• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Do all races in Middle Earth have the same opportunities as Men?

Arvedui

Stargazer
Joined
Aug 19, 2002
Messages
1,960
A topic taken from the Debating Tournament.
I'm not quite sure where this belongs, but for a start, I've put it here:

Is the race of Men in general treated fairly and had the same opportunities that other races had throughout the history of Middle Earth?

Enjoy:)
 
Last edited:
Men did not have the same opportunities as the other races. The other major race is the Elves, and the single biggest opportunity they got was an invitation to Aman. That is not to say that Men should have got this opportunity, it is just an example of one they did not get. Likewise, it seems the elves got no instruction direct from Iluvatar in their early days, as did the Men.

As for fair treatement, it depends who was doing the treating I guess. ;) But if you look outside of the history of Middle-earth, and to th way thay men are/were to become... I think it is obvious that Men treat Men most unfairly.

By other men, I would say yes, as least when compared to the treatment of other races by men.

By the Eldar, I would say often.

By dwarves? Yes.

By the Valar and Maiar? Hard to say. The Valar did care about men, and we are even told that they love men, but they appearantly work in mysterious ways. They did not take as much action for men. Could be they were not supposed to. But Men were aided in the WotJ and WotR by Aman.

As for treatement by Eru? Only God could say, I think. The very nature of the races is the most important part of this package I think, that and their fate. Who can say which race will have a superior fate?

By Morgoth? Well men were more fundamentally effected by evil since they fell to it as a race, but aside from that I think all races were treated with equal unfairness by evil. ;)
 
Care to emphisize on that?


I think they were treated fairly, although they had different opportunities than the Elves and Dwarves.
The Gift of Iluvatar never seemed to be acknowledged by the Atani (with good reason- since it wouldn't really appear as a gift at the time), but in a way, it was a gift. I can't remember the quote off hand, but one of the Elves spoke about the disadvantages of having to to forever- slowly stretching out their souls.
Perhaps more Men could have been given a longer life span, like what was done for the Numonoreans. But as you saw, they ended up being 'stretched' too much (although the proximity to Valinor could also be blamed for that).
If Men had been allowed to travel to Valinor, they would have forever lamenated about the fact that they were not immortal. It probably that it was for the best that they hung around on Middle Earth with other mortal beings.
 
I agree they were treated fairly... don't forget man was afraid for the valar. They did not understand them.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top