Sorry I missed this comment. However this was what my wandering, forgetful mind was referring to.I think Cart is referring to JRRT's hope with respect to Milton Waldman -- at this point Tolkien wanted The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings published -- briefly put, things didn't work out with Waldman
-- Tolkien ultimately ends up "back" with Allen and Unwin -- and at the time, A&U were only willing to publish The Lord of the Rings.
But yes, long before this, Tolkien had sent parts of his Elder Days material for feedback -- with respect to a possible publishment [a word?] of the larger work [Silmarillion stuff].
That's a hard concept for some people on Tolkien and many other topics, unfortunately.Buy, don't buy. Read, don't read. Nobody is forcing anyone 🤷
I fear there is great risk in pursuing this line of discussion, as many are quite vociferous about many things.And how can a man's heir be a 'grave robber'? What sense does that make? He was already entitled to Tolkien's work. You can't 'steal' what's yours.
The opposite sort of phenomena is equally ridiculous to me, where people assume that because Marvel or whomever has the legal rights to something that I must accept and praise the product, or else be a traitor. I like good comics, I couldn't care less about whether some corporate dinosaur has the legal rights or not, and I have no 'brand loyalty' whatsoever. If Image comics started publishing Superman tomorrow I'd probably stop buying DC comics.I think that's part of the problem. People feel so invested in some things they believe it's their property. It's a bit like football teams (I am a big football fan) where people are very vocal about how a club should be run but God forbid they put their own money where their mouth is. 🙈
Wheel of Time itself might be classed as a spin off fantasy of the book 😂😭Spin off fantasy might be Wheel of Time. But this?????
Assuming this season is a success then we can expect further departures from the source in the future. This is the Hollywood way. Even PJ did not deviate from the sources too much initially.
What possible moral objections could there be to CT's work?I fear there is great risk in pursuing this line of discussion, as many are quite vociferous about many things.
That said, I BELIEVE the feeling boils down to this:
. it's not that he 'owned' and 'had the rights' to it... it's that he DID something with it (in fulfillment of his father's wishes.)
Though of course, it's not stated in those terms.
And some of what was done with it is quite disagreed with, though it's all been quite legally done.
It boils down to a moral vs. a legal line of thinking, morals of course being quite a different and more fluid matter than the Law.
Some will no doubt feel I'm being overly simplistic. Yet we do have a tendency to over-complicate things.
I have no idea. you would need to ask those who consider him a 'grave digger'. i believe it has solely to do with his use of his father's works to 'make money' and that alone. from that springs a feeling of 'moral indignity'. (it also applies to many other of the things people fuss about with regard to Tolkien's work.)What possible moral objections could there be to CT's work?
Well, practically no philosopher in history can agree to precise defintions of what morality is, what constitutes a moral or immoral [thing/act], and while a lot of 'popular' moralism has overlap a lot of 'popular' anything is rubbish which they can't possibly defend with reason. Therefor it is quite plausible for someone to find almost anything 'morally objectionable' and defend it just about as well as anything else.What possible moral objections could there be to CT's work?
I have no idea. you would need to ask those who consider him a 'grave digger'. i believe it has solely to do with his use of his father's works to 'make money' and that alone. from that springs a feeling of 'moral indignity'. (it also applies to many other of the things people fuss about with regard to Tolkien's work.)
People (often rightfully) feel that when people do art with the explicit goal of making money they often compromise their product. On the other hand, I would say that making art solely for yourself is narcissistic, and often ends up with a 'product' nobody else cares about. I'd imagine a large part of the Nerd Rage is people who are disappointed by the final form of the work and, rather than blame JRR for dithering and not finishing his products, they blame Christopher for finishing it for him.To get the material published it has to be sellable. If The Silmarillion or The book of lost tales been commercial failures we would not have seen the rest in print. CT would presumably then simply sorted and edited the unpublished material and then donated or sold it to a suitable institution. The fact is the work proved sellable, and the rest is (to coin a phrase) history. Why should this cause moral indignation? What was CT supposed to do? Self publish the lot? Donate it to a library on masse?
May we all say the "Amen"..!!! (This assumes folks know what "amen" means, of course.)I find it's best to just not engage people when you don't share their valuations, because there's usually a lot more rationalization than rationality involved in such things.
Yep, don't argue with idiots or trolls.People (often rightfully) feel that when people do art with the explicit goal of making money they often compromise their product. On the other hand, I would say that making art solely for yourself is narcissistic, and often ends up with a 'product' nobody else cares about. I'd imagine a large part of the Nerd Rage is people who are disappointed by the final form of the work and, rather than blame JRR for dithering and not finishing his products, they blame Christopher for finishing it for him.
Really, though, I find it's best to just not engage people when you don't share their valuations, because there's usually a lot more rationalization than rationality involved in such things.
I dunno. Perhaps encase it all in indestructible plastic and bury it underneath the worlds largest and deepest buried deposit of nuclear waste...!Why should this cause moral indignation? What was CT supposed to do? Self publish the lot? Donate it to a library on masse?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?