• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

helm's deep

  1. K

    How many 🧝elves were at Helm's deep?

    Well there was enough of them to man the deeping wall and there was also more elves on the ground behind the wall shooting arrows. Since there was 3 lines of elves lining the entire deeping wall and about 100 elves in a line i would guess about 750 elves total in Helms deep. Its kind of sad when...
  2. PJ was at helms deep.

    i hope this wasnt already posted. at the part in the movie where the orcs are breaking in th gate at helms deep, a soldier screams and jumps out stabbing an enemy..... it was PJ. any one else notice this? (probobly everybody...lol) :o
  3. 10,000 Uruk-Hai at Helms deep? I dont think so!!!

    it came a bit odd to me that their was way more than 10,000 uruk-hai at helms deep. Their seamed like atleast 30,000. and when gandalf shows up, it seams like about 10,000 are left!!!
  4. The Men and 🧝elves at Helms Deep

    Did anyone else notice that during the end of the helms deep battle, their was only about 10 men left out of 600 men and elves combined? That kind of bothered me
  5. Helms Deep Last ride

    I thought it was kin of wierd when the king aragorn and other rohiriam and so forth rode out the gate and were running over the uruk hai. if u look closely, when they are swinging their swords, they are not hitting anything and they are swinging at nothing in the air. I thought that was a real...
  6. M

    Were the 🧝elves in Helms Deep in the books?

    I'm not a self-proclaimed LOTR: TTT buff, but I do enjoy the books immensely. Before I bore anyone to tears- quick question: I have read and re-read the battle at Helms' Deep numerous times, trying to find a sign of the elves' arrival to help. Can someone PLEASE help me and tell me where...
  7. A

    Movie Helm's Deep: ridiculous or not?

    Just trying to discuss the movie version's conclusion to the battle of Helm's Deep- did it make sense, or not? Just to try and get everyone up to speed, here's what I calculate as the relative strengths of each side during the battle: Theoden: 300-500 men, mostly conscripts who were...
  8. T

    So 🧝Arwen IS at Helms Deep?

    Check this out: http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/2/1042493150 If she is there, it must be in one of those awefully quick shots. Maybe we'll be able to spot it on the DVD. Then again, maybe the'll remove it by then. Or maybe it's not even there :).
  9. 🧝Elf leader who dies in helms deep.....

    What was the elf leaders name who lead the elves to helm's deep?
  10. K

    Have their been any other battles at Helms Deep?

    Besides the battle between the uruk-hai and the rohirrim have their been any other battles between the rohirrim and others at Helms Deep? Such as the dunlendings, orcs etc?
  11. J

    Helm's Deep ⚔️Battle

    Battle of Helm’s Deep as depicted in Two Towers Overall the numbers of Saruman’s armies appears to be right. Unfinished Tales (UT) and the LOTR describes the army as consisting of 10,000 orcs plus an unstated number of Dunlendings (I estimate there should have been a few thousand). I was...
  12. 🧝Elves at Helm's Deep weakened Rohan

    I think Jackson made Rohan look weaker than they were. Rohan was saying they had 300 men, but in the book they had more like 1,000. And Lothlorien wasn't supposed to come to Helm's Deep. I guess it kind of helped the movie because the first book had Lothlorien Elves like Haldir as stuck-up and...
  13. E

    Helms deep layout

    i am currently reading the TTT after finished reading the hobbit and FOTR. quite stuck at the helm's deep. the description was so difficult to digest. so confused about the hornburg, and then a wall from hornburg, then the helms deep, helms dike, deeping wall, etc. in the end, how many walls are...
  14. D

    45 Straight Minutes of Helm's Deep in TTT!?!

    This is what I've heard Ladies and Gentlemen! No cutaways!
  15. Did you think Gimli died in Helm's Deep?

    Did u think? I was reading TTT and I was kinda scared when they were battiling and they couldn't find Gilmi. I mean Gilmi isn't all bad and he did save The king. I was kinda scared, how 'bout u guys?
  16. E

    Helm's Deep

    What did you like about the battle in the Helm's Deep? In my opinion that's one of the best fights in the book.
  17. M

    Helms Deep pics rant

    OK, I know I've worked very hard to get over the whole Arwen scene in FotR and have posted many times about how much I enjoyed the movie anyway, put aside my purist standards and tried to forgive PJ for altering the best book in the world. Get over it, I told myself. And then I see pictures...
  18. A

    Helms Deep PICS

    I dont know if these are old or not but i found these today...Hlems Deep pics from TTT.Anyone got pics of Arwen at Helms Deep...i heard there was one. Gandalf:http://www.numenoreen.com/Images/GandalfHelm.jpg Soldiers:http://www.numenoreen.com/Images/AVHelm.jpg...
  19. T

    🧝Elves at Helms Deep?

    Read a quote from PJ that mentioned Helms Deep as being a battle of men and elves against Orcs. Ahh, someone refresh my memory here but I thought Legolas was the only elf at this battle. Has anyone heard anything about this?
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…