• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Film Review: _Fellowship of the Ring_

maquino

New Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Messages
8
Film Review: _Fellowship of the Ring_
[from December 2001]

There are three groups of people who will be seeing _The
Lord of the Rings_ films: (1) Those, mostly post-Boomers,
who haven't read The Trilogy; (2) those, mostly Boomers, who
have read The Trilogy and possibly _The Hobbit_, but nothing
else in the mythos; and (3) JRRT fanatics who've read & reread
everything the Old Man wrote and most or all of what orbits
around it (Christopher T's followup books, Fonstad's _Atlas_,
etc., all the way to the Harvard Lampoon's _Bored of the Rings_).

Each one of these groups is going to react differently to _FOTR_
the 2001 film.

Group #1 is going to be bewildered, but adequately entertained by
three hours of swords & sorcery ending with an abrupt cliffhanger.
The movie will remain in their minds about as long as _Titanic_
or _The Phantom Menace_ did, i.e. give or take a couple of weeks.

Group #2 knows where the story's going, so the cliffhanger doesn't
fret them. They will be generally appreciative that someone
actually managed to make a movie out of The Trilogy that stands
on its own feet, which the Ralph Bakshi cartoon version didn't.

Group #3 is also appreciative of the movie, but will scrutinize it
like Manwe's Eagles for plot/character imperfections, upon which
they will pounce righteously, if somewhat incomprehensibly to
Groups #1 & #2, who will wonder why #3 is getting so anal
about such trivialities.

Thus art thou forewarned: This is a Group #3 review.

Before anything else I am desperately, frantically, gaspingly
grateful that this _LOTR_ is a New Zealand production and
not a United States one. Otherwise, American Postmodernism
being what it is, Tolkien's original story would be relentlessly
amended to punch all of our Politically Correct anti-racist,
anti-sexist, anti-elitist tickets.

And make no mistake about it: the story is 100%
Anglo-Saxon Noble Savagery, with fairytale-stereotype
roles for both boys & girls and an aristocratic undercurrent
so strong that if you aren't descended from heroic royalty
through several generations, you, well, ain't **** (Hobbits
excepted).

Besides, just imagine what we'd get as a cast if this were
an American movie: Frodo = Tom Cruise, Gandalf = George
C. Scott, Aragorn = Sylvester Stallone, Arwen = Sharon
Stone, Legolas = Jackie Chan, Gollum = Michael Jackson,
Saruman = Jack Nicholson, Elrond = Clint Eastwood, Tom
Bombadil = Jim Carrey, Boromir = Arnold Schwarzenegger,
Galadriel = Madonna, Gimli = Joe Pesci, Bilbo = Danny
DeVito, and the Balrog = Geraldo Rivera.

But the casting in this NZ film is not only fresh, but for the
most part warmfuzzyright. Everyone settles into the part
as though born to it; you never squirm in your chair
because the actor's own identity is getting in the way
of the character's. Even Christopher Lee as Saruman: I
had misgivings about this - Are we going to get Dracula
flashbacks? But Lee serves us a superb Saruman, with
just the right blend of menace & twinkle, which comes
easily with his years of screenvillainous experience.

Aragorn is another matter. He's scruffy. Yes, I know that
he, as Strider the Ranger, is supposed to be weatherbeaten,
and that it isn't until _Return of the King_ that he gets a
shave, a shower, and fancy duds as King Elessar. But, look
as hard as I might, in this _FOTR_ I just don't see a mystical
Numenorean king peering out from under the Hell's Angel.
Indeed I suspect that, having all of the Elves blond-haired
& blue-eyed, Director Peter Jackson didn't want his Aragorn
tipping the whole canoe over into Arno Breker Aryan
Uebermensch, so sifted in enough Davy Crockett to safely
de-Siegfried him.

Frodo is a tough role to cast, as he's been so strongly
portrayed for so many years not only in JRRT's original
stories, but also in a flood of book illustrations & Tolkien
calendar art, not to mention the Bakshi cartoon _LOTR_.
Elijah Wood's Frodo is probably good enough to get past
most Group #3 geeks, though I personally see Frodo as
a somewhat tougher, more mature Hobbit. Wood plays
the character rather like Walt Disney's Bambi, with
expressions ranging from startled wonder to stark
terror (granted that he has plenty of grounds for both).

G#3 pundits will, however, spotlight two glaring changes
from the book: the absence of Tom Bombadil [probably
due to sheer running-time constraints] and the revision
of Arwen from Tolkien's ultimate Pedestal Sweetheart to
an action heroine - which is probably Jackson's towelthrow
to contemporary militant feminism. One commercial
movie critic, praising the Liberated Arwen, dismisses
Tolkien's book as a "he-man, woman-hating" anachronism.
(_San Francisco Chronicle_ 12/24/01).

Jackson and the _Chronicle_ needn't have worried,
because in _The Two Towers_ & _Return of the King_
we will be introduced to the Lady Eowyn of Rohan,
Tolkien's answer to Lara Croft, who kicks serious ass
right up to her slaying of the King Ringwraith himself.
But those movies are for later, and _Fellowship_ has
to pass the test right now, I guess.

The Elves you'll see in this film, in addition to being
Lebensborn-posterkids, are so pure, noble, and
supernaturally imposing that not only the humans
in the movie but the ones in the theater look and feel
like armpit-scratching Neanderthals by comparison.

To console yourself, just go out and buy a copy of JRRT's
_Silmarillion_, which recounts the history of Middle-earth
before LOTRtime, when Elves were the dominant species.
Turns out they mistrusted, disobeyed, and betrayed the
benevolent Valar (=archangels) who had created a
protected Earthly paradise for them, flirted with the
Vala Melkor (=Satan), stole from/betrayed/slaughtered
one another, and generally behaved so badly that by
the time of _LOTR_ there were only a few of them still
left alive.

Even Galadriel, squeaky-saintly in this movie, began
in the _Silmarillion_ as a calculating opportunist who
rejected her father Finarfin and the Valar in order to
carve out a Middle-earth domain of her own to rule.
She managed to dodge centuries of Elf/Elf and Elf/Orc
carnage to be on hand for Frodo & company, by which
time she could have mellowed out somewhat, I suppose.

As I've observed previously, _LOTR_ is a morality tale
selling the message that "Evil can only be destroyed by
greater Evil, or by accident". A secondary theme is that
if you leave something really dangerous lying around
long enough, somebody will ultimately find it and use it.
The Hobbits lucked out and got rid of the One Ring just
in time. [Humans today are not so fortunate: Since 1945
we've been sitting on thousands of thermonuclear bombs,
just waiting for some lunatic to finally set one or more
off. Sadly there is no volcano into which we can just
toss the technology, even if we had the resolve to do so.]

Of course, as philosophers from Petronius to de Sade to
Anton LaVey have realized, Evil is also more interesting,
stimulating, and exciting than Good, moving those
both within & without it to unusual feats of ingenuity,
creativity, and heroism. Thus Tolkien's First Age of Arda
(=Earth) saw the contests between the Valar/Elves and
Melkor/Orcs. The Second Age saw the contests between
the Men of Numenor (=Atlantis) and first Sauron/Orcs,
then the Valar. The Third Age saw the Men and other
remaining races in Middle-earth unite again against
Sauron. This all made for pretty exciting reading, and
is now giving us three adrenalin-jolt movies.

The Fourth, or Dull, Age began after Sauron was
snuffed and Aragorn/Elessar united all of Middle-earth
in a peaceful kingdom in which everyone cooperated
with one another, beat swords into plowshares, and
paid taxes. J.R.R. Tolkien didn't write a book about it,
and somehow I don't think we'll get a movie about it
either.

Michael A. Aquino

_The Morlindale"_
http://www.xeper.org/maquino/nm/Morlindale.pdf
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top