The Tale of Years usually refers to Appendix B in LoTR.the "Tale of Years",
I don't have an 'absolute' answer from all the sources but I believe there are several threads on this issue here and no date has ever been brought forward before.I'd be curious of this too. I don't recall a specific date being given.
You are correct. I got out my copy of the book, and what I thought I had read there, I must have read somewhere else.
In one of his writings, Tolkien admitted he tried to avoid repeating names for the Elves, unlike the Dwarves who made it a bit of a habit.shouldn't they all have unique names so they don't get confused?
Legolasses?
. . . though Glorfindal is indeed (most likely) the same. (upon saying which, Ent awaits the retorts of those who disagree.)
'most likely' because there are two different categories of people who (may likely) differ from that opinion."most likely".
'most likely' because there are two different categories of people who (may likely) differ from that opinion.
1) - many who have not necessarily read the PPP, and 2) many who have not accepted them as definitive even if they have.
on the Glorfindel matter specifically?
Ent could have just said "Glorfindal IS the same" but is not desirous of starting World War TTF on any thing at any time, holding to a strict "no riots please" policy if at all possible. If this is insufficient there we have it. It's all there is.
Don't tell anyone but that's my conclusion as well.In either case, one Glorfindel
You do realize it is now PUBLIC information, right? 😅Don't tell anyone but that's my conclusion as well.
We aren't even certain (or at least I'm not) that Legolas was the true name of this character in The Fall of Gondolin, as opposed to being a later confusion of two names (see below), but anyway, at the time FG was written, this character was a Noldo . . . noting another elven character named Gimli.
"Note: Laigolas = green-leaf (...) But perhaps both were his names, as the Gnomes delighted to give two similar sounding names of dissimilar meaning, as Laigolas Legolast, Turin Turambar, etc. Legolas the ordinary form is a confusion of the two." JRRT The Book of Lost Tales
I don't think it would be any more awkward than a person meeting someone they are named after in this day and age.One thing I've wondered about: Since Elves are immortal and do not leave Arda as Men do, shouldn't they all have unique names so they don't get confused? How awkward would it be to meet your namesake in the Halls of Mandos?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?