Greenwood said:
It continues to be one of the most absurd statements I have seen on TTF.
So now your ill-mannered statement depends on emphasising a three letter word, "
any".
Obviously, if there are to be a whole range of different norms, then some of them may be subject to establishment by evidence, and I should have omitted the word "any". However, I have
not been talking about that
range of norms.
One of that range could indeed be the norm of prize-winners, which I specifically excluded, though you choose to give it another three lines, of "evidence".
Another could be the income, the "gross" as I've seen it called, but again that was not
the one I was referring to,
and it is also not one that fits a normal definition of the word "norm".
Then Aragil has given us as members of the range "critics' reviews" and "IMDb rankings". Again I don't see these fitting in with a conventional definition of "norm", but I have often said how much value I attach to reviews, and I've never heard of "IMDb"!
You insist also on these references to this being something personal to me. Again I have specifically said that is not the case.
I saw the norm first and accepted it, not the other way around.
I'm talking about the "Hollywood norm" that corresponds to the "Italian norm", the "French norm", even the "Bollywood norm".
Those are
concepts that are known world-wide, and don't need me or anyone else to define them, or to provide "evidence"
for the extent to which any film in any of them is superior, equal, or inferior, to them.
As this has turned into an attempt to define the word "norm", rather than to attempt to decide PJ's place in relation to whatever "norm" is chosen from the range, it's almost too late for me to give my "ranking", but I'll do it anyway!
Against the norm that I have referred to consistently I place them - for what it's worth, probably nothing, to certain people -
for the most part on a level with the norm, with occasional outbursts of brilliance that raise them well above it, and with more but briefer spluttering squibs that drag them down below it.
As always, they're a mixed bag, a <what
was that expression about a cleric's breakfast?!>