Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
As Ugluk stepped off the podium, and moved to the recieving line to shake hands with his supporters, Grishnakh slunk in from the shadows and throttled Ugluk, leaving him a bloody, pulsating, dead mess. Then he took Ugluk's victory tiara, placed it on his own hideous head, and took Ugluk's place in the recieving line.
As Ugluk stepped off the podium, and moved to the recieving line to shake hands with his supporters, Grishnakh slunk in from the shadows and throttled Ugluk, leaving him a bloody, pulsating, dead mess. Then he took Ugluk's victory tiara, placed it on his own hideous head, and took Ugluk's place in the recieving line.
Nope. Grishnakh was busy over by the entrance gates to Isengard signing autographs because he had more screen time than Ugluk in the movies when an enraged purist snuck in and skewered him for daring to have a different death in the movie than in the book.
(With apologies for sneaking a movie reference into the book forum. )
Actually, while your description of Grishnakh 'slinking' might be accurate, this is NOT an RPG- it is a poll. And I note (with some satisfaction) that the leader in this poll for the past year has been Ugluk. Post negated, victory celebration commenced! All hail the pentorclete champion: Ugluk!!
Had to go with Grishnakh. After all, he couldn't have been Captain of the Dark Tower for his niceties. Besides... 'slinking away' is hardly a character flaw... to an Orc!
I see the race is rather tight... let's get some more members polled!
I reread The Uruk-hai chapter of TTT last night after getting home. As far as I can find it says Grishnakh was a messenger from Lugburz, not Captain of the Tower. Evidently Grishnakh is attempting to increase his low-cunning score by pretending to a more exalted position than the lowly one of messenger. Ugluk the Magnificent does not bow to shrieking, pretenders from Mordor.
Keep reading. It's actually a rather obscure reference. It's in Appendix F - in the section on Orcs and the Black Speech, where Tolkien slips in this tidbit about Grishnakh. I can post the pertinent paragraph later, if I get the chance... but it's just sort of an offhand remark.
The inscription on the Ring was in the ancient Black Speech, while the curse of the Mordor-orc in II, 53. was in the more debased form used by the soldiers of the Dark Tower, of whomGrishnákh was the captain.
[My emphasis]
The reference is indeed obscure. There was probably such embarrassment over Grishnakh's poor performance and shrieking death it was an attempt to hide his rank posthumously. I see the great Ugluk has picked up another vote since I last checked. Ugluk, Ugluk, UGLUK!!
I do not think it is quibbling to elucidate a point that has been the subject of debate for the last six posts. Indeed, even now it seems as if my posting of the pertinent passage has failed in increasing your understanding insofar as the relevant pronoun is whom, not which, indicating that Grishnákh was the captain of the soldiers of the Dark Tower, not of the Dark Tower itself.