• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

battles

  1. Ent

    What are your thoughts on "The Battle for Middle-earth" book in 2004?

    Has anyone read this work from 2004 by chance? It sounds like it might have 'features of interest' (Sherlock Holmes).
  2. Turin_Turambar

    Is the campaign in ⚔️Battle for Middle Earth II canon?

    I'm sure you all know and have played bfme 2 game. On the internet, some people say that bfme 2 game is based on canon and true stories for the good campaign mode. Some people say that the battles and events in the game are fictional. Do you think the good campaign scenario of this game can be...
  3. B

    What if the ⚔️Battle of Five Armies had been the Battle of Three Armies?

    For smiles, let's say that the Goblins and the Wargs didn't think the death of the Great Goblin was worth going so far east and waging a big battle, or, perhaps, somehow they didn't get the memo that Smaug was dead and didn't want to mess with the dragon they thought was still there. So that...
  4. Turin_Turambar

    Why are some Beleriand wars longer than others?

    War of wrath lasted 43 years. Dagor bragollach lasted about 2 years. Nirnaeth arnoediad lasted 6 days. Dagor-nuin-giliath lasted 10 days. Siege of Angband lasted 400 years. But during the siege of Angband there were no serious events that could be called war. So it was just an act of...
  5. Turin_Turambar

    Are these 2 battles in the ⚔️war of the ring canon or fiction?

    https://lotrfanon.fandom.com/wiki/Battle_of_Dunland https://lotrfanon.fandom.com/wiki/Battle_of_Rh%C3%BBn There are 2 wars that are stated to be in the war of the ring on the site in the link. I couldn't find any other information on the internet that these 2 wars took place. Any chance it's in...
  6. Rivendell_librarian

    The ⚔️Battle of Brunanburh

    I'm reading a fascinating history of Anglo-Saxon England and it included part of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle: a work I'm sure JRRT would have known well from Battle of Brunanburh (ASC) I haven't found out what giving rings meant to Athelstan beyond the obvious one of demonstrating his wealth and...
  7. Turin_Turambar

    Wondering who led the battles of Beleriand and the ⚔️War of the Ring?

    List of commanders of both good and evil in all the battles of Beleriand and the War of the Ring. I did not add to the list those who later betrayed during the war, and who commanded only in kinslayings and wars between dwarves and elves. The reason why I open this topic and present them is to...
  8. HALETH✒🗡

    Football is like a ⚔️Battle for Middle-Earth

    Did anybody watch the football match Barcelona vs Inter yesterday? My father did and I heard one of the sports commentators saying: "They're trying to kick the ball to the goal with the same frequency with which Legolas shoots arrows". :D I suppose you didn't hear this comment because it was the...
  9. Turin_Turambar

    Were Glorfindel and Ecthelion present at key battles?

    Unfortunately, Tolkien did not write which wars these two characters participated in before Nirnaeth Arnoediad. Do you think glorfindel and ecthelion fought in Battle of Lammoth and Dagor Aglareb?
  10. Squint-eyed Southerner

    Miniatures Day of ⚔️Battle 🧌Orcs

    This company is making print on demand figures in plastic: https://www.chrisparkergames.com/product-category/lotr-orcs/ I saw on another site that they'll be making Rohirrim -- or rather, substituting round for kite shields on their Normans...
  11. B

    Why didn't Thorin & Co use Mithril armor in the ⚔️Battle of Five Armies?

    I guess I first thought of this from a joke used in a "How it Should Have Ended" for the Hobbit movie (the third one) where Bilbo, who already has a magic ring, tells Thorin to keep the Mthril coat and so uses it to avoid being killed by Azog. While Azog was already dead in the books by this...
  12. Erestor Arcamen

    A ⚔️battle of wits: Smaug vs 👁️Sauron

    Someone else asked about who would win in a fight, Smaug or Sauron. A friend asked me who would win in a battle of wits though, Smaug or Sauron. My opinion is that Sauron being a maiar would defeat Smaug easily but at the same time, aren't there theories that dragons are possibly maiar as well...
  13. Elassar

    What would Happen if Thorin died in the ⚔️battle of Anzanulbizar?

    Thorin Okenshield was the leader of the hobbit company who reclaimed Erebor but what would happen if he died fighting Azog in the battle of anzanulbizar?
  14. Turin_Turambar

    How many battles were fought in Mirkwood during the ⚔️War of the Ring?

    Was there any other war apart from the woodland realm war and the battle under the trees in the war of the ring? I read somewhere that there was another war before the battle under the trees. How many battles were lived in Mirkwood?
  15. Elassar

    What if 👁️sauron had the simmerals in the ⚔️battle of the last alliance???

    At the battle of the last alliance Sauron, lord of the black land and all evil in middle earth's major weapon was the one ring. Which by itself is an incredible weapon, but what would happen if Sauron had the three simarils aswell. Would the simarils change the course of the battle or would...
  16. Turin_Turambar

    Were the battles of beleriand fought in order?

    We all know that the wars during the War of the Ring were fought at the same time. But I also curious about the time period of the battles of Beleriand. Were the battles of Beleriand fought sequentially at regular intervals? Or were there simultaneous wars in the battles of beleriand as in the...
  17. Turin_Turambar

    Why are the Wars of Beleriand said to be greater?

    First of all, I would like to start by stating that I am as objective as possible. I did the most detailed research on the internet and I came to the following conclusions. Beleriand, where all the events of the First Age takes place, is much smaller in size than the Third Age Middle-earth...
  18. Turin_Turambar

    Which of these 🧝elves do you think fought in the most battles?

    I think would be an elf the character who fought in the most battles for they were immortal throughout middle earth history.I guess there is no elf who has seen more battles than the elves on the list. Who do you think is the most participated battles elf in the history of middle earth?
  19. Turin_Turambar

    Turin vs. Fingolfin: Who reigns in Dagor Dagorath?

    you all know that turin killed melkor in dagor dagorath. a forum member said that turin in dagor dagorath is much stronger and superior than turin in first age. do you think so? and is turin turambar stronger and superior to fingolfin in the battle of dagor dagorath? please don't say dagor...
  20. M

    📖👀 The ⚔️Battle of the Pelennor Fields

    Another retrospective addition: Hurin the Tall, Warden of the Keys, was there with Imrahil's horsemen.
Back
Top