• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Cannons? Gun Powder? Rockets?

Yes; most of the magic of the Eldar was nothing to do with "technology" but with art. Take the Silmarils, for instance. Undoubtably magic, but made for the sole pupose of its beauty. Magic was also beneficial when it was used for healing. But it became "evil", a "Machine" to use Tolkien's terminology, when it was used for a materialistic purpose. And to quote French poet Théophile Gautier:
Il n'y a de vraiment beau que ce qui ne peut servir à rien [...] L'endroit le plus utile d'une maison, ce sont les latrines. The only really beautiful things are useless things. The most useful place in a house is the toilet.
 
Rúmil,poetry?Very,very interesting....and as a matter of fact I agree with you about the meaning of "machine" and "magic".Even nowadays "machine" doesn't sound very nice.....:cool:
 
Originally posted by Rúmil
Allthough bows long remained more precice that muskets, in our world, they had fallen completely out of use by the middle of the 15th century. Pecision wasn't needed, just a weapon you could teach a conscript to use in a week.

As for orcs and guns, well, first, as you said, they would be shot by Noldor or Númenoreans before they could get in range. But also, bear in mind that the force of the Orcs was in sheer numbers. Giving them crude bows and swords that could be made in very lage numbers at little cost and in a short time was all right, not giving them costly artefacts that they were liable to lose or break, and that was not very reliable anyway. (an early musket is a very capricious item)

And as for the absence of technological avance on the "good" side, well they were intelligent enough to realise that technology is not good in itself if it can be done without, and that progress is useless and damaging.

Good point. Also there are still a few places on this planet where so-called "primative" cultures survivie using a way of life that goes back many thousands of years, some dispite our attempts to "civilise" them.
 
The previous poster is thinking of Greek Fire which combusts on contact with water, interestingly enough for our debate here the secret of its making has been lost (as I'm sure many of the old secrets of Numenor were) also so are the machines built by Aristole which he used to terrify the Romans (interestingly enough Aristole was on the point of playing with calculus before he got whacked and had his reasonings survived instead of being buried in some monestry for years we might be in a very different technological position)
 
Greek... turkish... I was close... Turkey is close to Greece. When you cook turkey you might baste it with Greece.
 
Originally posted by HLGStrider
Greek... turkish... I was close... Turkey is close to Greece.
If you ever visit Cyprus, just don't make a comment like this one, you might get strangled... ;)
 
Not planning to go to Cyprus... Nor Kashmir... Nor anywhere in the Balkan Peninsula.... I'll stay home... nice and safe here...

Roast Rumil... Sounds delicious... :p
 
Why not in the Balkans HLGStrider?Bulgaria has so beautiful nature and it's so calm and quite place with nice people like me!:cool: :cool:
As a matter of fact I start thinking you have some problems with Rumil,just calm down and come in the Balkans.
 
Didn't mean to offend, Gil... I was trying to decide whether to use the Balkans or Peru and Balkans won out... Never been to Peru either... I was more thinking of Bosnia when I said Balkans however.
 
You should think more of Macedonia,Albania and Kosovo than Bosnia.In Bosnia now is safer than in these countries.But if you decide someday to visit BG I promise you'll like it pretty much, especially something called "Rakia"(drink which is stronger than a mix of Tequila and Vodka) :cool: :cool: :p
 
I'm not old enough to drink beer, let alone Rakia... :rolleyes:

However, I don't exactly like the way alcohalic beverages smell or taste... that's just from taking my uncle's dare to sip his wine and smelling other realatives drinks at Holidays. Smells like turpantine.
 
oooo....HLGStrider you probably know that Russians are those who drink most in the whole world.....well....we(Bulgarians)are at second place:)
So you're welcome to join me when you get older:p ?You'll like BG,I'm sure:cool:
 
Will do, Gil... If I'm ever rich enough for world travel... hey,there's always price line .com... :) ;) :D
 
Well then you'd better come sometime in summer in BG cause we have beautiful sea and by the way.......the bulgariam women are said to be one of the most beautiful in the world.Trust me I live here.;) and I have many friends from abroad who share the same opinion.:p
 
I'm female... Actually I am the most beautiful woman in the world... can't you tell???
 
I do that to people.

You are hardly the first. I made the mistake of having the Strider name. It throws everybody off.
 
Uhm..uhm....I must confess you're right I thought you were a boy.....heheheehh:) .BTW I wrote you a pm.
 
Received and replied... Of course I gave up a little of my disguise... Still, I think the general portion of this forum knows me as Elgee i Nanar or Chel, my two very female Role Playing characters... So it wasn't that much of a secret.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top