• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

mythology

  1. Lhunithiliel

    BoLT vs. Published Silmarillion - Which is closer to mythology?

    In the Introduction to BoLT1, Christopher Tolkien states: But there is also another aspect: IMO, the BoLT-books contain much more fantasy than the Silmarillion, the latter being somehow "drier" and more "facts-providing" than keeping the beauty of true fantasy. To my understanding...
  2. Lhunithiliel

    Justifying Wars in Tolkien’s Mythology

    The following is the excellent work of Eriol the Mariner ;) :) - his interpretation on the same topic - "War in Tolkien's works" I am more than pleased to submit it to everybody's attention! :) *************************************************** Justifying Wars in Tolkien’s Mythology...
  3. Anamatar IV

    Comparison of Greek Mythology

    The past few weeks I have been looking over the Greek Gods and Goddesses. It has stricken me that Tolkien based many of his Maiar and Valar on them. I have come to these conclusions: Manwe is NOT Zeus. Zeus was hated by the other Gods. Zeus overthrew his father (which would be Iluvatar to...
  4. A

    Where do Hobbits fit in Tolkien's mythology?

    Okay.. we've got: Elves & Men whose coming is told in Sil Dwarves made by Aule (Sil) Ents made by Yavanna (also in Sil) Orcs = Morgoth's mockeries of the Elves (okay these are all from Sil) Well, where the heck did Hobbits come from? It seems strange that such a influencial people...
  5. Gil-Galad

    Where do human souls go in Tolkien's mythology?

    What happens to people's souls after their death,according to Tolkien's world? This thread is actually posted by Melian and I,but now she is at her home crying. Now we are affected and grieved.We want to ask something very simple. We know where elven's souls go after their death,but where,if...
  6. Nenya Evenstar

    Myth or fact?

    I have heard that "The Silmarillion" is the only book that is the true history of ME and that "Unfinished Tales" and books like it are just stories that Tolkien wrote not meaning for them to be fact in his world. Is this true, or are books like "Unfinished Tales" really ME history?
  7. G

    J.R.R. Tolkien's "true myth" as a modern masterpiece

    Found an article by Andrew O'Hehir that addresses many of the topics that keep turning up in our threads. Check it out!
  8. E

    ‘Did Tolkien Create a True Mythology’?

    I dont think it can be qualified as actual mythology, I mean, if it is real it should be believed. As knowledgable as we all are in Tolkien mythology, I have my doubts that any of us take it as the highest form of truth or really believe that elves live in the woods and dwarves in the mountains...
  9. W

    Tolkien - Norse Mythology

    Im writing an essay about the link between the world of Tolkien and the Norse Mythology. Trying to find out about how much of his inspiration Tolkien took from it. I have some similarities like the dwarfs, ravens and black birds as spies, dragons, trolls, some names, the name of the world and...
  10. M

    Did JRRT create real mythology?

    In a letter to his publisher (it's in the my copy of the Silmarillion) Tolkien confessed that his goal was nothing less than the creation of a real mythology ( a la Greece, Scandanavia, Germany, Joseph Campbell) for the English-speaking world. Has he succeeded? Will he succeed? I believe he...
  11. Dengen-Goroth

    The Man, The Myth

    Well, recently, actually yesterday I picked up a book about Tolkien. Reading through it I saw how Tolkien had actually incorporated a number of themes, and had simply switched the names, and sometimes the roles of the characters. I thought it would be great fun to test not only your knowledge in...
Back
Top