Odo Proudfoot
Back into the fray!
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2001
- Messages
- 403
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
At the same time, Glorfindel says to Aragorn that he has learned he and the hobbits were in the wild carrying a heavy burden "without guidance" - that is, without the Wizard. It certainly doesn't sound as if Aragorn is "in charge" at all at this point.
While Glorfindel may have had more say than Aragorn, they were both guides. That is stated by the author.
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
But is Aragorn "in charge"? Yes, of course, in Bree he is simply because his followers are the four hobbits. Once Glorfindel appears, it is obvious that Aragorn has relinquished his leadership role to the more powerful and far older elf. At the same time, Glorfindel says to Aragorn that he has learned he and the hobbits were in the wild carrying a heavy burden "without guidance" - that is, without the Wizard. It certainly doesn't sound as if Aragorn is "in charge" at all at this point. To further demonstrate, Tolkien notes that the Elf puts them through a forced march after which even Aragorn appears exhausted.
To my mind, Aragorn's character doesn't change, but his mind becomes made up to put himself forward after the debacle at Parth Galen (all of his options have been considered and his choice made) and you therefore have very different actions on the part of the character rather than a different character.
(will say more later; late for church)
He is cardboard to me. I would not say never failing though. I also don't think he grew much during the story.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I did not say that he was not "strong enough", but I brought forth the points to illustrate that Jackson's supporters who say that Aragorn was a never failing "cardboard hero" who never "grew" during the course of the book.
Rivendell didn't have to know this at the time that the riders were sent out. Glorfindel would have figured it along the way.First of all, how could Rivendell know that the hobbits were accompanied by Aragorn? And, if Elrond and company did know, why would they think the Strider and the hobbits were "without guidance"?
I'm trying... but I do not see ANY logic in that. None.It appeared to me from first reading that Glorfindel's statement includes the man as well as the hobbits, probably because he supposed that only the Wizard (aside from himself) was able to prevail against the Nazgul.
How much more vulnerable and "unkingly" can one get than to virtually "beg" for the friendship and approval of four "country bumpkin" hobbits?
Originally posted by Nóm
He is cardboard to me. I would not say never failing though. I also don't think he grew much during the story.
At any rate, I dont see how the events with Glorfindel relate to this.
--------
It is certainly possible that Glorfindel figured that Strider had run into the hobbits. Glorfindel did not say "I thought the hobbits were without a guide"... he was merely repeating the message that made it to Rivendell. In repeating the message from Gildor, he was giving the explaination for why he was out and about looking for them.
--------
Mrs. Maggott:
Try as I might, I can not begin to understand this:
I'm trying... but I do not see ANY logic in that. None.
--------
Mrs. Maggott:
As for the bit about hoping that the hobbits would take to him, it indicates a vulnerability, but I wouldn't go this far...
I think "beg" is just a bit extreme. I can't see from a point of view where I can see this as being begging.
I suppose, but wish I understood about your Glorfindel/Aragorn idea. That isn't what this thread is for, and you and I are never on the same "wavelength" (for lack of better word)... so I guess it ends here.Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Alas, there is no reason to further discuss this issue. You see one thing and I another. Since we are not even on the same page regarding the most basic understanding of either film or text, then I'm sure you will agree that further debate between us is pointless.
Originally posted by Nóm
I suppose, but wish I understood about your Glorfindel/Aragorn idea. That isn't what this thread is for, and you and I are never on the same "wavelength" (for lack of better word)... so I guess it ends here.
But a problem I find with these discussions is that it is not clear why the film blames Aragorn for chosing the Path of Exile.
I did not say that he was not "strong enough", but I brought forth the points to illustrate that Jackson's supporters who say that Aragorn was a never failing "cardboard hero" who never "grew" during the course of the book.
jallan- with re. to the back story, what about my suggestion that Arathorn was slain in office in Gondor, and that Aragorn has chosen to stay in the North rather than returning to claim the kinship? I think there's evidence in the film story line for this, though I'm also well aware that there are many other possibilities at this point.Originally posted by jallan
What were those of that line supposed to do?
Make political overtures to dissident factions in Gondor, hoping to stage a coup or maybe a civil war?
Hire some lawyers and keep pushing and pushing and pushing the case?
Secretly arrange the assassination of the Steward and all his family?
...
I cannot make any coherent back story out of the hints given by the film that explain in what sense movie-Aragorn, any more than his ancestors, is to be blamed for not seeking the throne, unless indeed his ancestors in the film are known as northern trouble-makers, constantly interfering in the politics of Gondor with their claims, and he is thought wrong not to do the same?
I would like to point out that PJ is just following Tolkien here. Tolkien somewhat shrouded Aragorn's claim to the throne of Gondor, though that also is plain enough if you read slowly and carefully.I would like to point out here that I liked it that PJ chose Rivendell to "reveal" to the audience who in fact Aragorn is.
Yes, we see movie-Aragorn's fears about his own imperfection, which partly explains why he is, in fact, so perfect.Then, through the episodes at the Council of Elrond and of course the various conversations and talks in Rivendell we "get the picture" about this man. And what is most important, we see that "inner" struggle he has with himself!
There is nothing in the films to suggest that Aragorn was not all of these from long before we first see him, unless you wish to so interpret an enigmatic wink from Gandalf.In TTT he is starting to prove himself as the rightful king - a ruler of his time - valiant in battles, wise councellor, good war-startegist, one who cares for the fate of his world.
That doesn't explain exactly why Boromir says Gondor neither wants or needs a king, unless Arathorn had in some way, in some eyes, shamed the kingship.jallan- with re. to the back story, what about my suggestion that Arathorn was slain in office in Gondor, and that Aragorn has chosen to stay in the North rather than returning to claim the kinship? I think there's evidence in the film story line for this, though I'm also well aware that there are many other possibilities at this point.
Not so. From Appendix A:When Arvedui made the claim, there were men in Gondor who not only had the support of the people, but who could also claim descent from Anarion. No such person existed who was willing to press his claim after the death of Earnur.
It is possible that Aranarth was among those whose claim not all would allow.So it was that no claimant to the crown could be found who was of pure blood, or whose claim all would allow; and all feared the memory of the Kin-strife, knowing that if any such dissension arose again, then Gondor would perish.
Yes, we see movie-Aragorn's fears about his own imperfection, which partly explains why he is, in fact, so perfect.
'Isildur took it, as should not have been. It should have been cast into Orodruin's fire nigh at hand where it was made. But few marked what Isildur did. He alone stood by his father in that last mortal contest; and by Gil-galad only Cirdan stood, and I. But Isildur would not listen to our counsel.
'"This I will have as weregild for my father, and my brother," he said; and therefore whether we would or no, he took it to treasure it.'
Now movie-Aragorn, descendant of Isildur over a thousand years later, "fears that he might fail in the same way Isildur did, and does not want the power that comes with kingship."
Why should movie-Aragorn fear to be corrupted by a Ring of power that has been lost for a thousand years before it actually resurfaces?
It would be nice to know why movie-Aragorn chose the Path of Exile though none of his ancestors did so.
Or did they also renounce power? Do we have an entire lineage who chose the Path of Exile?
If Jackson does have a coherent story to tell about this, maybe he should tell it.
Originally quoted by jallan
So it was that no claimant to the crown could be found who was of pure blood, or whose claim all would allow; and all feared the memory of the Kin-strife, knowing that if any such dissension arose again, then Gondor would perish.
Wha? I thought claiming the throne through Isildur was a bad thing. Oh well, no accounting for Stewards, I suppose.From the Steward and the King
‘Men of Gondor hear now the Steward of this Realm! Behold! one has come to claim the kingship again at last. Here is Aragorn son of Arathorn, chieftain of the Dúnedain of Arnor, Captain of the Host of the West, bearer of the Star of the North, wielder of the Sword Reforged, victorious in battle, whose hands bring healing, the Elfstone, Elessar of the line of Valandil, Isildur’s son, Elendil’s son of Númenor. Shall he be king and enter into the City and dwell there?’
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?