• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Are 🧝Legolas from 'The Fall of Gondolin' and 'the' Legolas the same?

I don't consider the early Fall of Gonolin canon (according to my definition of canon), but that aside, Christopher Tolkien described this text briefly (Unfinished Tales):

"It is written in the extreme archaistic style that my father employed at that time, and it inevitably embodies conceptions out of keeping with the world of The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion in its published form. It belongs with the rest of the earliest phase of the Mythology, "The Book of Lost Tales"

Though that said, Christopher also noted that the early 1950s revision (as far as it went) "yet retained many of the essentials of the story written in his youth."

However, we didn't even get close to meeting any night sighted Elf in the version written decades later!

And even that version, found in Unfinished Tales (not intended as a chapter in Quenta Silmarillion but as a long prose account of one of the Great Tales) dates to the early 1950s. There's some later writing too (see Maeglin in The War of the Jewels, for example), but in any case, enter the multiple opinions about what Tolkien, if he had finished an updated version, "would have" kept in, tossed out, revised in some measure (or reworded), or added . . .

. . . in that light we have this very late note, for example: "The Duel of Glorfindel and the Demon may need revision" JRRT, marginal note, The Peoples of Middle-Earth, note 10, Last Writings

:)
Thanks. It is good to have clearly defined sources for all these things that I mostly knew, but didn't have a clue from where.

This all aside, do you believe it is the same Legolas?
 
legolas-what-do-your-elf-eyes-see-where-im-from-we-14327637.png
 
Having read "The Fall of Gondolin" for the first time about a year ago, I was quite surprised and pleased to have found my good friend Legolas Greenleaf present and playing a role in aiding The Escape (even if the mention was only in "The Original Tale" and not the other versions). I was pleased because of the extra depth it brought to the character I knew so well from decades of reading LOTR. Then, I joined the conversation in this thread, and encountered this pesky Grandmaster Loremaster named Elthir :) giving me all of this new information beyond what I'd read. And, this new information detracts from the "extra depth" for Legolas I was enjoying. So, after some "Elthir-inspired" study, here's where I'm at now:

If I only look at what's in the texts of LOTR and The Fall of Gondolin I still have no problem with the two Legolas's being one and the same. I don't have to assume anything extraordinary for Legolas:

Assume Legolas comes to reside in the eastern end of Turgon's domain of Nevrast. Eastern Nevrast is halfway between Vinyamar and Gondolin, a good distance inland. (Legolas comes nowhere near the coast. This is important because LOTR tells us that Legolas had never seen the sea before). Maybe he serves to help protect the eastern borders of Nevrast.

When Turgon marches his population from Vinyamar to Gondolin, Legolas joins the march. He's already halfway there.

Even the final version of The Fall of Gondolin indicates a substantial Sindarin presence. Speaking of the Third Gate, The Gate of Bronze: "Again silently they passed the gate and saw in the court beyond a yet greater company of guards in mail that glowed like dull fire...Of the kindred of the Sindar of Nevrast for the most part were those that held this gate."

After Gondolin falls and the refugees escape, Legolas eventually goes his own way and travels eastward far enough to avoid the drowning of Beleriand.

Elthir,
Would you agree that within the constraints of my underlined "if statement" above that it's not problematic for Legolas to have been in Gondolin? Or, are there still other problems?
 
See, that seems more like a compliment... The other one is odd.
Yes. I always liked that little exchange in the book. Legolas says there are 105 horsemen with yellow hair and bright spears, and their leader is tall. When Aragorn compliments his eyesight, Legolas basically says: "Whatcha talkin' about? They're only 15 miles away!"

"What do your elf eyes see?" is a poor substitution. Peter Jackson missed an opportunity.
 
Yes. I always liked that little exchange in the book. Legolas says there are 105 horsemen with yellow hair and bright spears, and their leader is tall. When Aragorn compliments his eyesight, Legolas basically says: "Whatcha talkin' about? They're only 15 miles away!"

"What do your elf eyes see?" is a poor substitution. Peter Jackson missed an opportunity.
I know! I love the entire sequence in the book -- thanks for the refresh-- and Peter Jackson's adaption just isn't a suitable replacement. Disappointing.. But of course, certain things in Peter Jackson's version were well done, but I believe that list belongs somewhere else.
 
The Legolas in LOTR was born early in the 3rd Age. His birth year is given in the "Tale of Years."

Is there a page reference for this please? I confess my review of Peoples of Middle Earth, and Tale of Years within it, has been very brief, but I cannot find it, and pursuing the 'index' on all the pages on which Legolas is referenced, I can't find it.

I'll get back at it later, but for myself and for the moment, will need to leave the "will the real number of Legolas's please step Forward" issue with the Chief Cellrog in the "Great Halls of Speculation".
--------------------------

LATER ADDITION:
so now having taking a few moments, thus far, I can only find two clear references, which I'm sure all know, and some extenuating text to apply.

In the tale appears the keen-sighted Elf Legolas Greenleaf, first of the names of the Fellowship of the Ring to appear in my father’s writings (see p. 217 on this earlier Legolas), followed by Gimli (an Elf) in the Tale of Tinúviel. (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Book Of Lost Tales, Part Two (History of Middle-Earth 2) (p. 214). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.)

Here, Christopher seems to make a clear distinction between two Legolas persons.

Legolas ‘or Green-leaf was a man of the Tree, who led the exiles over Tumladin in the dark, being night-sighted, and he liveth still in Tol Eressëa named by the Eldar there Laiqalassë; but the book of Rúmil saith further hereon.’ (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Book Of Lost Tales, Part Two (History of Middle-Earth 2) (p. 217). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.)

Here we see a typical literary device used to speak to the ongoing future of a thing or person, intending to represent 'from then to current' whenever 'current' is. Tracking him from there to anywhere else is beyond what I can find in my quick research at present.

Of other relatively clear distinctions (so far) I can only find this one...

Legolas the former is "night-sighted", never "keen-sighted".
Legolas the latter is "keen-sighted" but never said to be "night-sighted".

And Gimli and Aragorn say this in LoTR when they're chasing the Orcs who took Merry and Pippin:
Gimli - ‘And there is this also,’ said Gimli: ‘only by day can we see if any tracks lead away. If a prisoner should escape, or if one should be carried off, eastward, say, to the Great River, towards Mordor, we might pass the signs and never know it.’
Aragorn - "‘We will not walk in the dark,’ he said at length. ‘The peril of missing the trail or signs of other coming and going seems to me the greater. If the Moon gave enough light, we would use it, but alas! he sets early and is yet young and pale."

If this 2nd Legolas were 'night-sighted' he would have said "I will not miss them" or some such thing.
After all, it was the first Legolas that "lead the exiles" before BECAUSE he was night-sighted.
And we should keep in mind that it was 2nd Legolas that was most anxious to keep on during the night so they did not lose more ground in following the Orcs (yet never brought a night-sightedness into the conversation to overcome the concern for missing more attempts by the Hobbits to escape.)

Given that Tolkien had written much earlier about the former Legolas, he was well aware of that Legolas' "night-sightedness". If he intended this to be the same Legolas, he would not have failed to make use of his prior developed senses.

So for me at this point the weight of evidence points to our having two separate Legolas persons in view.
 
Last edited:
Is there a page reference for this please? I confess my review of Peoples of Middle Earth, and Tale of Years within it, has been very brief, but I cannot find it, and pursuing the 'index' on all the pages on which Legolas is referenced, I can't find it.

I'll get back at it later, but for myself and for the moment, will need to leave the "will the real number of Legolas's please step Forward" issue with the Chief Cellrog in the "Great Halls of Speculation".
--------------------------

LATER ADDITION:
so now having taking a few moments, thus far, I can only find two clear references, which I'm sure all know, and some extenuating text to apply.

In the tale appears the keen-sighted Elf Legolas Greenleaf, first of the names of the Fellowship of the Ring to appear in my father’s writings (see p. 217 on this earlier Legolas), followed by Gimli (an Elf) in the Tale of Tinúviel. (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Book Of Lost Tales, Part Two (History of Middle-Earth 2) (p. 214). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.)

Here, Christopher seems to make a clear distinction between two Legolas persons.

Legolas ‘or Green-leaf was a man of the Tree, who led the exiles over Tumladin in the dark, being night-sighted, and he liveth still in Tol Eressëa named by the Eldar there Laiqalassë; but the book of Rúmil saith further hereon.’ (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Book Of Lost Tales, Part Two (History of Middle-Earth 2) (p. 217). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.)

Here we see a typical literary device used to speak to the ongoing future of a thing or person, intending to represent 'from then to current' whenever 'current' is. Tracking him from there to anywhere else is beyond what I can find in my quick research at present.

Of other relatively clear distinctions (so far) I can only find this one...

Legolas the former is "night-sighted", never "keen-sighted".
Legolas the latter is "keen-sighted" but never said to be "night-sighted".

And Gimli and Aragorn say this in LoTR when they're chasing the Orcs who took Merry and Pippin:
Gimli - ‘And there is this also,’ said Gimli: ‘only by day can we see if any tracks lead away. If a prisoner should escape, or if one should be carried off, eastward, say, to the Great River, towards Mordor, we might pass the signs and never know it.’
Aragorn - "‘We will not walk in the dark,’ he said at length. ‘The peril of missing the trail or signs of other coming and going seems to me the greater. If the Moon gave enough light, we would use it, but alas! he sets early and is yet young and pale."

If this 2nd Legolas were 'night-sighted' he would have said "I will not miss them" or some such thing.
After all, it was the first Legolas that "lead the exiles" before BECAUSE he was night-sighted.
And we should keep in mind that it was 2nd Legolas that was most anxious to keep on during the night so they did not lose more ground in following the Orcs (yet never brought a night-sightedness into the conversation to overcome the concern for missing more attempts by the Hobbits to escape.)

Given that Tolkien had written much earlier about the former Legolas, he was well aware of that Legolas' "night-sightedness". If he intended this to be the same Legolas, he would not have failed to make use of his prior developed senses.

So for me at this point the weight of evidence points to our having two separate Legolas persons in view.
"Frodo looked up at the Elf standing tall above him, as he gazed into the night...His head was dark, crowned with sharp white stars that glittered in the black pools of the sky behind...Soon it appeared as a great winged creature, blacker than the pits in the night...Suddenly the great bow of Lorien sang..."

"Praised be the bow of Galadriel, and the hand and eye of Legolas!" said Gimli..."That was a mighty shot in the dark, my friend!"


I spent some time the other day trying to find better references in LOTR indicating Legolas had exceptional night-sight for an elf, but this remains the best I could find. I was hoping to find something better to support the single Legolas theory.
 
this pesky Grandmaster Loremaster named Elthir

It seems wise to me to pay attention to the sayings of the 'pesky Grandmaster @Elthir ' and, as you have well done, to pursue the studies further seeing if what he says may be so. He seems to have a knack for directing one to a more accurate or more complete course of understanding - or if in the end there is still disagreement, the reasoning is all the better clarified.

That said, he's not Eru. But he also seems more than willing to interchange over varying thoughts without recrimination.

We hope though it truly does not 'detract' from your enjoyments, but rather in the end, IF any change is needed based on his input, it enhances.
 
It seems wise to me to pay attention to the sayings of the 'pesky Grandmaster @Elthir ' and, as you have well done, to pursue the studies further seeing if what he says may be so. He seems to have a knack for directing one to a more accurate or more complete course of understanding - or if in the end there is still disagreement, the reasoning is all the better clarified.

That said, he's not Eru. But he also seems more than willing to interchange over varying thoughts without recrimination.

We hope though it truly does not 'detract' from your enjoyments, but rather in the end, IF any change is needed based on his input, it enhances.
Well said. I don't think I really have a disagreement. I'm just having some fun trying to maintain the single Legolas history I prefer, in spite of the ample evidence and reasoning Elthir provides to the contrary.😎
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ent
Well said. I don't think I really have a disagreement. I'm just having some fun trying to maintain the single Legolas history I prefer, in spite of the ample evidence and reasoning Elthir provides to the contrary.😎

And I thank you for bringing it forward. I had determinedly avoided any pursuit of the "Legolas Issue" in favor of other issues more 'immediately' in view for me. (Being rather new to the study of the Lore as well as much of the Lore itself, it all gets tossed onto one big list of 'find out about it'.)

Now, having come to my own 'initial conclusion' on it based on my (admittedly less than complete) research, I can toss it back into the "Great Halls of Speculation" where our Chief Cellrog will keep an eye on it until it's time for me to retrieve it for further exploration.

I'm so excited to be at last able to explore all this stuff..!

"Frodo looked up at the Elf standing tall above him, as he gazed into the night...His head was dark, crowned with sharp white stars that glittered in the black pools of the sky behind...Soon it appeared as a great winged creature, blacker than the pits in the night...Suddenly the great bow of Lorien sang..."

"Praised be the bow of Galadriel, and the hand and eye of Legolas!" said Gimli..."That was a mighty shot in the dark, my friend!"


I spent some time the other day trying to find better references in LOTR indicating Legolas had exceptional night-sight for an elf, but this remains the best I could find. I was hoping to find something better to support the single Legolas theory.

And yet this does have its 'features of interest' as Sherlock Holmes would say.
I shall bring it alongside when next I spring Legolas from the 'Great Halls...' for another review.
 
(. . .) After Gondolin falls and the refugees escape, Legolas eventually goes his own way and travels eastward far enough to avoid the drowning of Beleriand.

Elthir, would you agree that within the constraints of my underlined "if statement" above that it's not problematic for Legolas to have been in Gondolin? [If I only look at what's in the texts of LOTR and The Fall of Gondolin]

Hmm. In the updated Fall of Gondolin (Unfinished Tales) there's no "Legolas" because the tale ends so painfully early. And in the early Fall of Gondolin (Lost Tales) the people of Gondolin were that "kin of the Noldoli who alone escaped Melko's power when, at the battle of Unnumbered Tears he slew and enslaved their folk . . ."

That said, we could say that the updated version takes precedence here, with respect to a Sindarin presence in the city, and I certainly have no problem with that.

Regarding the refugees: of course, here again the updated version gets nowhere near to describing what happens to them, but the early version goes so far as to describe their wanderings, even give their numbers, and in the end, notes: "Yet now those exiles of Gondolin dwelt at the mouth of Sirion by the waves of the Great Sea."

And jumping to The Lord of the Rings, for another example, it would appear that Thranduil passed eastward from Lindon (near the sea yet again, in any case). So, I guess it depends upon what's "too" problematic (as this can get subjective) when inventing a special history for Legolas to allow for a given scenario.

I'll put it this way, for myself, I'm not swayed to imagine this scenario as "true" within my personal legendarium -- although I don't get the feeling that you're trying to sway me in any case!

And I'd hate to detract from anyone's enjoyment of anything Tolkienian!

But people ask questions, so I give my opinions . . . sometimes :)
 
I'll put it this way, for myself, I'm not swayed to imagine this scenario as "true" within my personal legendarium -- although I don't get the feeling that you're trying to sway me in any case!

And I'd hate to detract from anyone's enjoyment of anything Tolkienian!

But people ask questions, so I give my opinions . . . sometimes :)
Thanks for providing your thoughts. You've been very generous with your time!

And, correct, I'm not so much trying to sway you as just looking for significant problems in the way I'm approaching the question of Legolas.

My comment in the previous post about "detracting" was certainly written with a smile on my face...intended in good humor. I'm quite enjoying exploring the issues under discussion. So...no worries there.
😎
 

Similar threads

Back
Top