Great thread Aragil.
In general I support most of the characterizations.
I didn't perceive some of the characters as portrayed in the way that many others did. I didn't think Gandalf's "is it safe" remarks re the Ring were "sputtering". Consider that he's left the most appallingly powerful artifact in Middle Earth in the care of a hobbit and he's just been given cause to believe that the pursuit is hard on his heels. I don't think that a little trepidation and urgent inquiry is out of place.
Merry and Pippin were not what I had in my mind's eye, but I think PJ came up with a better picture than I had. He captured their adolescence and immaturity very well, and he did make a clear distinction between the two. Merry was clearly more level headed and quicker to realise that a situation was serious and called for serious action.
I'm with you on Aragorn. The Aragorn I saw was fairly weatherbeaten and looked like someone who had spent some hard time in hard places. Although chronologically he is old, he is not old for his bloodline (especially one in whom the blood of Numenor runs more true than in any other for centuries). The books clearly give the impression of not quite middle aged for me. Certainly he should be vigorous and capable. Some of the Aragorn objectors seem to want an old veteran on the verge of collecting his pension. And I don't think JRRT ever used the adjective "grizzled" to describe him.
Elrond was great. He had the stern approach and careworn attitude I was looking for. Galadriel, likewise was good given the limited time on screen. More time would have brought out the softer side of her a bit more.
Sorry to the Orlando fans, but Legolas was boring and colourless. However, that's how he was in FOTR. It wasn't until well into TTT that he developed much of a personality and even then he never set the world on fire.
Gimli was a bit of a D&D stereotype dwarf for me. However, he may warm up when he has a bit more to do.
I hated Boromir to start with but found myself warming to him by the end of the movie. As with Legolas, my reaction to him was exactly how I reacted to him the first time I read the book, so from that perspective, they got his character right.
Sam was great. He had the right mixture of rustic, bucolic ignorance (NOT stupidity) and stubborn loyalty. I did miss the "tall, shapeless felt bag" that he used for a hat though.
I thought Frodo was in some ways was the weakest of the Fellowship. The pathos got a bit close to pathetic and he was a bit too Boy's Own for me. And the CG stuff made his neck look like he was a front row forward (Rugby allusion, I don't know the equivalent American football position). But overall, he was acceptable.
In general I support most of the characterizations.
I didn't perceive some of the characters as portrayed in the way that many others did. I didn't think Gandalf's "is it safe" remarks re the Ring were "sputtering". Consider that he's left the most appallingly powerful artifact in Middle Earth in the care of a hobbit and he's just been given cause to believe that the pursuit is hard on his heels. I don't think that a little trepidation and urgent inquiry is out of place.
Merry and Pippin were not what I had in my mind's eye, but I think PJ came up with a better picture than I had. He captured their adolescence and immaturity very well, and he did make a clear distinction between the two. Merry was clearly more level headed and quicker to realise that a situation was serious and called for serious action.
I'm with you on Aragorn. The Aragorn I saw was fairly weatherbeaten and looked like someone who had spent some hard time in hard places. Although chronologically he is old, he is not old for his bloodline (especially one in whom the blood of Numenor runs more true than in any other for centuries). The books clearly give the impression of not quite middle aged for me. Certainly he should be vigorous and capable. Some of the Aragorn objectors seem to want an old veteran on the verge of collecting his pension. And I don't think JRRT ever used the adjective "grizzled" to describe him.
Elrond was great. He had the stern approach and careworn attitude I was looking for. Galadriel, likewise was good given the limited time on screen. More time would have brought out the softer side of her a bit more.
Sorry to the Orlando fans, but Legolas was boring and colourless. However, that's how he was in FOTR. It wasn't until well into TTT that he developed much of a personality and even then he never set the world on fire.
Gimli was a bit of a D&D stereotype dwarf for me. However, he may warm up when he has a bit more to do.
I hated Boromir to start with but found myself warming to him by the end of the movie. As with Legolas, my reaction to him was exactly how I reacted to him the first time I read the book, so from that perspective, they got his character right.
Sam was great. He had the right mixture of rustic, bucolic ignorance (NOT stupidity) and stubborn loyalty. I did miss the "tall, shapeless felt bag" that he used for a hat though.
I thought Frodo was in some ways was the weakest of the Fellowship. The pathos got a bit close to pathetic and he was a bit too Boy's Own for me. And the CG stuff made his neck look like he was a front row forward (Rugby allusion, I don't know the equivalent American football position). But overall, he was acceptable.
