• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

joxy said:
as many members of the range of "norms" as there are members of the range of Gimli jokes.

How much range can fit in the "terrible" category?

Joxy, you seem pretty open-minded! I can't believe you're so against tattoos!
 

And there's nothing that beats a good old fasioned: "My god, it was horrible."

It is interesting to speculate what would have occured to the LotR "trilogy" had a movie like Braveheart or Gladiator been released at the same or similar time. Would LotR have seemed any different from films like those?

Or put another way, what moves you more about the LotR movies: seeing the book (occasionally) come to life in motion and color or the manner in which Jackson chose to tell and visualize the story?
 
joxy said:
So now your ill-mannered statement depends on emphasising a three letter word, "any".
joxy,

Your absurd statement specified no particular "norm" that your were referring to. It said, in its entirety: If you wished your statement to apply to a specific norm you should have stated this rather than making a sweeping statement about all "norms".


joxy said:
Obviously, if there are to be a whole range of different norms, then some of them may be subject to establishment by evidence, and I should have omitted the word "any".
Yes, you should have omitted it.


joxy said:
However, I have not been talking about that range of norms.
One of that range could indeed be the norm of prize-winners, which I specifically excluded, though you choose to give it another three lines, of "evidence".
You did not "specifically" exclude anything. Your entire quote is given above.


joxy said:
Another could be the income, the "gross" as I've seen it called, but again that was not the one I was referring to, ....
How was anyone to know; you said "any norm".


joxy said:
and it is also not one that fits a normal definition of the word "norm".
Please explain how any "normal definition of the word "norm" " automatically excludes the possibility of the "norm" of box office gross for films. Make sure you include the specific dictionary defintion you are referring to and which dictionary it came from.


joxy said:
Then Aragil has given us as members of the range "critics' reviews" and "IMDb rankings". Again I don't see these fitting in with a conventional definition of "norm",
As above, I await a "conventional defintion of norm".


joxy said:
I saw the norm first and accepted it, not the other way around.
What norm?


joxy said:
I'm talking about the "Hollywood norm" that corresponds to the "Italian norm", the "French norm", even the "Bollywood norm".
I don't know what any of these norms refer to. I assume "Italian norm" or "French norm" or "Bollywood norm" refers to something more than the language the films are performed in.


joxy said:
Those are concepts that are known world-wide, and don't need me or anyone else to define them, or to provide "evidence" for the extent to which any film in any of them is superior, equal, or inferior, to them.
Congratulations! You have made a statement that rivals your earlier one in absurdity! Actually "concepts that are known world-wide" in reference to "French norm" or "Italian norm" or "Bollywood norm" is probably even more absurd than your earlier statement.


Again, what norm are you referring to other than your own personal views.
 
My sources:
Box Office Mojo has all the information you could ever want on box office figures- domestic, "overseas", and even adjusted for inflation (though in a rather suspect way).
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is a good site for figuring out who won which Oscar in which year.
Rotten Tomatoes compiles lists from every accredited movie critic in the US and Canada.
Finally, IMDb, the site which I personally find the most informative, is a database of every movie in every language in history. Any person from any country with internet access can become a member (for free) and then register their comments, along with a ranking on a scale from 1-10, for each of these movies.

Just to take simbelmyne through a quick tour, here are the top 5 grossing domestic (i.e. US) of all times in a single release, along with their $ grosses:
Titanic: $600,000,000
Star Wars Ep. 1, The Phantom Menace: $430,000,000
Spiderman: $403,000,000
Return of the King: $380,000,000 (extrapolated by me from current $375,000,000)
The Passion of the Christ: $415,000,000 (somewhat wildly extrapolated by me from current $335,000,000- this could still go over $450,000,000 IMO)

Now, here's how each of these 5 did in my other 3 'independent' measures of quality:

Oscars (# awarded/# nominated):
Titanic: 11/13
SWep1: 0/3
Spiderman: 0/2
RotK: 11/11
Passion: n/a

Critics awards- percentage of critics recommending the movie/# of critics reviewing the movie (average critical review is 53%, minimum of 50 reviewers):
Titanic: 88%/73 reviewers
SWEp1: 63%/143 reviewers
Spiderman: 89%/194 reviewers
RotK: 96%/208 reviewers
Passion: 51%/218 reviewers

IMDb rankings- score on a scale of 1-10/number of votes (average score across all movies on IMDb- 6.9, minimum number of votes 1,250)
Titanic: 6.9/76,000 votes
SWEp1: 6.5/69,521 votes
Spiderman: 7.4/46,300 votes
RotK: 8.9/57,631 votes
Passion: 7.5/ 18,089 votes

First of all, while I agree with simbelmyne that these movies can have some good reviews from critics, and some bad reviews by critics, I find Rotten Tomatoes to be compelling because it is averaging across a large pool of critics- the old, "you can't fool everyone all the time" argument. Secondly, Rotten tomatoes further breaks down it's ranking to the "creme of the crop", meaning the critics in the most widely read/distributed papers in the US and Canada. For that select group, the rankings are as follows (again an average ranking is 53%):
Titanic: 68%/19 reviewers
SWEp1: 40%/44 reviewers
Spiderman: 87%/32 reviewers
RotK: 97%/37 reviewers
Passion: 36%/ 41 reviewers
In this case Titanic barely exceeds the norm, while it only matches the norm on IMDb. Clearly, it is possible to rank very highly by some of these measures (SWEp1 in Box Office), while ranking abysmally in others (SWEp1 on the IMDb charts). What is remarkable to me is the consistency for RotK- besides Box Office (the measure most disagreeable to Purists), RotK outperforms the other four movies in every category (with the possible exception of Passion in Oscars). To me that is impressive, although I still respect anyone's opinion that they don't personally like RotK (unless they also admit to loving Titanic). However, at least to my scientific mind, "exceeding the norm" should not be a subjective measure, as norm usually implies some sort of objective measure pooled across seperate trials. For that kind of norm, there are objective measures, and I have provided 4 which clearly indicate that RotK "exceeds the norm". Doubtless there are other objective measures, and once again, I don't recommend anyone letting objective measures sway their subjective opinions on anything such as appreciation of a movie.
 
aragil said:
However, at least to my scientific mind, "exceeding the norm" should not be a subjective measure, as norm usually implies some sort of objective measure pooled across seperate trials.

These are not controlled trials. They are essentially meta-analyses of polling data (without the statistical support of an actual meta-analysis.
 
Greenwood, I have to congratulate you on your remarkable ability to make a substantial meal out of the tiny selection of ingredients I presented you with: the three letters A N Y.
I've already withdrawn the word "any", ANYway, so I'll have to pass the menu on.
You say: "You did not "specifically" exclude anything". I specifically excluded awards, in posting #772, which was an extension of posting #762 from which you quoted.

We're obviously inhabiting two different worlds, so we're never going to be speaking the same language.
Your world doesn't have the expression "Hollywood norm" appearing in its press, on its television, in its books, in its general conversation, referring to a standard of quality and content with which new films can be compared; mine does.
I'm not saying that the actual expressions, French, Italian, Bollywood, norms, are actually in as common usage in my world as their Hollywood equivalent, but I do claim that they express perfectly familiar concepts. People generally can look at a film, and rate it according to its norm - the norm out of the range of norms, which is the most commonly understood norm.

Aragil, I can see that your scientific mind is good at obtaining and comparing statistics, but I have a scientific mind too and it tells me to beware statistics, and also to check my definitions!

RS points out the technicalities of relying on the type of statistics that you present. I say, switching over to my non-scientific common-sense mind, that those statistics prove nothing about the subject of this discussion.
You suggest that "norm usually implies some sort of objective measure". "Usually" and "implies" are fair qualifiers, but I suggest that the generally accepted use of the term, specifically in the phrase "Hollywood norm", precludes any idea of "measure" at all.
 
Last edited:
simbelmyne said:
Joxy, you seem pretty open-minded! I can't believe you're so against tattoos!
Thanks for that simbelmyne, and sorry, if you're in favour of them!
I actually quite like to see them, and if they were easy to remove I might just like them anyway, but I KNOW that many people who have them regret their permanence; plastic surgeons make a living from removing them.
The human form is so attractive anyway, that any addition to it is superflous and ultimately either comical or tragic.
 
rs691919 said:
These are not controlled trials. They are essentially meta-analyses of polling data (without the statistical support of an actual meta-analysis.
Your point being?
 
Rrrrrr!! Not to harp too much on a memory, but you HAVE heard of "IMDb"! In this thread you asked of me "Who are these "general audience members" who have actually been asked the question, in such gigantic numbers?
Rankings and box-office statistics say nothing to me, but again, where are all these "poll statistics", which give the overwhelming results?", you did so in this post. I replied (in this post) that it was To this you amicably replied (here) that "That certainly answers my question as to where all the statistics appeared, and yes, 100,000 is quite a large sample, even of the many millions who have seen the films. Those statistics with rankings 1-10 sound the most interesting and I'll check them all out."
OK, so in spite of the fact that you have seen it and said that it looked interesting and that you'd check it out, maybe you have forgotten. But I mentioned it again, specifically in addressing you here- and you were the first to reply to my message! This is extremely frustrating for someone- when they go through the trouble of linking and discussing an entire web-entity, you discuss it, but then the next time it is brought up in a post you claim you've never heard of it. Perhaps you have a really bad memory or something, I don't know- but please at least try to remember what other people tell you, otherwise further discussion with you seems rather pointless.
 
aragil said:
Your point being?

That all the statistics you cite are in the realm of pseudoscience--or observation if you prefer. The four guages which you utilize to determine the "impressive" achievement of RotK (not, it should be emphasized, FotR or TTT) are co-dependent and interrelated.

If you wished, for instance, to design a trial to determine what critics really felt about this movie, you would need two arms, or cohorts. The first cohort would be allowed access to the full range of marketing and publicity; they would have knowledge of the box office number, any awards the movie had recieved or been nominated for; they would be able to read the reviews of OTHER critics.

The second cohort would be blinded to all that. To add a layer of control, you could have this second group watch only Oscar-winning films and box office hits in the days leading up to watching RotK. Then, after watching RotK, they would have to write their reviews.

Compare the two groups and analyze the differences in reviews. Still, the simplicity of this trial and the inherent qualitative nature of reviews would call into question the results.

So you return once again to psuedoscience and observation. And the statistics and measures you emphasize are ultimately meaningless as a measure of the movies.
 
You objected to my finding your original statement absurd, yet now you make a major point about withdrawing the very part of the statement that made it so absurd. I take the withdrawal as an acknowdgement of the absurdity of the original statement.

joxy said:
You say: "You did not "specifically" exclude anything". I specifically excluded awards, in posting #772, which was an extension of posting #762 from which you quoted.
So, you made the exclusion ten posts after your original statement. Once again an admission that my statement was correct and yours was at best poorly worded, at worst outright wrong. It speaks well of a person when they can admit to making an error, and you have now admitted to two. I salute you. Now, if we could only do something about your faulty memory.
 
Hey thanks, Aragil-this info is very interesting.
Although I don't see these statistics making much of a case for ROTK, even if it consistantly slightly outperforms these other movies-because each ranking has to put in context.

First off, it is edged out of the box office draw and oscar nods by...Titanic, which so far we all seem to agree is a bad movie. So how do box office draw and the oscars definatively show "exceeding the norm" or shine the light on quality? Unless the boat movie is of higher quality than ROTK.

Next you sight IMBd, where viewers from around the world rate movies (?)that show the boat movie edged out by the likes of Spiderman...which is several points behind ROTK. Spiderman? The type of viewers who found that movie a feat of cinematic genius are exactly the ones I imagine take the time to go online and rate movies. Most of us can't be bothered. If only 40% of Americans bother to vote for the President, what percentage of people who have seen ROTK actually go online to rate it? Especially those who weren't particularly impressed?

And, although I enjoy Rotton Tomatoes as well, I don't put TOO much stock in some of their reviews. The "critics" at USA Today and CNN aren't exactly going to pick out the classics of tomorrow. SOME of the reviews are thoughtful, some are not. Of all the statistics you've shown, this one seems the strongest, but I don't think it's much to hang your hat on, so to speak.
 
aragil said:
Not to harp too much on a memory, but you HAVE heard of "IMDb"! I mentioned it again, specifically in addressing you here - and you were the first to reply to my message!....Perhaps you have a really bad memory or something.
No, I haven't heard of it, and I've scarcely seen it. Your first mention of it was a part of a URL, which I clicked on and checked.
I certainly didn't file away the URL in my memory and the relevant four letters of it didn't register with me automatically. The second reference is to a very long posting which is not specifically addressed to anyone, and to which the first response was from jallan, not from me. In my response, after jallan's, I did hazard a guess that the posting had been adressed to me, but I don't recall you ever confirming that. When reading that long posting three months ago I'm sure I read the important details from you with great care, but the actual four letters are of no importance in themselves and again I did not file them away in my memory. Having some control over one's memory is a very useful faculty, one which anyone with a busy fact-filled life would do well to cultivate. I have a good memory, one which retains useful and relevant information, not a bad one which fills up with junk.
 
Greenwood said:
....So, you made the exclusion ten posts after your original statement. Once again an admission that my statement was correct and yours was at best poorly worded, at worst outright wrong.

....if we could only do something about your faulty memory.
I did not claim in my post #779 that I had made the exclusion in post #762 - nothing poorly worded, or wrong, about that - no admission involved.

See comment to Aragil.
 
joxy said:
I did not claim in my post #779 that I had made the exclusion in post #762 - nothing poorly worded, or wrong, about that - no admission involved.
I never said anything like the above. Your post which we have been discussing was: First please note that this was post # 759 on this thread, not # 762 as you have said. (Post #762 was by aragil.) Later in post # 786 on this thread you said:
joxy said:
I specifically excluded awards, in posting #772, which was an extension of posting #762 from which you quoted.
Thus, you are revising what you said in post # 759 (in post # 772) and are pointing out in post # 786 that you made the revision. If your original post was not poorly worded or wrong why did you find the need to revise it thirteen posts later and then call attention to the revision another fourteen posts after that? It appears to me that your memory is so faulty you can't even remember what you said when you have it in front of you.
 
Now we've gone from a set of three letters to various sets of three digits!
When I wrote about my #762 and #772, the former certainly was numbered 762; I noted that it was just 10 before the second. Now the first one is indeed numbered #759.
Allowing for oddities like that, it would help if you quoted post numbers too!
I thought, when you wrote of my post that was "at best poorly worded, at worst outright wrong", that you were referring to my post #772; you were actually referring to #759.
As I've already said, and as you've kindly acknowledged, I withdraw the one word "any" from post #759, because it could be taken to include norms which refer to quantitative matters. At the time I wrote it, I did not believe such matters were within the scope of the word; you have told me that they are so included, and I accept your claim. My use of the offending word was due to incomplete understanding, not to "poor wording", or to being "outright wrong".
Memory doesn't come into the matter.
 
joxy said:
When I wrote about my #762 and #772, the former certainly was numbered 762; I noted that it was just 10 before the second. Now the first one is indeed numbered #759.
Are you suggesting a moderator (no one else would have the capability) edited the thread to move your post back by three while leaving the subsequent posts with the same post numbers? Paranoia combined with a faulty memory would indeed be an unfortunate combination.


It never occurred to me that I needed to list post numbers since I directly quoted your statement FOUR (4) times (complete sentence in post #'s 763, 773 and 783, as well as a sentence extract in post # 777). Additionally you quoted the sentence yourself in post # 772 and Gandalf the Grey posted it in post # 774. Your statements are going from the absurd to the down right bizarre.
 
Absurd to begin with! Bizarre now! What next!

I had hoped that my feeble attempts at humour might rub off on to you, but it seems you are impervious to a soh.

I wasn't suggesting anything about the change in that post number. I have very little idea of how it could have happened,
and I have no interest in how it happened. However, it happened.

You, and I, and everyone else, make a lot of statements.
Your reference to one of my statements being "poorly worded, at worst outright wrong" came immediately after you had referred to two of my statements. I wrongly assumed that that it referred to the second of those statements of mine; and I now accept what you tell me: that it referred to the first statement.

And, to recapitulate: My use of the offending word was due to incomplete understanding, not to "poor wording", or to being "outright wrong".

I shall now polish my soh, put it away in a drawer, and leave it there until further notice.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…