• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

How is 🧙Gandalf serving as a Steward?

In what way, and for whom, is Gandalf serving as a Steward?

'Unless the king should come again?’ said Gandalf. ‘Well, my lord Steward, it is your task to keep some kingdom still against that event, which few now look to see. In that task you shall have all the aid that you are pleased to ask for. But I will say this: the rule of no realm is mine, neither of Gondor nor any other, great or small. But all worthy things that are in peril as the world now stands, those are my care. And for my part, I shall not wholly fail of my task, though Gondor should perish, if anything passes through this night that can still grow fair or bear fruit and flower again in days to come. For I also am a steward. Did you not know?’ And with that he turned and strode from the hall with Pippin running at his side. (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Lord of the Rings: One Volume (p. 758). HMH Books. Kindle Edition. Gandalf speaking to Denethor II.)

Given all we know about Stewards, and that Gandalf is playing directly off Denethor II's comment that he was serving as "Steward" (one ruling over a kingdom in absence of the King), how do we see Gandalf's Stewardship, and for whom?

There are clues within the paragraph itself... but I am curious as to what other discussions have been held about it, and have difficulty finding any.
Perhaps it's just so obvious it doesn't need any chatter?!

It is interesting to me too, that it's the 'white wand' that designates the Stewards... and we see Saruman the White as the chief Istari, then Gandalf the White.
There is most likely a connection here as well.
To sum up everything in the thread, I think the most important thing to note here is capitalization.

Denethor is a Steward (capitalized), because that is a specific position: akin to that of a King, a ruler of the realm that had been entrusted to his care until the King returns, and in presence of the King, his right hand.

Gandalf is a steward (lower-case) because that is a concept: he is caretaker of the world, or rather everything good in it, and is the enemy of evil (Sauron) no matter where it may act.

Both positions have something in common: taking care or stewarding of good that is left in this world. So while the manner of their actions is different, owing to different nature of their positions, fundamental goal shared by both Gandalf and Denethor is the same: preservation of whatever good is left in this world.

So Gandalf is, in the same stroke, showing both similarity and difference of their positions: reminding Denethor that as important as Denethor may see his own position as a Steward, Gandalf too is in a fundamentally same position and with similar task, but one that far overshadows Denethor's own task and responsibility.

It is basically Gandalf saying "stop being a self-centered donkey, not everything is about you and Gondor".
 
To sum up everything in the thread, I think the most important thing to note here is capitalization.

Denethor is a Steward (capitalized), because that is a specific position: akin to that of a King, a ruler of the realm that had been entrusted to his care until the King returns, and in presence of the King, his right hand.

Gandalf is a steward (lower-case) because that is a concept: he is caretaker of the world, or rather everything good in it, and is the enemy of evil (Sauron) no matter where it may act.

Both positions have something in common: taking care or stewarding of good that is left in this world. So while the manner of their actions is different, owing to different nature of their positions, fundamental goal shared by both Gandalf and Denethor is the same: preservation of whatever good is left in this world.

So Gandalf is, in the same stroke, showing both similarity and difference of their positions: reminding Denethor that as important as Denethor may see his own position as a Steward, Gandalf too is in a fundamentally same position and with similar task, but one that far overshadows Denethor's own task and responsibility.

It is basically Gandalf saying "stop being a self-centered donkey, not everything is about you and Gondor".
I agree with this! Thank you for stating.
 
To sum up everything in the thread, I think the most important thing to note here is capitalization.

Denethor is a Steward (capitalized), because that is a specific position: akin to that of a King, a ruler of the realm that had been entrusted to his care until the King returns, and in presence of the King, his right hand.

Gandalf is a steward (lower-case) because that is a concept: he is caretaker of the world, or rather everything good in it, and is the enemy of evil (Sauron) no matter where it may act.

Both positions have something in common: taking care or stewarding of good that is left in this world. So while the manner of their actions is different, owing to different nature of their positions, fundamental goal shared by both Gandalf and Denethor is the same: preservation of whatever good is left in this world.

So Gandalf is, in the same stroke, showing both similarity and difference of their positions: reminding Denethor that as important as Denethor may see his own position as a Steward, Gandalf too is in a fundamentally same position and with similar task, but one that far overshadows Denethor's own task and responsibility.

It is basically Gandalf saying "stop being a self-centered donkey, not everything is about you and Gondor".

Well summarized... and very similar will be finding its way into my little 'essay'.
 
BTW -- when you've completed it, here's a place to post:


Terrific, (in today's meaning of the word, not it's original).
It looks like Forum Folks can review, comment and help adjust/correct/improve on it there for further refinement.
I hope to have it drafted and a bit refined soon.
(I just need to figure out how to prevent being distracted by other hobbit holes I want to poke into for quick rudimentary research on along the way..!!)
 
Well, I believe all the necessary research and preparation are now done.

I am thrilled to say in the course of my further collection, I have also discovered that J.R.R.T. had an absolutely correct understanding of the Hebrew מַלְאָךְ - malak - "messenger, emissary" and Greek ἄγγελος - ággelos - "messenger, emissary", as we should expect. (Note: Greek ággelos is called by many "angelos" instead. ἄγγελος is also printed specifically at one point, describing his view of the Wizards' roles.)

Not the 'angel" (derivative of the Greek transliteration 'angelos') with fluttering or feathered wings, and assigned to protective missions we humans have straddled them with in spite of all Scriptural evidence to the contrary. (Angels do NOT have wings. Those are only spoken of with relation to other heavenly created beings. Nor are they assigned as 'protective servants of humankind', one or a dozen or so assigned to each individual as their very own 'heavenly' or 'guardian angel'.) They were, are, and will always be "messengers, emissaries" sent with particular "messages" and "missions"

Anyway, soon "THE STEWARDSHIP OF GANDALF" will be done, and I'll figure out HOW to match it to the WHERE Squint-eyed Southerner has so graciously provided.

(NOTE: "soon" is purposely nebulous as there are many dependencies.)
 
Last edited:
In what way, and for whom, is Gandalf serving as a Steward?

(Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Lord of the Rings: One Volume (p. 758). HMH Books. Kindle Edition. Gandalf speaking to Denethor II.)

Given all we know about Stewards, and that Gandalf is playing directly off Denethor II's comment that he was serving as "Steward" (one ruling over a kingdom in absence of the King), how do we see Gandalf's Stewardship, and for whom?

There are clues within the paragraph itself... but I am curious as to what other discussions have been held about it, and have difficulty finding any.
Perhaps it's just so obvious it doesn't need any chatter?!

It is interesting to me too, that it's the 'white wand' that designates the Stewards... and we see Saruman the White as the chief Istari, then Gandalf the White.
There is most likely a connection here as well.
Ah, this is one of those favorite snatches of dialogue of mine from the entire novel! It would have been so satisfying to see this exchange acted out in the film, but I digress...

Yes, to me it is clear that the use of the term steward is not limited to a person who rules a realm on behalf of a missing sovereign as Denethor is doing, but also includes guiding, caring for, assisting, teaching, inspiring, and a whole host of ways to support a land, or a people in flourishing and thriving. In the broadest sense, anyone can be a steward by stepping up to the task in recognition of one's own access to values, wisdom, and spiritual guidance. A person could become a steward of a portion of land, or of a community, for instance, simply by being linked to that land and community in an intimate way and caring for it with an invested heart.

In Gandalf's case, his stewardship is more formal, as Denethor is, since he was sent by the Valar. He only alludes to this in the dialogue, but presumably Denethor has enough lore to be aware, at least generally speaking, of who Gandalf is and what he's doing in Middle-Earth. Gandalf here is trying to remind Denethor of that, and rebuke him somewhat, for forgetting what Stewardship is all about. In a sense, its appropriate for Denethor to be thinking about Gondor above all else, given his position as the Steward. But he has grown proud, and is very resistant to the idea of returning the scepter to the king when he comes, indicating that he is not really ruling in the spirit of stewardship, but in the spirit of servicing his own lordship.

Likewise, if Denethor is ruling as a steward on behalf of the missing king, his duty is to rule in service of what a good king would be in service to as well. The king is looking after the wellbeing of the kingdom and the people in it, but in service of what? Not in service of the kingdom for the sake of the kingdom, nor of the kingdom for the sake of the king's aggrandizement. The proper role for all kings is to be ruling as stewards for Manwe, who in turn, is also ultimately just a steward on behalf of Iluvatar.

All of these relationships of earthly power, the ethics of rule, pride, and the primacy of spiritual service are all captured in Gandalf's exchange about stewardship, which is part of why I love this exchange so dearly! Also, that last withering line: "Did you not know?" has all these different layers of possible meaning. Gandalf could be saying, "Seriously, you should really know this stuff, and I thought you did know it. But you're acting like you don't know it, so maybe you don't? In that case, listen up, and learn it!" Or he could be saying, "I know that you really know this. You're acting like you don't, but I know deep down that you do. So I'm kind of making a joke here, asking 'Did you not know?' as if you didn't actually know such things. But we both know that's absurd, and that you really do know what a steward is or should be, and you know who I am and who you are. You also know how important it is to get this stuff right, so snap out of your pride loop!" Or he could be saying, "I thought you knew this stuff, but you're acting like you don't, so please, tell me if you don't. I'm curious! It would help me a lot to learn from you where your level of understanding is here." Or it could be a rhetorical flourish mic drop line to leave Denethor with in the hopes that it will provoke some thought and contemplation on Denethor's part. Or likely all of these things at once.

Anyway, like I said, I love this exchange.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top