• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Did Jackson Misinterpret the Story?

It looks beautiful and is full of action and drama, but somewhere along the way, the people and the meaning of it all gets lost.

Just out of curiousity...what is YOUR interpretation of the meaning of Tolkien's work, and your interpretation PJs presentation. Not what he says he means by everything, but your interpretation of the film that appeared on the EE.

*gets the feeling this could produce a big post*
 
I will ask a question back: what do you think Jackson is saying in his story?

What is the point of the story (and by that I don't mean the plot)?

Is he producing a great myth as did Tolkien or just another very well done and exciting adventure story with characters little or no different (and I don't mean in their costumes and makeup) from the same "type" of characters that appear in most adventure films?

Does the film's cinematic wonders including special effects overwhelm the characters? And, remember, most of us are watching the film having read the books and understanding Tolkien's myth but there are many others who don't have that advantage.

Sadly, most would say that despite the deviations, Jackson is making the same points as Tolkien. I would disagree, but I am older and perhaps that is why I am able to see that many of the characters have been so changed in the film that they cannot possibly represent the virtues and moral concepts that they represented in the book. Does this change the "plot line?" Perhaps not. Does it change the meaning of the tale? Yes it does, but if that change isn't obvious to the viewer, no amount of 'explanation' will reveal it.
 

With all due respect, one has to accept the fact that different people may find different meanings in the tale. And after that one has to realize that not everyone is claiming PJ captured every little theme and idea from Tolkiens book. He captured the main themes, "main" being the key word here. Something tells me this isn't so much about not understanding the book as it is about having extremely relegated and unfair expectations. We may both agree on the themes of the book, but if I am going in the theatre to see one kind of movie and you are going in to see another, we are bound to disagree.
 
What, then, as I asked, is the "main theme" of the book? Is it only an "adventure story"? You see, there is a subtlety in Tolkien's work that the film has missed. Probably any film would have missed it and that's what Christopher Tolkien meant when he said the work was to complex to bring to the screen. Whatever one believes that theme to be, Jackson did not see the book as "selling" to the viewing public in its original form and so, he changed it. You believe that he was able to maintain the author's vision despite the changes. He was less concerned with Tolkien's "vision" and more concerned about his own. Did he make a good movie? So far, yes. Is it Tolkien's story? Even Jackson admits that, aside from the superficial structure, it is not. But then, we've been down this road before without profit for either point of view.
 
An excellent point Mrs MAggot,
Thankk you for educating me and correcting the error of my ways
- Johovishta
 
>>That's a bold declaration in itself, but, because your knowledge of THE Ring, and your elegant style of discussion and writing, suggest you are someone whose opinion is worth knowing, I respect and acknowledge it!<<

Deep breath!! And with apologies for the length and any incoherence.

Although Tolkien’s LOTR obviously has many themes, three lie at the heart of both the book and Tolkien’s own vision of the world. They are both conceptually interconnected and interact decisively at the story’s climax.

1. The fundamental nature of the world and the intentions of its creator (God, “the One”, Eru) are good. Good actions are in harmony with the nature of the world and will tend towards being successful (though not necessarily achieving a precisely envisaged outcome), whereas evil actions are discordant with the nature of the world, tend to go awry and may even achieve unintended “good” outcomes.

2. Nothing is evil in the beginning (“even Sauron was not so”). Tolkien is no dualist. Therefore everyone is potentially redeemable. But since God is the only adequate judge of such matters, pity and mercy are a necessary duty for the rest of us.

3. Since we have free will, it is necessary to make choices. The evil of the Ring lies in the fact that it limits free will and removes choice. With the Ring Sauron can dominate the wills of others - that is the power of the Ring. The Ringwraiths have no will of their own, they are the slaves of the Ring. Gollum’s will has been almost entirely sapped by the Ring and Frodo’s will be. The ultimate evil of the orcs lies not in the fact that they themselves are evil, but in the way that they have been so fundamentally warped by Morgoth/Sauron/Saruman that they no longer have the power to choose to be good.

It is only by the interaction of these three themes that the Ring is ultimately destroyed. Frodo, of course, in the end cannot will to destroy the Ring and claims it for his own, and yet Tolkien did not regard this as a failure on his part, because the destruction of the Ring takes place as a result of Frodo’s choice to take the Ring to Mordor, combined with Frodo’s decision to show mercy to Gollum. Frodo’s pity for Gollum and his freely taken decision to shoulder the burden of the Ring’s destruction created the situation whereby the Ring was in fact destroyed. Not because Gollum is a convenient plot device to resolve a difficult situation, but because, in Tolkien’s view, that is how the world works; Frodo made various choices, which, although they were not in themselves obviously destined for success or even perhaps in Frodo’s immediate or long-term self interest, were good in and of themselves, in harmony with the nature of the world and its creator’s intentions and thus achieved a successful, if unlooked for, outcome.

So how is this view of the world reflected in the film? Well, it is interesting that these three themes are explicity stated or implied together in the Gandalf’s words to Frodo in the Mines of Moria. A speech constructed almost entirely verbatim from Tolkien’s own words. Gandalf impresses upon Frodo (1) the importance of Bilbo’s mercy to Gollum, the fact that he has no right to deal out death in judgement when he cannot also give life (the prerogative of the Creator), (2) that it is necessary for Frodo to choose what to do with the time that is given him, and (3) that Frodo was meant to have the Ring (i.e. that there is a benevolent intention behind many of the apparent chances of the world). It seems unlikely, to me at least, that these three ideas should have been so juxtaposed and given such a prominent place in the film by accident. In fact one of them is re-emphasised at the end of the film as Frodo stands at the water’s edge steeling himself to make the choice he knows he has to make.

Of course the many different changes to the film have been made for many different reasons - pacing, structure, visual effectiveness, director’s whim etc., but several of the major ones and particularly those that have most worried/irritated/annoyed/enraged some fans, if this website is anything to go by, do seem to me to have been motivated by PJ’s (or his fellow scripwriters') desire to emphasise these themes and most of all the theme of choice and free will. For example:

The change to Aragorn’s character emphasises that he must make a choice to accept his destiny. And as presented in the film, I don't think that he can be accused of moral cowardice (he is clearly no physical coward), rather he is someone who is only too well aware of what will be staked on the outcome of such a choice. He is the heir of Isildur, and, as is emphasised on several occasions and shown in the scene between Gandalf and Elrond, it was Isildur's choice not to destroy the Ring that has allowed Sauron to return. Therefore, in the scene with Frodo at Amon Hen we see Aragorn choose to reject the Ring - our first clear sign that Aragorn may be Isildur's heir but he has not inherited Isildur's weakness, he is his own man.

This of course is also in vivid contrast to Boromir's attempt to take the Ring moments before. (But note Frodo’s words to Aragorn – “the Ring has taken Boromir” not "Boromir tried to take the Ring" – with the implication that the Ring had robbed him of his free will.) Also it would seem from reviews of TTT that the change to Faramir has possibly been made in order to emphasise that unlike his brother he chooses to reject the Ring and let Frodo go, by making the brothers more alike than in the book and showing the different choices that each makes when the moment for choice arrives.

Whereas in the book Galadriel has clearly considered and rejected the temptation of the Ring before Frodo offers it to her, in the film we see her make the choice and be shaken by it.

Even the increased role for Arwen revolves around the question of choice, for she must choose between the fate of elves and men (“I choose a mortal life”) – no simple decision when one way is that of immortality and a certain future while the other leads to death and the unknown. And Aragorn too must choose whether to accept so great a sacrifice and all that either decision will imply.

Whether one likes these changes or not, even whether Tolkien would have liked or approved of them, is another matter, but like them or loath them I don’t think that they stem from a misreading of Tolkien or that they are out of harmony with the themes at the heart of Tolkien’s work. Ultimately I think that the spirit of Tolkien's work remains essentially and intentionally intact in the film, no matter how much of a drubbing is occasionally meted out to the letter. For my part I hope that, whatever else may be the case, these themes continue to be worked out through TTT and brought to fruition in ROTK.
 
Wow- no need to apologize for that post. Top-notch stuff, Bjarki.

A detail question- are you sure Galadriel is not tested in the book as well? I've gone over this in another thread, with the following in favor of a 'prior rejection': On the other hand, we have the following two thoughts by Tolkien:
IMO these two quotes say that Galadriel's pardon was due to her refusal to take the Ring when it was offered to her. I suppose that we can reconcile these by saying that her refusal was founded on prior consideration but that the true test occured when the ring was in front of her. Anyway, just a detail question re. your (great) post.
 
I think this is very much a matter of interpretation. And I'm not sure how much prior resolve would help you when actually confronted by the reality of the Ring. It's one thing to theoretically contemplate what one might do if the Ring came within your grasp and quite another to be confronted by a 3'6" mortal with curly hair and no shoes offering to give it to you, no questions asked. I would imagine even Galadriel's prior resolve was tested when the Ring was only a few inches from her hand. But then it's those few inches and the choice not to cross them that make all the difference.
 
Galadriel makes this choice because she knows what it entails. It is not a choice between impotence and power or even between good and evil, but a choice between personhood and absorbtion. The person wielding the Ring does not become powerful, but in fact, is eventually absorbed by the Ring (the only exception is, of course, its Maker of whom the Ring is already a part). That's what Galadriel means when she says that she will "diminish and go into the West and remain Galadriel"! The "fair Queen" she shows to Frodo when she contemplates the consequences of possessing the Ring, is not Galadriel, but a nullity of that person. So, in other words, had Galadriel taken the Ring, Galadriel would have (eventually) ceased to exist and what would have remained would only have borne her outward appearance.

Throughout the book, Tolkien points out how evil limits and eventually destroys. The slit pupil of Sauron's "eye" is a "window into nothingness". The "Mouth of Sauron" no longer even has a name! Doubtless at one time, he did, but to gain the ultimate power available to him, he has been willing to become nothing more than an appendage of his evil Master.

In fact, the great "strength" of evil appears to be its unity in the face of the factions and petty feuds that are taking place among the free peoples of Middle-earth. But, in fact, what happens with evil is not that it becomes united, but that it is absorbed. It is like a black hole that swallows all that comes within its sphere until there is nothing left but a mark upon creation that once upon a time, something existed which no longer exists. Of course, the power is still there and like the immendse gravity of a black hole, it can continue to consume all who come under its sway. But in fact, all that truly exists is a void, a nullity, a nothing. That is why neither Morgoth nor Sauron can "create", only twist, wrench and debase. They themselves no longer exist as once they did. All that remains is their malice, hate and envy. Unfortunately, that is enough - at least in Sauron's case in LOTR - to continue to wreak havoc around him until that power is broken and he becomes in fact, the nothingness that he has been in truth.
 
Very well put. But perhaps in a sense even Sauron himself has become a slave of the Ring. Thinking himself its master, but in reality as much in thrall to nullity of its power as the meanest of his slaves.
 
Excellent post, Bjarki. Really well thought-out. With your permission, I would like to quote it on another forum I visit.

As I stated earlier, there are many different meanings in LotR, and I'm sure everyone holds different parts of the book to different standards. As for me, I agree with the themes you've outlined. There are others that I believe are important, but "free will" and "pity" are at the top. Indeed, that very exchange in Moria (in the film) is in my opinion really the heart of the whole tale, and was most certainly inteded to be so. If you listen to the writer commentary on the EE DVD you'll hear Fran or Phillipa acknowledging this. The quotes are from bag-end, but they hold a special place when put together at the heart of Moria. Indeed, only minutes before Gandalf falls.
 
That is true. We tend to think of evil as "someone" - Morgoth, Sauron, Satan etc. But, in fact, evil is an attitude, a "decision", a choosing to reject good. Someone may become evil or may act in an evil way, but, as Tolkien says, nothing is evil from the beginning! To have something evil at the outset would take away the moral foundation since that being could hardly be held responsible for his/her/its behavior! It would be like blaming a blind person for being unable to see!

Evil is, in fact, a choice and evil must come when there is free will since there will always be at least the opportunity to chose to reject good. Unfortunately, love and good are only possible with free will as well. Remember, the person who is "programmed" to be good is no more morally praiseworthy than the person who is "programmed" to be evil is blameworthy. Both would simply be acting in response to conditions outside of their control.

Doubtless, Sauron is a "prisoner" of his Ring because he is a "prisoner" of the evil he has chosen. The problem with chosing evil - especially for beings such as Sauron and Saruman rather than simple "people" is that the time comes when they can no longer "disengage" and be redeemed. They go too far to be able to "let go". This particular failing is beautifully illustrated in the book with the confrontation between Gandalf and Saruman when the latter is given the chance to reject his evil schemes, repent and become what he was supposed to be at the beginning, a servant of the forces of good in Middle-earth. The Wizard comes within just a hair's-breadth of humbling himself and acknowledging his wrongdoing...but in the end, he simply cannot do it and so is condemned to eventual destruction. (I wonder if that scene will happen in the film? If Jackson has in fact left it in, it would make up for many of his "revisions" since it is a very large part of the moral of the story!).

In his book, The Great Divorce, C. S. Lewis takes us on a journey with people from hell who get on a bus and go up a huge chasm until they reach the outskirts of heaven. It's a fabulous work and I would suggest that all read it. In any event, one of the people from hell who repents of what is "keeping him from heaven", asks the angel who has come to speak with him, why God's angels don't "storm hell and forcibly remove the souls entrapped there." Among the answers to his question, the angel takes the man and shows him a crack in the ground. This is where your bus came through on your way from hell to heaven, this "tiny crack" is the gateway to hell! In this, the author means that evil so constricts, limits and "absorbs" men, that even if God willed it, sometimes those afflicted become too "small" in their souls to be helped even by God Himself.
 
Originally posted by Talimon Excellent post, Bjarki. Really well thought-out.
AND
Originally posted by Aragil Top-notch stuff, Bjarki.

Couldn't agree more.

It led on from
"....the fundamental themes of book (there are three in particular), are they also fundamental themes of the film....?", and I have to say that, at this level of intellectual discussion, the idea of the film having fundamental themes at all seems almost grandiose. It does have that fine chunk of dialogue in Moria, but that clashes with the general feel of the film, which, seen with these postings in mind, has more of the tone of an adventure spectacular than of a deeply philosophical exploration of these great themes.
 
Yes, this is the root of the problem I think. I have asked many times, just what was Mr. Jackson's "vision" other than making a profitable and excellent film. And it seems to me that much of what he did (the changing (diminution) of the vital characters) argued against the book's main themes which required those characters to be what they were and not what they became.

Still, it is difficult to impart deep philosophical truths in a film, especially a so-called "action-adventure" film. A Beautiful Mind might have gotten away with it and there are other films which are fairly intimate and therefore permit lengthy dialogue and character interaction. The only films that I remember that had at least some action but permitted great character development were Godfather I & II.

But alas, in LOTR there is entirely too much going on for the film to take a great deal of time developing deep inner meanings and/or themes. That is why Jackson was so remiss spending time (or so much time) on unnecessary and uncalled for scenes when he should have been utilizing as much time as he could on character interaction. Those few moments which allowed Aragorn to impart to the hobbits the nature of the Nazgul; the few moments of introspective dialogue in Moria; Galadriel's moments alone with Frodo; these did more to convey the meaning of the story than all of the cinematic "eye candy" put together. However, sadly it wasn't enough and as well, from the responses of many younger viewers, these moments of relative serenity were entirely too much because they "interfered" with the "action". Unfortunately, the respondents were a large portion of the audience for whom Jackson made the films and had hopes of profiting thereby, so I have no doubt that his choices about what to include and what to discard were just under the circumstances.
 
Well MM, all I can say is that what is too little, just right, or too much is a completely subjective decision. PJ was treading on a tightrope- he was obligated to New Line to make a succesful film, and he was obligated (in some way) to make a good adaptation of the Lord of the Rings. Certainly a good adaptation and a succesful film can contain large portions of both action and character development, but the question becomes will too much of one detract from the other. The only true scale for evaluating this rests with each individual viewer. As far as I am concerned, PJ balanced both action and character develpment quite well (excellently even). Clearly you think that PJ emphasized the former to the detriment of the latter. However, now that Bjarki has given us a thematic frame to work in (wish I'd been clever enough to have done that), we might as well try to address specifics within that framework. I think that Bjarki has done a good job in showing how the film reflected the three themes of the book during the Moria scene. This of course was largely pertaining to Frodo, and (IMO) was nowhere near a comprehensive look at how the film treats these three themes with just F's character. Also, Aragorn got a quick mention for his choice, both in regards to his destiny as king and in his refusal of the ring. Again, I think that this could be developed a lot more, but Bjarki has certainly given a good starting point. You yourself have mentioned the PP scene where Aragorn relates the nothingness that the Nazgul have become. IMO we are starting to see that these three themes are fairly well-developed in the movies. I'd like to try and further show how these themes were treated in the character of Boromir. For me he was probably the highlight of the film. Intellectually I've always known what T was trying to do with this character in the books, but for some reason I never felt any connection (certainly no sympathy) for the steward's eldest son. However, for me the movie established that connection, and really for the first time in my LotR experience I truly felt what a loss it was when he died. Now, were any of Bjarki's 3 main themes conveyed through the portrayal of Boromir? I think so:

1)Good actions are in harmony with the world, evil actions are less so- Certainly we see that things go awry for Boromir when he commits an evil action. He attempts to take the Ring from the Hobbit, and ends up paying the ultimate price as a consequence. Perhaps his lowest moment comes when he proclaims "You go to your death, and the death of us all! Curse you! Curse all you halflings!" On the other hand, he meets his end in a manner of his own choosing, in an attempt to save the other Hobbits from the clutches of the Uruk-hai. This is a good action, one which is perhaps unsuccesful in saving the Hobbits, but one which is succesful (IMO) in saving Boromir himself. Perhaps (and this was always my take from the books) Boromir, great man though he was, was not strong enough to continue living without the Ring. Perhaps if he had survived the disaster at Parth Galen he would have pursued Frodo, and so brought ruin to all that he had sought to save. This is certainly the feeling I get from the movie. In this sense his good action of fighting to save the Hobbits might have had an (unintended) good consequence- Boromir was allowed to depart in peace, without causing additional suffering on those he loved. I almost hesitate to mention what effect this has on Strider, but it seems that in the film it is Boromir's Heroic death that helps Aragorn decide to return to his people. ~"Yes there is weakness, yes there is frailty in men, but there is also courage and much that is good". Boromir says this to Aragorn in the EE, and, judging by A's reply, Aragorn doesn't really take it to heart. "I wouldn't take the Ring within a hundred leagues of your city". However (this is in the film), after witnessing Boromir's death, Aragorn seemingly has a change of heart- he vows "I know not what strength lies in my blood, but I swear to you I will not let the White City fall, nor our people fail." Yes, our people. Because of the good action of Boromir, Aragorn recognizes in part that there is indeed strength along with the weakness in human nature, and so he decides to go to Minas Tirith and try to protect it. Remember, saving the White City was in part what motivated Boromir to try and take the Ring from Frodo. How appropriate then that his subsequent actions in trying to save the Hobbits will have the (again unintended) good result that Aragorn decides to save the White City.


2)Nothing is evil in the beginning- Piece of cake, because I don't think that Boromir ever becomes 'evil'. However, we do see him heading that way. Certainly his attempt to take the Ring by force from a Hobbit was no 'good act', even though his original intent (saving his city) might be considered good. As Boromir is not inherently evil, he is allowed a shot at redemption- I think we all agree that the film did a pretty good job at showing Boromir redeem himself. In fact, I have to admit that I choke back a tear every time I see Boromir charging up the hill to save the Hobbits, hopeless though he must know it to be. This brings us up to ...

3)Choices are a consequence of Free Will- certainly Boromir is a free spirit, and he makes good choices as well as bad. As I suggested before, perhaps the Ring had such power over Boromir that he was at the very limit of not being able to do any more good deeds, with the exception of his sacrifice on the part of the Hobbits. There are many scenes in the movie to suggest this sapping away of his will- from his first lines at the Council of Elrond through his near-handling of the Ring upon Caradhras, to his reactions when confronted by Galadriel. This heavy foreshadowing is neatly tied up when Boromir finally attacks Frodo- an act so out of character from the Noble Captain of Gondor that even Frodo says "You are not yourself". At this point the Ring is winning, and almost every ounce of free will Boromir has is gone. Almost, for he still has one choice to make- he can recant his curse upon the Hobbits and do his best to save them, even though this might mean the loss of his own life, and subsequently his own ability to ever again help his people. Not an easy choice, by any means, but in this last decision of his life Boromir makes the correct choice, and is in turn rewarded with the eventual saving of his city.

Well, that is all I'm prepared to post at this late hour. I dare say that the movie interweaves the good/evil choices of Boromir with his level of free will, and that all three themes are brought nicely together in his character at the end of the film. Of course, I picked the easy character, as his part his completely played out in the first film. However, I think these three themes were equally well expressed in the characters of Frodo, Gandalf, Aragorn, and Saruman as they appeared in the film, as Bjarki has already suggested.
 
Jackson is at his best and truest when he keeps the moral struggle between good and evil in the forefront. This would not have been necessary in a less cynical age, but we are in an age of moral relativism - nothing is absolute, there is no right or wrong, it only depends upon your circumstances, what's right for you might not necessarily be right for me and so on ad nauseum.

In the late cold war, there were many who posited that there was no essential moral difference between the West and the Communists (ask the 10 million Kulaks whom Stalin starved to death about that one!). Therefore, even though the "villains" in LOTR look villainous, it is always wise to put into words (dialogue) the continuing moral struggle. If that isn't done, the films could devolve into a very large and very expensive video game where the only difference between the two sides is the appearance of their forces.
 
To Bjarki

I am glad I read your comments on TTT. I didn't think of it in exactly those terms and now I have a different aspect of the film shown to me. I will see it again and try to leave the 'book' behind and see if I sense the 'spirit'.

Very well thought out comments, Bjarki.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…