• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

🧝Elves at Helm's Deep weakened Rohan

Whaddya mean "ugly"? As in it's not a very clear post? As in you don't like the green background? Or as in you don't like my message? And is it just "Marry Anne on Gilligan's Island" ugly, or is it "Cornelius on Planet of the Apes" ugly (tv ugly or Ugly ugly)?
 
The elves of Lorien fight for the protection of their own lands. They don't travel 500 miles to help the Rohirrim with whom there was never a bond of alliance (such as with the Numenoreans).
Glorfindel and other individuals help the Men in their mission, because the feel that it is their duty. This doesn't apply to the general population of the elves who are no longer concerned with the events of ME and plan to leave it.
Elladan and Elrohir, have most probably chosen mortality by this time and fight with Men not as Elves.
The wars with the Witch-King were at a time where the Northern Kingdom was destructed and the homes of the elves were at danger. This war was not against the total evil and also the time of the high-elves on ME had not passed completely.
What I believe is that the High-Elves were not "meant" to fight with Men at the War of the Ring, except for particular "lesser" kingdoms that fought for their land only(Thranduil, Lorien). The elves would soon leave ME and if Men were ready to face the evils alone, they should be able to defeat Sauron alone. By putting some elves to fight with Rohan it destroys this idea. And PJ should have known better.

PS. Aragil, I don't object to people finding flaws to Tolkien's writings, as long as they try to explain their arguments (as you did). Of course, I don't agree, but I gladly debate them.
 
The argument that the Elves only fight in defence of their homes seems to be sort of selfish for the Elves. Of course, this is exactly what Elrond in the movie is thinking, until Galadriel (rightly) upbraids him. The Elves are partially responsible for Sauron's ascension to power, and for them to not help 'clean it up' is morally negligent on their part. I like to give Elrond more credit than that- (for god sakes Spock, you're half human). He had certainly benefited from the aid of the Numenoreans in the past- why not help them in their final struggle to overcome evil? It was an end of the Age of the Elves, but Sauron was still part of that age. Unless the Elves' moral compass was extremely skewed, they owed it to men to help out one last time. Selfishly-motivated isolationism was their only excuse in the books, and frankly I'm not sad to see it go in the movies.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…