PJ was at helms deep.

[gilgalad]

I think the fact that most people didn't even notice this error is a pretty reliable gauge of its magnitude. Then again, the nit-pickers will nit-pick, won't they.

 

[Ariana Undomiel]

Of course, this mistake is completely overshadowed by his whole ridiculous idea of having Arwen there in the first place - then to take her out again. How much of his $300million did that waste?!

Joxy, must you be so antagonistic? Why don't you just be quiet and stop complaining until after you have walked a mile in PJ's shoes. No director in history has ever tried to do what he did. And besides the mistakes, his has done a note worthy job.

- Ariana

 

[gilgalad]

Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
Joxy, must you be so antagonistic? Why don't you just be quiet and stop complaining until after you have walked a mile in PJ's shoes. No director in history has ever tried to do what he did. And besides the mistakes, his has done a note worthy job.

- Ariana

Well said.