruman's message to come to Orthanc) and the evil characters in Bree. To a certain extent, this was understandable. However, if we are "simplifying things", why make Arwen into a warrior princess only to have that part of her character abandoned after the flight to the fords? Why make Aragorn weak and conflicted, Elrond nasty and cynical, Merry and Pippin airheads and all the other character changes that began in FOTR and continued (and worsened) in TTT? How did such changes "simplify" anything?

Worse yet, why does Jackson then go and add plots threads as he did in TTT? Right now it is apparent that he is going to cut the end of the Saruman thread out of ROTK which is going to leave a plot hole big enough to drive an oliphaunt through! And this became necessary because of all the stupid inventions he put in the second film (Osgiliath, warg riders, horse kissing etc.).

Film defenders cannot on the one hand say that all Jackson's changes were the result of time constraints and plot simplification and then find excuses for adding things to an already complex tale and changing the very essence of many of the major characters in order to create an entirely different story altogether. It just won't wash.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....Jackson’s fixation with the character Lurtz in FOTR....why Jackson put so much time and energy into the character
I don't doubt, now you mention it, that PJ was fixated with L, and put much time and energy into him, but, until now, he had wasted it all as far as I was concerned - I knew L is in the cast list,
but PJ hadn't even established, to me, who he was.
I'm still not sure; he's the one who killed Boromir? - and does he appear in earlier scenes?
 
Originally posted by joxy
I don't doubt, now you mention it, that PJ was fixated with L, and put much time and energy into him, but, until now, he had wasted it all as far as I was concerned - I knew L is in the cast list,
but PJ hadn't even established, to me, who he was.
I'm still not sure; he's the one who killed Boromir? - and does he appear in earlier scenes?
From what I remember of FOTR, Lurtz is the "first born" of the Urak-hai (the "pod" scene) and becomes the "poster boy" for that species. He is the leader of the troop Saruman sends after the Ring with instructions to capture the hobbits and kill whomever of the Company remains. Boromir is struck by his arrows and just as he takes aim for the final shot, we get Aragorn's attack against him and their duel-to-the-death.

As I noted, Tolkien had already named the leader of Saruman's Urak-hai, but Jackson did not use that name. I think that this need to create a whole new and different character in place of one provided by the author is definite proof of the expansion of Jackson's role from director to co-creator/writer of the story. There was no need for a new character as Tolkien had already provided one to use if Jackson wanted to "highlight" the Urak-hai but the fact that Jackson not only "created" one but then spent so much time and energy on him rather proves my point.
 
Mrs. M.

Great analysis as usual. I had hoped we had moved past that by now. We all know (at least I do) that this isn't Tolkien's Lord of the Rings. I've known that since day one. This is The Lord of the Rings as told by Peter Jackson, New Line Cinema, and a bunch of other people.

Different version, different perspective, different biases, different ethnicity, different everything.

If you want Tolkien's story read the book. If you can trick your mind into thinking other versions of the tale could exist, go enjoy the film.

As for Peter's utterance of "staying true to the book". The only argument I have heard by the way that leads credence to any of this bickering back and forth, well, all I can say is Peter lied to you all.
 
Well, I had hoped to look at why Mr. Jackson did what he did - not so much that he did it, which cannot be argued. Both sides accept the fact that the story has been changed. Still, many opinions have been put forth as to why that happened. Some say that Jackson had to make changes because of the translation from book to the medium of film. Some say that New Line forced changes on him. Some have said that he feared the book would not "play" with a modern audience - and so forth.

However, when I considered the character of Lurtz and its rather unique place in the first film, I wished to offer my opinion and that is that Jackson was not satisfied merely "directing" the films. For whatever reason, he had a great yen to be more creatively involved (as if translating a book into film were not creative enough!) and so he decided to put his hand to actually writing the story! Of course, there was only one problem with that - it had already been written!

And so, of course, what he actually did was make changes in the characters and plot in such a way as to "showcase" his "new creation". He started in FOTR but fairly subtly as his changes were mostly to the characters. What plot changes he did make in the first film were generally considered to be based upon time constraints and an effort to simplify the story. However, in TTT, he cast away any pretence of faithfulness to the book - and the rest is history.
 
With Peter not having enough time to wax Saruman, but have time for Warg riders, mysterious deaths, and treks to Osgillath,(sp?) does anything else really need to be said???
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
With Peter not having enough time to wax Saruman, but have time for Warg riders, mysterious deaths, and treks to Osgillath,(sp?) does anything else really need to be said???
With regard to the reality of the changes, no. But it is motive being considered here and many have opined differently on Jackson's motives: time and money constraints, New Line interference, audience recognition etc. But to my mind, Jackson's changes, inventions and deviations only become understandable when you look at them in light of his desire to "write" the story himself using Tolkien's work only as a foundation for his own tale. Only in that way do his actions make sense. Frankly, no other "motive" answers all the questions raised.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
With regard to the reality of the changes, no. But it is motive being considered here and many have opined differently on Jackson's motives: time and money constraints, New Line interference, audience recognition etc. But to my mind, Jackson's changes, inventions and deviations only become understandable when you look at them in light of his desire to "write" the story himself using Tolkien's work only as a foundation for his own tale. Only in that way do his actions make sense. Frankly, no other "motive" answers all the questions raised.
Yeah, I agree with that. But, it is not like we have not hashed out his motives before.

Time constraints is totally irrelevant when you "add" things in, so that argument has long been kicked to the curb.

New Line interference is part of this no matter how you look at it.

Audience recognition is also part of it. Jackson is making a movie for a "non-Tolkien" audience first. I find that completely believable and most likely true.

I do not think you can boil down his motives to a single entity of "co-creation". Again, as per the making of the film it only matters what Peter Jackson believes to be true. His underlying motive is that he wants to make the best movie he can. Bad or good that is what he is doing.

He obviously believes in Tolkien more than a bunch of us do, because just like Tolkien he doesn't believe the source material can do it self justice on the screen either.

Money over art. That is the symbiotic theme that describes the relationship between the films and the books.
 
I have to disagree. I think that the most successful parts of Jackson's films and certainly his most successful characters are those wherein he is being most faithful to the book.

And as for the argument that Tolkien did not believe that the book would successfully translate into film, well that opinion was based upon a medium of almost 50 years ago! If the author could see what can be done with film today, I don't think he would maintain that belief. Certainly his very subtle "under-themes" would probably be lost in a book-to-screen translation, but there is no reason on God's green earth why the essential tale with its essential characters intact would not succeed on screen. In fact, I think in many instances they would have been easier for non-Tolkien audiences to understand than Jackson's contrived, conflicted, confused and befuddled inventions! Certainly Tolkien's Aragorn is much easier to understand than Jackson's. Now whether or not an individual viewer would accept the "hidden king/hero" of Tolkien's mythos (with all of his very human failings and doubts) is questionable. But I think certainly that character would have translated far better into the story line (there would have been no need to "convince" him to claim his heritage!) than did Jackson's weak and vacillating anti-hero.

If in fact, the films were better where they were truer, then the money argument is as obsolute as the time constraint factor. And, as noted above, I do not believe the "non-Tolkien audience" argument either for the reasons also noted above. And so, in the end, it comes down to ego, pure and simple. Of course Jackson wanted to produce "the best film he could". The trouble is that he was of the opinion that he could only do so by abandoning Tolkien and taking on the task of writer himself. Too bad he was mistaken.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
And as for the argument that Tolkien did not believe that the book would successfully translate into film, well that opinion was based upon a medium of almost 50 years ago!
Hasn't Christopher Tolkien stated as much just recently?
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
Hasn't Christopher Tolkien stated as much just recently?
Somehow I doubt that C.T. is much of a movie fan or that he is able to separate the frequently abhorrent contents of many modern films from their technological marvels. It may be that he is more than a bit prejudiced against the film community given what happened with Bakshi and some other rather horrible book adaptations. In any event, we certainly can see by what Jackson has accomplished that the blanket evaluation that the book cannot be filmed is just plain wrong. Jackson has kept the skeleton of the story and has been able to fit it in three films - or would have been able to do so if he had refrained from his own plot "inventions - so had he been faithful to the book, a good deal of Tolkien's LOTR would have been successfully brought to the screen. The fact that it hasn't been is Jackson's fault, not Tolkien's.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Somehow I doubt that C.T. is much of a movie fan or that he is able to separate the frequently abhorrent contents of many modern films from their technological marvels. It may be that he is more than a bit prejudiced against the film community given what happened with Bakshi and some other rather horrible book adaptations. In any event, we certainly can see by what Jackson has accomplished that the blanket evaluation that the book cannot be filmed is just plain wrong. Jackson has kept the skeleton of the story and has been able to fit it in three films - or would have been able to do so if he had refrained from his own plot "inventions - so had he been faithful to the book, a good deal of Tolkien's LOTR would have been successfully brought to the screen. The fact that it hasn't been is Jackson's fault, not Tolkien's.
Yes.

I guess what I am getting at is that I would have been allot more comfortable if the Tolkien estate had been involved. J.K. Rowling was very involved in the filming of the Harry Potter films and was consulted numerous times. In this case New Line bought the movie rights from Tolkien Enterprises which is owned by Saul Zaentz. Peter not having any pressure or influence from the original author or his son certainly gave him more freedom then he deserved.
 
Well, of course, you are correct to a certain extent. But there is more here than meets the eye. Jackson was getting input from a Tolkien grandchild for the first film until the family put the kaibosh on it. Apparently, the individual involved had to choose between collaborating with Jackson and family unity, so to speak and in the end, he choose to side with the family. So for the first film, Jackson was getting some input from a member of the Tolkien family. However, that didn't stop him from re-writing so many of the characters and giving us Arwen, Warrior Princess. Nonetheless, the first film was by far (in plot, at least) the most faithful of the two so far. I don't believe that much of anything (short of a gun) would have prevented Jackson from going about his reconstruction, retelling, rewriting (or whatever you wish to call it) of the story. If the direct involvement of a Tolkien family member did not give him pause, then I can't imagine that the presence of the author himself would have made a difference.

Nor can you compare the H.P. films with this situation because the "rights" had not been disposed of years before (as was the case with LOTR) and the stories were much more recent and, most importantly, simple. Had Columbus deviated in the way that Jackson did, there is no way that he could have gotten away with it because it would have been far too obvious. A "sweet" Professor Snape or a "nasty" Ron Weasley would have hit the audience in the face and the books' fans would have voted for Mr. Columbus' "new stories" by staying away in droves! His first film would have been his last, excellent special effects notwithstanding.

However, in Jackson's case, the story itself is very complex, there are a large number of subtle and unique characters and quite a few opportunities to "hit 'em in the eye" with spectacular graphics, scenery, crowd scenes, sets etc. Therefore, Jackson had a lot more "wiggle room" for his changes since many would go fairly unnoticed (as in FOTR) or be accompanied by so many exciting extras that many in the audience would be willing to "forgive" them (as in TTT). Furthermore, as noted, the book itself is much more subtle and complex than the Potter stories. Many in the audience had never read it or had read it years before and were not familiar enough with it to fault Jackson's exposition. Many of those who were able to note and understand his changes were willing to accept them because the films were exciting and at least bore some superficial resemblence to a much loved story. In their case it became a matter of "something was better than nothing". It is only in a relatively few cases that Jackson's changes have actually ruined the enjoyment of the films for the individual movie goer.
 
So based on your responses and this thread we are to accept as fact that Peter Jackson's desire to be "co-creator" is the sole reason for what happened and why?

Historical references have nothing to do with it. New Line has nothing to do with it. To much control has nothing to do with it. Screenwriters have nothing to do with it.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
So based on your responses and this thread we are to accept as fact that Peter Jackson's desire to be "co-creator" is the sole reason for what happened and why?

Historical references have nothing to do with it. New Line has nothing to do with it. To much control has nothing to do with it. Screenwriters have nothing to do with it.
Actually, probably very little. As for "historical references", you would have to tell me just what these "references" are.

As for New Line, if Jackson had convinced them of the efficacy of the original story and how it would save time and still keep audience interest, I simply cannot imagine New Line forcing Jackson to do the sort of stuff he has done. Of course, if you can point to something that Jackson has done which is an "invention" that was in fact "insisted upon" by New Line, I shall concede the point. But I simply cannot imagine that they are going to happily approve of having to drop the resolution of the Saruman plot thread simply in order to allow Jackson to have warg riders and Aragorn's faked (and very fake indeed!) death! From what I have read about the people at New Line, they were quite enthralled with both the project and the director and I simply cannot imagine that they would insist upon some made up rubbish if Jackson held out against it!

And, finally, as for the screenwriters, well if they produced something Jackson did not like, I cannot imagine that he would meekly go along to spare their feelings! I think that what we have gotten is a combined effort to rewrite the story with Jackson in the lead. From what I have read of film directors, they suffer their screenwriters, but they certainly do not hand over to them the entire project willy-nilly. Of course, if Jackson did so, then he still bears much of the blame for what has happened. Of course, the very term "blame" used in this context assumes that the individual feels that "blame" is warranted. As I have also pointed out previously, many people are "just thrilled" with this new story in the films and, in fact, prefer it (as film at least) to that which has been presented in the book. As they say, to each his own.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Actually, probably very little. As for "historical references", you would have to tell me just what these "references" are.

As for New Line, if Jackson had convinced them of the efficacy of the original story and how it would save time and still keep audience interest, I simply cannot imagine New Line forcing Jackson to do the sort of stuff he has done. Of course, if you can point to something that Jackson has done which is an "invention" that was in fact "insisted upon" by New Line, I shall concede the point. But I simply cannot imagine that they are going to happily approve of having to drop the resolution of the Saruman plot thread simply in order to allow Jackson to have warg riders and Aragorn's faked (and very fake indeed!) death! From what I have read about the people at New Line, they were quite enthralled with both the project and the director and I simply cannot imagine that they would insist upon some made up rubbish if Jackson held out against it!

And, finally, as for the screenwriters, well if they produced something Jackson did not like, I cannot imagine that he would meekly go along to spare their feelings! I think that what we have gotten is a combined effort to rewrite the story with Jackson in the lead. From what I have read of film directors, they suffer their screenwriters, but they certainly do not hand over to them the entire project willy-nilly. Of course, if Jackson did so, then he still bears much of the blame for what has happened. Of course, the very term "blame" used in this context assumes that the individual feels that "blame" is warranted. As I have also pointed out previously, many people are "just thrilled" with this new story in the films and, in fact, prefer it (as film at least) to that which has been presented in the book. As they say, to each his own.
So Jackson is 100% at fault. I get that.

But then you refuse to consider Jackson's thinking on any of this or use any context of that thinking.

1. Except for a single quote where Jackson states he would stay true to the books you have nothing to go on.
2. Jackson legally had every right to do what he has done.
3. New Line is laughing all the way to the bank.'
4. You continue not to except Hollywood's propensity for screwing things up on an enormous scale. How about the new Matrix film? Complete disaster and the quote we get from the director is "hard to argue with a billion dollars in ticket sales. You'll excuse this too because it was an original film. Still it illustrates a pattern.

The bottom line whether you want to believe it or not is that Peter Jackson's only obligation was to make money. At that he was an unmatched success.

Money over art. There is your "historical context".
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
?Historical references have nothing to do with it. New Line has nothing to do with it. To much control has nothing to do with it. Screenwriters have nothing to do with it.?
Historical references and too much control - what are you referring to?
Why would New Line have insisted on changes to a story that they had been happy to take on in the first place?
P Jackson WAS one of the scriptwriters himself, and another was his wife. He's supposed to be in control of the whole thing anyway, but if he can't control himself and his wife he should look for another career.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top