• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

aragil said:
Wait a minute joxy, if a norm can be objectively quantified....
Afraid I waited only half a minute to answer that one!
"If", "objectively", and "quantified": those are mighty obstacles to get over!
Rate the norm of beauty of sculpture, then quantify the "David" and the "Kiss" against that norm - and give your evidence for the rating.
Norms in matters of personal, objective, opinion cannot be defined, cannot be quantified, in terms which any form of "evidence" could confirm.
It should be possible from wide experience to know instinctively what the norm of Hollywood films is, but no amount of "evidence" will ever define it, or help to compare a particular film with it.
My instinct, based on less than wide experience, is that the FOTR films beat the norm in some respects and lag behind it in others - as always, they're one big curate's egg. :D
 
I would go so far as to say that there has never been a single thing on the planet that everybody was pleased with in its entirety. Everything is a curate's egg, so remarking to the fact is, well, a little obvious. "Better than eggspected" is somewhat more tangible and surprising. And this is what I think Greenwood and rs691919 are discussing with the "Hollywood norm".

In any case, on the subject of eggs, saying it is "good in parts" is hardly instructive. Do you find that the good parts outweigh the bad, that the two elements are in careful balance, or that the bad parts are in excess? I could hazard a guess towards rs691919's response, but your opinion seems more mottled.
 
joxy said:
Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
This is one of the most absurd statements I have ever seen on this Forum. If you want to say something meets what you consider the norm, that is fine because it is clearly subjective. If you just refer to a norm without making it clear you are defining the norm yourself you have left the realm of subjectivity. It is not necessary for me to define "Hollywood norm", all I need do is point to the many awards that are given out each year in and outside the movie industry for what the presenters consider the year's best and show that these films were nominated for many of these awards. The nominations alone, never mind all the awards actually won, show that the presenters of these awards consider these films above the norm. More objectively, I have no idea what the average gross (the "norm") of all Hollywood films released in a given year is, but since the first two films in the LOTR trilogy each came in second for the year of their release and ROTK came in first, they all clearly left the "norm" far behind.
 
Greenwood said:
This is one of the most absurd statements I have ever seen on this Forum.

It is not necessary for me to define "Hollywood norm", all I need do is point to the many awards....
I have no idea what the average gross (the "norm") of all Hollywood films released in a given year is, but since the first two films in the LOTR trilogy each came in second for the year of their release and ROTK came in first, they all clearly left the "norm" far behind.
I noted recently with pleasure that you had borrowed a sense of humour, and hoped that you would be allowed to keep it.
Now I suggest you go back to the lender and ask to borrow some good manners.

The norm that is defined by those who decide on awards is theirs alone.
You may accept that norm as your norm, but I attach no importance at all to those people's opinions, and I refer to a norm that is based far wider - on a knowledge of the way in which the products of Hollywood are regarded in the real, wide, world.
But now we come to what you're really talking about - the "gross", which you apparently equate with the "norm" - correct me if I've misunderstood the quotation above.
You are using the word "gross" in its secondary meaning: gross monetary income? If so, we are certainly back to matters that can be quantified, but they're not the matters I think about when I hear and use the word "norm".
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
The norm that is defined by those who decide on awards is theirs alone.
You may accept that norm as your norm, but I attach no importance at all to those people's opinions, and refer to a norm that is based far wider - on a knowledge of the way in which the products of Hollywood are regarded in the real, wide, world. (emphasis added)
But now we come to what you're really talking about - the "gross", which you apparently equate with the "norm" - correct me if I've misunderstood the quotation above.
You are using the word "gross" in its secondary meaning: gross monetary income? If so, we are certainly back to matters that can be quantified, but they're not the matters I think about when I hear and use the word "norm".
I guess hubris is catching. Now you know what the "real, wide, world" considers the "Hollywood norm". Would you care to enlighten the rest of us as to where you gained this knowledge? Do you have some scientifically conducted polls to cite?

I am not responsible for what you think when you hear something. If you would like the rest of us to know what it is you think you should tell us in a way that does not masquerade your opinions as global opinions.
 
Last edited:
I certainly do think there's a generally accepted concept worldwide as to what the "Hollywood norm" for films is. It's not something that I've devised; it's something that I see expressed in all areas of the media.
It's nothing to do with anything that polls could establish.
Do you have an idea of what the "Hollywood norm" is? If you have, then is it "hubris" for you to regard your idea of it as the Hollywood norm"?
If that norm, or any other you have, involves the "gross", it's not the one I'm referring to.
Your comment: "I am not responsible for what you think when you hear something" has lost me. What's it about?
 
joxy said:
I certainly do think there's a generally accepted concept worldwide as to what the "Hollywood norm" for films is. It's not something that I've devised; it's something that I see expressed in all areas of the media.
Well, please enlighten the rest of us what this "generally accepted concept worldwide" is? Also please explain how you know that the "norm" you perceive is the same everyoen else means.

BTW, it is not rude to say that I think something is the most absurd statement I have seen on the forum.
 
Greenwood, you've got it in the wrong order. I didn't perceive the norm for myself and then look around to see whether the rest of the world sees the same norm. I looked around first, saw what the norm out in the wide real world is, and began to understand it, and then to agree with it.
It isn't something that can be defined, or even described in any detail; it's something that exists and that people widely accept.

I didn't say anything about you being rude. I suggested that the comment you made was lacking in good manners.
 
Greenwood said:
Aragil, and to a lesser extent I, have shown that the movie version does follow the book fairly closely except in relatively minor points.

You have shown that the movie follows the book in the sense of getting from point A to point B. The Rohirrim charge...yada, yada, yada....Theoden dies....yada, yada, yada...Aragorn arrives...yada, yada, yada...they win the day.

Greenwood said:
Admittedly, it is possible for such a short passage to be that important, but as exciting as this scene is I don't see it rising to that level of importance. There is a about to be a confrontation between two powerful characters in the book and it doesn't happen. You argue the fact confrontation doesn't happen makes the scene that much more important. I don't buy it.

Actually, Tolkien himself argued it. Again, look at Letter #156: "He alone is left to forbid the entrance of the Lord of the Nazgul to Minas Tirith, when the City has been overthrown and its Gates destroyed -- and yet so powerful is the whole train of human resistance, that he himself has kindled and organized, that in fact no battle between the two occurs: it passes to other mortal hands."

As you then go on to say, it is indeed in keeping with the veiling of Gandalf's power. But it is not simply a matter of leaving it in the hands of mortals--the small and the weak. It is by his hand that the resistance has been kindled and organized. He is the one who is meant to guide Frodo. He does, as Tolkien states in this same letter, operate through others. And he is so succesful in kindling and organizing the resistance that the confrontation between himself and the Witch-king--the climactic moment in the siege of Minas Tirith--does not become an explicit battle.

Tolkien goes on to state: "He was sent by a mere prudent plan of the angelic Valar or governors; but Authority had taken up this plan and enlarged it, at the moment of its failure."

The moment at the Gate of Minas Tirith, then, takes up prominent importance within the tale, at least as regards the defense of Gondor (which does represent the bulwark against the power of Mordor). It is the moment in which the reader believes all is lost: the Gate crumbles, the Lord of the Nazgul rides through that archway, the armies of Mordor are poised to surge into the City. It is the moment at which the West is at its nadir. It is the moment in which that train of human resistance which Gandalf (sent by Iluvatar) has set into motion proves utterly indomitable.

And it is a moment which is absent from Jackson's movie. Since Tolkien repeatedly mentioned that this moment moved him deeply and placed great importance on it, one has to wonder why Jackson would not include it, if not to alter the themes of the original.
 
rs691919 said:
You have shown that the movie follows the book in the sense of getting from point A to point B. The Rohirrim charge...yada, yada, yada....Theoden dies....yada, yada, yada...Aragorn arrives...yada, yada, yada...they win the day.

The moment at the Gate of Minas Tirith, then, takes up prominent importance within the tale, at least as regards the defense of Gondor (which does represent the bulwark against the power of Mordor). It is the moment in which the reader believes all is lost: the Gate crumbles, the Lord of the Nazgul rides through that archway, the armies of Mordor are poised to surge into the City. It is the moment at which the West is at its nadir. It is the moment in which that train of human resistance which Gandalf (sent by Iluvatar) has set into motion proves utterly indomitable.
You can yada, yada, yada all you want. The facts remain the story line is all there in the movie. The Gate crumbles, all appears lost but the West triumphs. And it triumphs through the same sequence of events as in the book, even if small details are telescoped or changed.
 
Greenwood said:
You can yada, yada, yada all you want. The facts remain the story line is all there in the movie. The Gate crumbles, all appears lost but the West triumphs. And it triumphs through the same sequence of events as in the book, even if small details are telescoped or changed.

Again, the movie moves from point A to point B. How it arrives there is different, and no matter how "minor" those differences are (or appear to be), they profoundly alter the portrayal of the themes contained within Tolkien's writing of this episode--a moment which Tolkien himself considered among the most moving and most important.

No one seems to argue that the confrontation at the Gate and the charge of the Rohirrim don't work "cinematically". There appears to be plenty of "dramatic tension" and "dramatic reversals"--terms which Boyens and Walsh are fond of using. So again, why would these three brilliant writers alter this scene if they didn't want to alter the thematic focus of the episode?
 
Last edited:
I have just been looking back at the statement I made, on which your comment was "This is one of the most absurd statements I have ever seen on this forum".

When I suggested that your comment was ill-mannered, you replied that "it is not rude to say that I think something is the most absurd statement I have seen on the forum", though I had said nothing about it being rude.

My original statement was "Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence"; it can be no more than a matter of opinion."

Unless you were referring to a monetary norm, which I wasn't, would you now expand on what was so absurd about what I said, and then suggest what forms of evidence might be provided towards deciding "whether the films exceed any norm".
"Oscars" is not the answer. :rolleyes:
 
Joxy,

It continues to be one of the most absurd statements I have seen on TTF.

joxy said:
Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
"Exceed any norm"? The fact that ROTK is the first film in the 76 (?) year history of the Academy Awards to sweep 11 categories plus all the other awards the films received prove they exceed the norm of such things for films. The fact that these three films are three out of the top ten films of all time in box-office gross receipts prove they exceed the norm of box-office success for films. These are all objective pieces of evidence. You say that these are not the "norms" you are referring to. The problem is you made a sweeping statement that there could be no "evidence" of the films exceeding any norm. You did not specify that you were referring to some nebulous "norm" that is only defined in your own mind. Of course no one can say anything about the norm in your head because we can't know what it is.
 
Regarding joxy's quote:

Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.

My first reaction was this: :confused: :eek: :p :D

Thinking about it though, how's this for evidence?

HABEAS CORPUS

PJ's films indubitably exceed the norm when it comes to the number of cast members from a single film or trilogy of films all going out and getting Elvish tattoos! :)

* takes a bow *
 
Greenwood said:
ROTK is the first film in the 76 (?) year history of the Academy Awards to sweep 11 categories

Actually, ROTK ties with 2 other films for 11 categories - Ben Hur and Titanic. :)

I certainly don't want to offend anyone who found Titanic to be one of the best movies of all time - but in my opinion, it stank. The breakup of the boat was cool, but the story and the dialogue was horrid.

Just trying to make the point that box office and awards aren't everything. And that I really hated Titanic. :p
 
simbelmyne- I agree with you about Titanic, and I believe Greenwood does as well. However, what Greenwood said about the awards is "to sweep 11 categories plus all the other awards the films received". Both Ben Hur and Titanic were nominated for 13 awards, but each was twice snubbed, while RotK won them all. The Last Emperor also won all the awards it was nominated for, but it was only nominated for ~5. So RotK not only exceeds the norm when measured by Oscars, it establishes precedent.

And, not that I haven't tried this before, but the LotR trilogy is the only set of movies I know that exceed on four quite different measures of quality: box office, academy awards, critics reviews, and IMDb rankings. While not entirely independent, each of these different measures represents what a different group thought of the movies. Pleasing any of these groups is difficult (box office probably being the least difficult), but pleasing all four simultaneously is unheard of- I can't think of any other movie which has done so in the last 50+ years. That is what I call exceeding the norm, though I think there's still nothing that beats good old fashioned, subjective, "In my opinion" it was really good.
 
simbelmyne,

Aragil has correctly pointed out that I was referring to a sweep (winning all that is was possible to win) of its nominations. I am aware ROTK is not the first film to win 11 Oscars. (In regards to Titanic, I expect I would agree with you if I ever watched the film. I am a bit of a Titanic buff having read a number of books and articles about it. When I first saw a preview for the film, my reaction was: "This looks like a load of ****." I made the decision then, and it was only reinforced by reviews I read, that I had no interest in seeing the film and I never have,)

My point all along has been that it is not possible to make sweeping statements such as: "These films do not exceed any norms." Since there are lots of "norms" that they can easily be shown to exceed. That is not an argument that any individual person must like them or is wrong if they don't like them. "Liking" is a matter of individual taste.
 
I, personally, don't see a huge difference in winning 11 awards and being nominated for 13 and winning 11. If anything, it would seems the academy was heaping more praise on Titanic by nominating in in more areas. Plus the fact that PJ's first two movies were nominated and did not win. Does this mean FOTR and TTT were "snubbed"?

I agree that PJ's movies exceed the norm in some ways, but not in others. FOTR, especially, raised the bar in what was possible for a big budget action movie. Unfortunately, IMO, PJ subsequently lowered it again in the last 2 with bad characterization, cheesy dialogue and a plot that in many ways made no sense. Yet in substantial ways even the last two exceeded the norm.

As far as PJ's movies exceeding in four measures of "quality", I again point to Titanic. It was one of the highest-grossing movies of its time and it was nominated for 13 Oscars. AND IT WAS A BAD MOVIE. As to reviews, I read plenty that praised it to the skies - and some that didn't. I've also read several reviews that do not praise PJ to the skies. Critical reviews vary to the extreme. I'm not sure what IMDb ratings are, so I can't comment. :)

I think the only real test for a movie's quality is the test of time. And PJ's movies have yet to face it. So until then I'll stick to my opinion and yours.
 
Greenwood said:
It continues to be one of the most absurd statements I have seen on TTF.
So now your ill-mannered statement depends on emphasising a three letter word, "any".
Obviously, if there are to be a whole range of different norms, then some of them may be subject to establishment by evidence, and I should have omitted the word "any". However, I have not been talking about that range of norms.
One of that range could indeed be the norm of prize-winners, which I specifically excluded, though you choose to give it another three lines, of "evidence".
Another could be the income, the "gross" as I've seen it called, but again that was not the one I was referring to,
and it is also not one that fits a normal definition of the word "norm".
Then Aragil has given us as members of the range "critics' reviews" and "IMDb rankings". Again I don't see these fitting in with a conventional definition of "norm", but I have often said how much value I attach to reviews, and I've never heard of "IMDb"!
You insist also on these references to this being something personal to me. Again I have specifically said that is not the case.
I saw the norm first and accepted it, not the other way around.
I'm talking about the "Hollywood norm" that corresponds to the "Italian norm", the "French norm", even the "Bollywood norm".
Those are concepts that are known world-wide, and don't need me or anyone else to define them, or to provide "evidence"
for the extent to which any film in any of them is superior, equal, or inferior, to them.

As this has turned into an attempt to define the word "norm", rather than to attempt to decide PJ's place in relation to whatever "norm" is chosen from the range, it's almost too late for me to give my "ranking", but I'll do it anyway!
Against the norm that I have referred to consistently I place them - for what it's worth, probably nothing, to certain people -
for the most part on a level with the norm, with occasional outbursts of brilliance that raise them well above it, and with more but briefer spluttering squibs that drag them down below it.
As always, they're a mixed bag, a <what was that expression about a cleric's breakfast?!>
 
Gandalf The Grey said:
PJ's films indubitably exceed the norm when it comes to the number of cast members from a single film or trilogy of films all going out and getting Elvish tattoos!
Which immediately goes to the top of my list of the disagreeable features of the films!
They rank pretty high too in the norm of "films with the noisiest music"; and no doubt we could come up with as many members of the range of "norms" as there are members of the range of Gimli jokes.
 

Today's events

Back
Top