• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

question

  1. A

    Obscure Question about J R R Tolkien's Luggage...

    Hi I have seen a piece of luggage that has the initials JRR on them - its a very smart leather suitcase & I did some googling & I came up with a very similar suitcase with the same initials and the person who was selling it insinuated that it was JRR Tolkiens luggage! I have attached a photo of...
  2. Arquen

    Quenya Syntax Help: Impersonal Verbs in Compounds

    Hello everyone, I am new to this forum so I hope I am asking in the correct thread. Basically, as a little translation excercise, I decided to translate some bits from the latin textbook "Lingua Latina per se illustrata" into Quenya (don't ask why; I've probably got too much free time, haha)...
  3. 1stvermont

    Question ABout 🌳Ents and the Silmarillion

    In of aule and Yavanna, Ents [not called so of course] are spirit beings that indwell trees to protect the forest from dwarves who will cut them down. However at this period of time are not the only spirit beings valar and Maiar? does this make the spirits of ents...Maiar? At this same time of...
  4. CirdanLinweilin

    A question on 🧝Elves.

    Weird question, but it relates to the Elves not being what we call "Fallen" as Men are. Can anyone speculate as to whether Elven woman had pains in childbirth? As someone who believes that the pain of childbirth came from the sin of Adam and Eve, I was just wondering. It's been a question...
  5. Andrew King

    Tengwar question - English Mode

    Hello! I've been playing about using the Tengwar to represent English words for a little while now, but have stumbled across a situation I can't quite figure out. If a word ends with two vowels, can you have a sequence of two vowel carriers next to each other to finish the word? For example...
  6. C

    A Question of Time

    I have a somewhat confusing question for discussion. One of Thorin's company, Balin, was born in the Third Age (2763), making him 7 years old when Smaug took over the mountain in the Third Age (2770), and Bilbo begins his journey in The Shire in the Third Age (2941). Are these Valian years...
  7. M

    Question about Numenorean ancestry?

    Are they all descended of the "Half Elven" or just the Royal line of Elros, and other houses to branch off like the Elendi?
  8. Z

    Beginner question - where is Angband?

    I'm going crazy here. Where is Angband? On the map in Silmarillion, either I'm blind, but I'm sure its not there. The map is just of Beleriand, and not of the entire Middle Earth. Any map I find on the internet is of the 3rd age, where the names are all changed, and Forlindon seems to be in the...
  9. C

    Chronology Question

    Hello everyone, I used to be very versed in Tolkien and his literature, although it's been many years and I seem to have forgotten most of what I knew. :*down I would love to get back into his books, and I was curious if anyone could provide me with a Middle-Earthean timeline of sorts. I want...
  10. P

    Beowulf question

    Hello In his critique of Beowulf Tolkien writes: “Let us by all means esteem the old heroes: men caught in the chains of circumstance or of their own character, torn between duties equally sacred, dying with their backs to the wall” (1936: 17). Who were these 'old heroes'? Many thanks...
  11. A

    Question about Boromir

    The other day I was tidying my room when I found an old summary of the characters of the Lord of the Rings I wrote long ago for a friend who wanted to read the book, but was afraid of getting the many characters all mixed up. Under the entry for Boromir, I was surprised to read that I had...
  12. childoferu

    A Burning Question

    What would epic fantasy be without war? Honestly? See, at first, I was only thinking about the question regarding Lord of the Rings, but now I realize all the great epic fantasies of our time are all set in a war-time setting. Even with the new brilliant Avatar movie, at the end, I kind of...
  13. P

    🕷️Shelob question

    Hello I'd like to ask two questions if I may: how old was Aragorn when he got married, and did Shelob perish at the end? I have the impression, right or wrong, that Shelob is independent of Sauron and so when his plans are thwarted is does not matter one way or the other to her. Since Tolkien...
  14. Aisteru

    A Quick Question For Everyone

    Today my friend asked me a question to which my answers were not satisfactory so I told him I would consult with some people and get back to him. Question: The eagles fly Gandalf in and Frodo and Sam out of Mordor. How come they couldn't have done that in the first place? Answer: ......
  15. A

    A question about Tolkien's books

    I have read the Lord of the Rings, the Silmarillion and the Hobbit so far. There are places and lands that are not mentioned there, like Fornost, Arnor, Cardolan, Edhelion, Annuminas... This part of the history of Middle Earth is less known to me, mostly from summaries in internet, in which book...
  16. LoreMaster

    Question about Avatars

    Hello everyone! I've been a member here for over four years, but it's been a long time since I posted anything. Anyway, I have a question. I've downloaded a bunch of photos from the official LOTR movie site and I'm wondering if there would be any copyright issues with me using one of them...
  17. Persephone

    Question about Archiving Original Work/Fanfiction

    I don't know if it's just me not looking in the right place, but there seems to be no guidelines as to what we can post on here. I would like to know the following for Archiving Original Work/Fanfiction here for other TTF people to see. Like what is the Rate limit (if any. I know that in many...
  18. S

    Movie question

    At what point in the movie does Sam take the Ring from Frodo? In the book it happens after Frodo got stung, but I dont recall seeing that in the movie.
  19. P

    Question about Role Playing

    We wants to join -- but when we looked inside threads, it looks like the Role Playing is more like co-authoring a story. If this is the case, who decides the plot, and who makes decisions in case there is a fork in the story? or can each player just do what they want as long as it does not...
  20. D

    question about elronds council

    i was watching the extended version and in lord elronds council boromir goes for the ring. is the booming voice that comes in saurons? anyone know what sauron and gandalf are saying?
Back
Top