• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Best 🧌Orc Pentathlete

Choose the best Orc Pentathlete

  • Gorbag

    Votes: 6 7.2%
  • Grishnakh

    Votes: 27 32.5%
  • Shagrat

    Votes: 15 18.1%
  • Ugluk

    Votes: 35 42.2%

  • Total voters
    83
Let consider Low Cunning for a moment:

Ugluk is ordered to return with a Halfing. Ugluks response: Death March in straight line until killed by Horse Boys.

Grishnakh is ordered to return with a Halfling. First he tries to convince Ugluk the Intelligence-Challenged that his plan will lead to disaster.

Not getting too far thru the thick bone layer surrounding Ugluk's pea-brain, he ON HIS OWN INTIATIVE, returns to get reinforcements. He arrives back at the party and gives Mr. SAT another chance to deviate from his disastrous "plan."

Finally, ON HIS OWN INTIATIVE, he grabs the halflings, one in each powerful paw, and legs it away.

Can you imaginge using the phrase "ON HIS OWN INTIATIVE" when speaking about Ugluk. It is to laugh--harshly, of course.
 
Shirley you are not deriding the Death March. It is a staple of the pentorclon. Orcs are encouraged to do such an event at every opportunity, starting from very early on in life. Laud Low Cunning all you want, but please give Death Marching it's due.
 
Both Shirley and I consider "Death Marching" to be one of the sacred 5 pillars of the Penathlon, no less in stature than "Low Cunning," "Insults", "Threats," and "Brute Strength." Hence the Orc Pentathlete Champion, Grishnakh the Great, is MIddle-Earth Class in all these Orcly pursuits.
 
And yet another vote for Ugluk. Grishnakh may be good at Brute Strength and Death Marching, but he is far inferior to Ugluk the Magnificent, who was twice runner-up to Schwarzenegger in the Mr. Ea competition. Still too early to declare a Pentorclete champion, in my books.
 
Another appeal to all who love Grishnakh, the real Orc, is in order.

Remember Ugluk's brave charge at the Horse Boys. Is that Orc behavior? Not on your life! Orcs are not stinkin heros. They are Orcs: low cunning, betrayal, run-away--those are the traits the Orc Pentathlon cherishes.

So stab Ugluk in the back and vote for Grishnakh!
Grrrrrrrrzzzzzzzzek!
 
Ah, a deviously (and Lowly) Cunning argument. Adopting a slogan that even the Uglukiest Orc will espouse: Ugluk the Magnificent is Brave. So hard to argue with. I'll just remind the voters which Orc they'd rather have accepting the laurels: The one thinking about stabbing them in the back later, or the one too proud to pay them a second thought. The truest pillar of Orcish thought: if it's bigger and stronger than you, respect it. That is all Ugluk asks.
 
How about Goblins? Azog? He killed Thror. But he still was killed by Dain Ironfoot.....O well nevermind

I know Azog was a Uruk, I was nominating him, And I wanted to know if there was a poll about Goblins too
 
Last edited:
Azog was a Uruk, same as Shagrat, Gorbag, and Grishnakh. I think this can be demonstrated by looking at the tale of years, seeing when Uruks first arise (TA 2475), when Sauron begins to populate Moria with his Orcs (~TA 2480), and where Azog is found (Moria, ~TA 2750).
Azog was already ranked by VofK: http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?s=&postid=50174#post50174
As you can see, he did better than the Snaga but worse than Grishnakh or Ugluk.

And now that there has been new information uncovered, I think it's time to recalculate this (I'm demanding a recount):
originally posted by Harad the White
--------------------Ugluk--------Grishnakh

Death Marching-------------10---------10
Insults---------------------8----------9
Threats--------------------10----------8
Brute Strength-------------10----------8
Low Cunning-----------------6---------10

Total----------------------44---------45
As we now know, Grishnakh cheated in the Death March, so I move that Grishnakh's Death Marching score be reduced accordingly, making Ugluk the leader by scoring, if not by actual voting.
 
Time for a recount?

Eight months have passed since this legendary pentathlon began. As we are nearing the realization of the event on screen, I think it is only fair that the newer members of our forum get the opportunity to voice their opinion on such an important matter.
Also, as the campaign manager for Mr. Grishnakh (shrieker) is regrettably unable to state his case, I will keep my own campaigning on behalf of Ugluk (the magnificent) to a (sublinibababable) minimum.
 
I will be the campaign manager for the legendary Grishnakh. This was the first thread I posted in.

Grishnakh is the clear winner. Ugluk shouldnt even be allowed in, as he is not even a proper orc. Miserable wizardling-spawn... pah!
 
I voted for Grishnakh as well.

Shagrats a simpering puppy and a wimp and all-in-all lame, Ugluk isn't even a proper Orc as Snaga states, and Gorbag doesn't even deserve to be on the poll!!

Besides, Grishnakh just kicks @$$. My brother and I used to fight about this. He wanted Ugluk and he'd scream "URUK-HAI!" and I wanted Grishnakh and I'd scream, "YRCH!" Hehe. Even just last night at the dinner table he put his arms in the air and said, "Yrch!!" and I did the same.
Quite fun...anyway.
 
Wonks, I can't believe what I'm reading. Just precisely whose @$$ does Grishnakh kick? Certainly not Ugluk's. Grishnakh runs away from Ugluk at every available opportunity. In what way is turning tail considered to be kicking @$$??? Of the four Orcs on the poll, Grishnakh alone stands out as the only one with no confirmed kills. Ugluk, on the other hand, kills not only Orcs (hey, who can't), but also MOUNTED KNIGHTS OF ROHAN. Even Harad conceded that Ugluk kicks the most butt.
 
Even a fan of Mordor Orcs has a better candidate than Grishnakh to look up to. I'll just remind everybody that at one point there w ere ~200 Orcs in the Tower of Cirith Ungol. A day after the arrival of Frodo's Mithril shirt there was one orc left alive, clenching the coat in his remaining claw. That Orc? Shagrat. Grishnakh would have been hoofing it off to Lugburz in order to clean his soiled breaks the moment things got ugly. Of course, as good as Shagrat was I think it's pretty apparent that Ugluk would have come out of the scuffle with a couple more lads, and probably would have taken care of Sam in short order. Ah well, not every Orc is born Magnificent, and Shagrat is still pretty admirable, if Apes of Lugburz are more you're speed.
 
Shagrat, good?!? Are you kidding?
He was a wimp and a coward! He deserves NO votes!!!

*draws her bow and arrow* Don't MAKE me slay you!
 
WtS, what is the basis for saying that Shagrat was a wimp and a coward? Here's some quotes I'm happy to provide that show how Grishnnakh and Shagrat deal with challenges to their authority. You tell me who looks like a wimp:

Shagrat: "Come here and I'll squeeze your eyes out, like I did to Radbug just now. And when some new lads come, I'll deal with you: I'll send you to Shelob."

Grishnakh: Grishnakh stepped aside and vanished into the shadows.
 
You can pick any two quotes to make it SEEM like you're right but you're not!

I don't have my book with me! But I'll get it and I'll show you!!!

*runs off to get her book*
 
Any 2 quotes? There aren't a lot of relevant quotes, but the facts is the facts:

Number of times Grishnakh confronts Ugluk openly: 1
Number of times said confrontations end with Grishnakh running away: 1
Number of other times in the books Grishnakh runs away: 2
Number of times Grishnakh is described as shrieking: 1
Number of times in the books Grishnakh sticks around for a fight: 0
Number of confirmed kills for Grishnakh: 0

On the other hand we have Shagrat
Number of times Shagrat is confronted with combat: 2
Number of times Shagrat runs away: 1
Number of confirmed kills for Shagrat after he is injured: 2

And finally, Ugluk:
Number of times Ugluk is confronted with Combat: 4
Number of times Ugluk runs away: 0
Number of Orcs Ugluk kills: 1+
Number of Humans Ugluk and his boys Kill: Boromir + several Rohan knights
Number of Humans killed by the other three Pentorclon candidates combined: 0
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top