• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

I didn't realize Beleriand was a seperate land.

Coelacanth

New Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2026
Messages
15
I'm not sure how I missed this for so long, but I had read the Lord of the Rings, the Silmarillion, and even Unfinished Tales multiple times, and it wasn't until I started reading the History of Middle Earth that I realized that the setting of the Silmarillion was a seperate place from the rest of Middle Earth. I guess when I read about the drowning of Beleriand, and maybe even the changes that took place after the downfall of Numenor, I suppose I just thought that those events were meant to explain why the land looked different in later times. Even the migration of the elves I misunderstood as them coming from a foreign land into the regions of Middle Earth i was familiar with. I completely missed the fact that they crossed over the Misty Mountains and through Eriador and over Ered Luin in order to get to Beleriand. When i was reading the History of Middle Earth and Christopher Tolkien started talking about how Beleriand and the East of Middle Earth that I knew were seperate places in a casual way as something that was already evident, my mind was blown lol. I hadn't ever really studied the maps too closely, which may partly explain how I missed it, as well as changes in names like Ered Lindon becoming Ered Luin, but after I learned about it i was amazed to see how the west edge of the third age map coincided with the east edge of the map of Beleriand. I was curious if I'm the only one who completely missed this detail. Also, I'm posting this so that if anyone did miss this fact for any length of time, don't feel bad, you can know that you're not alone in it, and I'm pretty confident that it flew over my head far longer than for anyone else lol.
 
Finally, it's good to know there are at least two of us.!

I posted this on another thread a few years ago:

After reading LOTR many times and The Silmarillion the first few times, I remember spending time holding Tolkien's maps of Beleriand and Eriador side by side, trying to figure out how the features of Beleriand were remade into the features of Eriador during the geographic catastrophe, "The War of Wrath". I thought the River Sirion probably became the River Anduin. (They both had a big waterfall and many "mouths".) It wasn't until later that I realized the extent of the flooding of the continent.

😀
 
For me, I don't quite remember, but there was some confusion.
I recommend someone reading the Silmarillion for the first time to have the maps that go with it next to them the whole time if they really want to understand what is going on. I think I gradually understood Beleriand's relation to Middle-earth this way. At least that is how I approached it. I figure if I am going to commit to a long complex narrative I might as well understand it. Maybe have a genealogy or take notes if you wish too... 😅
 
Well, you may be glad to know there are at least three of us. Many years ago, when I took The Children of Húrin into my hands for the first time (having only read The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings) and looked at the map (which lacks Ossiriand and Ered Luin), I thought that Minas Tirith on the map was the Minas Tirith and Doriath was what was going to become Mordor.
The Children of Hurin was actually the first thing I ever read of Tolkien's, before even the Hobbit or LOTR. I had watched the movies, but suffice to say I didn't understand a lot of what was going on lol. Although it does work as a standalone story too. I just didn't understand the context around it.

Finally, it's good to know there are at least two of us.!

I posted this on another thread a few years ago:

After reading LOTR many times and The Silmarillion the first few times, I remember spending time holding Tolkien's maps of Beleriand and Eriador side by side, trying to figure out how the features of Beleriand were remade into the features of Eriador during the geographic catastrophe, "The War of Wrath". I thought the River Sirion probably became the River Anduin. (They both had a big waterfall and many "mouths".) It wasn't until later that I realized the extent of the flooding of the continent.

😀
Nice, nice. At least you took the time to try comparing the maps. I just assumed they were the same place and that a bunch of things changed over time lol.

For me, I don't quite remember, but there was some confusion.
I recommend someone reading the Silmarillion for the first time to have the maps that go with it next to them the whole time if they really want to understand what is going on. I think I gradually understood Beleriand's relation to Middle-earth this way. At least that is how I approached it. I figure if I am going to commit to a long complex narrative I might as well understand it. Maybe have a genealogy or take notes if you wish too... 😅
True, that's a good idea. Sometime afterwards i tried to keep a copy of the map of Beleriand beside me on one of my readthroughs of the Silmarillion and follow along with it. It's a bit harder for me to do, because whenever I'm reading something and then stop to consult something else, it throws me out of my comprehension a bit, like stopping to read footnotes mid sentence and things like that, but I think it did ultimately help me to appreciate Beleriand more.
 
I noticed right away that the eastern mountains on the fold out map of my hardcover Silmarillion had the same name of Ered Luin as the western mountains of my Lord of the Rings map. The geography was different, but I went into reading the Silmarillion knowing that the land of Beleriand had disappeared by the time of the 3rd age. I referred to the map a lot in my first Silmarillion read.
 
Well, I must say that I never heard this before.

I recall getting my copy of the Silmarilion in the hospital from my mother in February 1978, mere months after it came out, and only a few months more than I’d been introduced to Middle-earth in April or May ‘77 when that hokey Hobbit cartoon movie debuted on NBC. I was hooked immediately. It didn’t hurt sitting in an empty theatre a few weeks later on a Friday afternoon with less than ten people watching this (now ruined franchise lol) movie called Star Wars.
I was hooked on the genre.

But anyhow, I certainly took a number of readings at 15 years old and new to Middle-earth to start to figger out the Silmarillion. Three times through and I could start in chapter 7 (the darkening of Valinor) and dispense with all that Valar this and Valar that and just read the Elves and Edain back in Middle-earth….

But the maps - and text - certainly made understanding where Beleriand stood in connection to Eriador and the Blue Mountains simple for example.

Tolkien was very clear on the importance of maps to a fantasy story; map before story in fact.

From this thread one can certainly see why he insisted on including accurate and fitting maps for each edition of work he was releasing. Of course, if you don’t use them, they won’t serve the purpose they were created for and people might run around saying how confusing the book is on this subject when that is hardly the case at all.
 
Well, I must say that I never heard this before.

I recall getting my copy of the Silmarilion in the hospital from my mother in February 1978, mere months after it came out, and only a few months more than I’d been introduced to Middle-earth in April or May ‘77 when that hokey Hobbit cartoon movie debuted on NBC. I was hooked immediately. It didn’t hurt sitting in an empty theatre a few weeks later on a Friday afternoon with less than ten people watching this (now ruined franchise lol) movie called Star Wars.
I was hooked on the genre.

But anyhow, I certainly took a number of readings at 15 years old and new to Middle-earth to start to figger out the Silmarillion. Three times through and I could start in chapter 7 (the darkening of Valinor) and dispense with all that Valar this and Valar that and just read the Elves and Edain back in Middle-earth….

But the maps - and text - certainly made understanding where Beleriand stood in connection to Eriador and the Blue Mountains simple for example.

Tolkien was very clear on the importance of maps to a fantasy story; map before story in fact.

From this thread one can certainly see why he insisted on including accurate and fitting maps for each edition of work he was releasing. Of course, if you don’t use them, they won’t serve the purpose they were created for and people might run around saying how confusing the book is on this subject when that is hardly the case at all.
I agree that maps are important for writing as well as understanding most works of fantasy. My misunderstanding was probably due to a combination of not studying the maps close enough, the changes in place names like Ered Lindon becoming Ered Luin, and likely largely due to a preconcieved idea that the events of the Silmarillion could only have taken place in the same lands as the later stories. I saw the northwest of Middle-Earth bordering a Great Sea in both maps, so I assumed that it was the same land and that things just changed over time. I like to believe that I am detail-oriented, but I have to admit there have been many instances in my life where I have overlooked things that may have been very obvious to others lol.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top