Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
Any Battle for Middle-Earth players out there? Interested to hear your takes on the first, and II and Rise of the Witch-King. Myself I thoroughly enjoyed the first, loved the movie score + classic RTS game music, character voices and hero play. II was a disappointment, and Rise of the...
You guys all know the Palantir, and I won't insult your IQ about how it works.
Now here's a big bug-the free people of middle-earth seldom use it for military communication, and they used some primitive methods like beacons instead.
Why didn't they use Palantir like Radio for military...
The Fords were the one point where the River Isen was passable, so my thinking if the rest of the river was either too wide further toward the mouth, or the riverbanks too steep and the river quite turbid further up toward the source.
So it would be the central point of invasion from Dunland...
I'm definitely not patient enough to do something like this.
http://canyouactually.com/lego-battle-of-helms-deep/?fbclid=IwAR2cAwCk0XunGnRl0CmKYVvspQhCfLIwiNZg6rQFEAxCPhjVKiE162dwnPw
Hi All!
So, instead of the High Fantasy Novel first, I am starting my High Fantasy with a Novella called: "The Court of Last Battle", with the same High Fantasy Character as in the novel.
Here's my starting description for the story:
"Starved...
Cold...
Frozen to the Bone and Jagged at the...
Even with Sauron himself being defeated, it was pretty well stated that the armies of Mordor and its allies greatly outnumbered the armies of the West.
While I can understand, if Sauron's armies of orcs and trolls might be weakened or killed if they were vulnerable to sunlight, surely the...
Frodo Baggins had walked into a battle like no other. Every city and village in Middle-earth had gone to war. He had just arrived in Helm's Deep. 'This is like the Second Battle for Helm's Deep,' he said to himself. Legolas the Elf and Aragorn, son of Arathorn were on both of his sides. They...
Logically, it wasn't really much needed. Saruman was already defeated by the Ents. The people could have just evacuated instead of losing soldiers at Helms Deep.
More to the point, if they'd retreated from Rohan toward Gondor, Saruman, assuming that the Ents didn't attack him, would have...
I recall in The Hobbit that they were VERRRRRRRRRRRRRRY close to duking it out between Thorin, his 11 companions, and Dain and his dwarves on one side and Bard and Thrandil and their guys on the other when luckily the goblins arrived and forced them to join forces to fend them off.
But what if...
The part I didn't like one bit in the third Hobbit film, where you can see the forms of the Ring-wraiths, without their black cloaks. The Nazgûl wore their rings long enough that their physical forms faded away until they had become entirely invisible to mortal eyes. Their black robes gave them...
So,
The Battle of the Five Armies.
The extended edition tries to improve what is considerably the weakest link in this chain.
Now I've heard of scenes that really SHOULD'VE been in this movie:
I'll list them:
Gandalf talking to Thranduil about the white gems.
Bilbo planting his acorn in...
Has anybody seen it yet? I just received it in the mail a few days ago. I'm doing The Hobbit with my grade 7s and I decided to watch it fresh with them for the first time.
The only thing I hope for is....PLEASE let there be more of Beorn in the battle! I was SO disappointed to see about 5...
I would like to propose a hypothetical debate. Let's say that for some reason the armies of Orcs and Wargs never appear at the Lonely Mountain. The impending conflict between the Armies of Elves and Laketown Men and the Dwarves of the Iron Hills is not halted and carnage breaks out.
The Elves...
Well fellow Tolkien forum-ites. It has been a good 13 years since I started my purist's reviews. As I will not be doing the EEs, and unless Jackson comes out with more Tolkien works to butcher, this will be my last movie review. *sigh* :( It seems like yesterday since I started this journey. To...
It just hit home to me now that when this movie comes out, it will be my last review. I've decided not to review the EEs of The Hobbit so after 13 years, I will ending a legacy of purist reviews. I will have to pull out all the stops on my last one. Going to see it the weekend it comes out.
I...